Software
Houzz Logo Print
malcomroad

Need help trying to get the "perfect" front door paint color

10 years ago


Little Red Brick Ranch - curb appeal · More Info

Our new home, a "fixer upper" is a small late 70's
ranch. We want to keep the original style; but add a touch of a "cottage"
look for warmth and charm. The front door is a new oak door. I have
always been a "red" front door person; but am thinking of getting
braver and considering teals or blues. We will be making changes to front
of house and yard; adding small front porch with overhead and one or two benches on either
side of the door, updating windows (with or without grids(??), new shutters
(that's a whole other issue (lol)), and more beds, etc... The
brick is a red/orange with charcoal gray in it; grout is sort of a greige, roof
is charcoal gray. Any help/suggestions you can give would be appreciated.
Below is a better shot of the door (I have tons of others) and the pain
chips in both shots are just thoughts. Can’t tell you how much I
would appreciate your ideas.

Little Red Brick Ranch - curb appeal · More Info

Little Red Brick Ranch - curb appeal · More Info

Comments (41)

  • 10 years ago

    I really love a teal colored door right now. I'm doing my house in gray and really want one!

    malcomroad thanked April Sorrow
  • 10 years ago

    Cute house and front door! I love the idea of a teal/blue color. Of the ones you posted, I really like the deeper, warmer color (top right). I think it will pop, but not look out of place. Good luck!

    malcomroad thanked Laura Perek
  • 10 years ago
    The choice of door color could be driven by what's inside. I prefer a door that's painted the same on both sides. If you feel that way, go with a color that relates to your pops of color inside that you might see when door is opened. Even if you don't choose to paint the same color both sides, this is a good strategy. A house is for those living inside, rather than for the world-view.
    malcomroad thanked Katie Truax
  • 10 years ago
    An all-black door could also be nice, since you have black shutters and some trim.
    malcomroad thanked Katie Truax
  • 10 years ago
    I once painted my door in Venezuelan Sea by BM. It's a gorgeous teal--more green, perhaps, than the colors you've shown--that goes beautifully with brick. I loved it! Then I painted it in something else, and then something else, and then...yeah, I'm a serial door painter. But the inside of the door has remained Venezuelan Sea because it's 100% right for my interior. Anyway, that doesn't actually answer your question, so before I wander off again, let me just say that of the colors you've posted, I'd go with the richest teal. You won't be sorry.
    malcomroad thanked Liz H
  • 10 years ago
    Pssst! But I also love that stunning blue on the bottom left.
    malcomroad thanked Liz H
  • 10 years ago

    All those colors seem really bright for the brick. Tone down the intensity. Go for a contrasting color which would be a sage green or dusty aqua. The door doesn't need to jump out at you.



    malcomroad thanked leelee
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Little Red Brick Ranch - curb appeal · More Info

    Wow! It was so exciting to come home and find all these great responses! I was very happy (and surprised) to see that most of you were leaning towards Teal. I had considered the idea of Black and am still considering some kind of green. I really thank all of you for your great thoughts and suggestions. While I was out, I went to Lowe's and got another sample (I think this stuff is addicting). This one is Sherwin Williams Intense Teal. Would love your thoughts on it and any other color suggestions you have. This weekend I will probably begin to paint sample boards...very exciting!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Were it my house, I would remove the shutters; paint the paneling black and the front door, black, as well.

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    In terms of fashion, I chose the teal on my house in 2009, before I moved in in 2010. The fashion been going for a few years. New fashion coming in is dark green, and olive green.

    Anyway, you can always repaint. Painting doors is a chore, though.

  • 10 years ago

    Hi Judy, This would be a BOLD step for me to paint the door black and the panels black. If anybody can photoshop, it might be fun to see how it would look! The pictures I posted above of the new color are not correct. I will repost.

  • 10 years ago

    Totally agree with Judy. The black would also look great with your roof...very nice!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Chloebud...you see what I see.

  • 10 years ago
    Good morning all - again thank you all for your great comments and suggestions. I know the
    Black door w/black shutters would look great - but might be a little out of current comfort zone. Here are the correct pictures of the newest color - SW Intense Blue. Thoughts??? I did see a green on Pinterest that I liked. Will try to find
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I can't find a picture of windows with paneling and I can't photo shop, but this is close...will keep looking.


    Rocky Ledge Exterior · More Info

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • 10 years ago
    Thanks Judy - I wonder what that style of window (with apron/panel) is called. I see the look on several old banks in town and a very few homes.
  • 10 years ago

    Love this picture! And, yes indeed, window boxes are exactly
    what I am thinking of for the windows (next project after door)! If I
    keep any shutters, it will just be on the two windows to the right of the door.
    Shutters will be “architecturally correct” (i.e. large enough to close)
    and with full hardware. Not sure of the style of shutter (i.e. louvers,
    board and batten, or panel); not sure of the length (all the way to the bottom,
    or be different and stop them at the window and add beautiful window boxes below).
    See picture of my current window. Below, I have also posted picture found
    on Pinterest of another door color Behr Ultra Verdant Forest - more
    green in this color. Brick appears to be similar color to mine. Foundation planting will be changed (another project) although I do love the knockout roses.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I, too, wondered what it is called. Apron seems to be the only term I could find.

    Wondering...what is under it? Is it just decoration?

  • 10 years ago

    I'm not sure what's under it; think I will go check. Wish it were brick; but bet it is studs or plywood or something....

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    It looks like applied wainscoting, but it seems recessed. I was hoping you could take it off.

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    LOL, so I am looking for pictures which could relate to your house and look what popped up on Pintrest.

    Your house looks so different with a full view.

    We have to rethink. Maybe trib and chloe will come back in to take another look.

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    The bay window area (one the garage door?) Those muntins are white, but other three windows are black. Think all black muntins. I am a stickler for appropriate shutters, but in this case what if one pair of black shutters is cut down to fit the the bay window? Now black balances with the three other black windows (no shutters)?

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    01 - Italianate Front Exterior · More Info
    Or no shutters: all windows black; front door black and the panels are painted the color of the brick...leaving the white frame around the red?

    There is a Ben Moore color called Somerville Red. It might work for the wainscoting.

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • 10 years ago

    Can you all access my Ideabook on Houzz or do I have to give you some sort of permission (which I would gladly do; just don't know how yet)? I have a bunch of pictures posted with where I "think" I am going with this Curb Appeal project; all subject to change; but it might help give you a fuller idea....

  • 10 years ago

    Judy - you are messing with my mojo (lol) - I think I like those suggestions...but I would have to be so brave!!! When I go out I will get a paint chip for that color. I think my husband would like that suggestion - he is struggling with the teal. So what color are you saving you think we should paint the entire Bay Window; and are you saying the only window that would have shutters would be the Bay Window and shutters would be Black with the mullions Black????

  • 10 years ago


    Little Red Brick Ranch - curb appeal · More Info
    This is a fairly current picture, showing shutters off of front window. We will be adding a small front entry porch with peaked roof and benches. We want to "beef up windows (all windows will be new) and thus we will trim out front window, bay window and front door. If we do not use shutters at all we will, of course, trim out the windows to the right of door.

  • 10 years ago
    It's a beautiful door, but the colour just disappears into the brick colour. Be adventurous. Giving the living room shutters would help continue the line.
    malcomroad thanked jbtanyderi
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Brucewood · More Info
    This house is pretty much the idea...except for that shutter....


    Brucewood · More Info

    So, in this picture the garage section is your white bay. You paint the windows black.

    When I do a close up of your other windows, the skinny trim is white...I think that should be painted black; front door black.

    What if you did all that and then see if the wainscoting should be black, as well.

    Also, save one pair of shutters, because they may be an important last touch of black on the white bay.

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Something to listen to while you are painting...

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96bQT9u3Gyc

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • 10 years ago

    jbtanyderi - Thank you, glad you like the door, it's really kind of special - we had one very simlar to it in a house we lived in in Atlanta, our daughter got us this one as a gift. JudyG Designs; very funny (music was actually great!) - might help me get my mojo back!!!

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Paul Butterfield Band...from the 60's great music! Love the album cover...big guy in the middle...Sam Lay, the drummer, is wearing gold lame boots...

    malcomroad thanked JudyG Designs
  • 10 years ago

    Wow, Judy, good work finding the Pinterest pic! I like your suggestions on the Brucewood house.


    malcomroad, I hope you seriously consider the black which can be so classic with brick. I like the idea of some white incorporated into the mix. However, maybe not the downspouts...they need to blend more with the brick.


    Is that cute black dog yours? Looks great with the house!

  • 10 years ago
    We also have "aprons" under our window. We updated our home last summer. Our aprons looked like yours. This is how we changed them up.
  • 10 years ago
    And we chose a yellow toned color for our door with red brick.
  • 10 years ago

    The intense blue may be too bright. Someone once told me to lean toward colors with some black in the base, rather than white - I think that's a shade, rather than a tone. That will keep you in the color family you want without getting garish.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    kellykins1 - this looks amazing the way you have dealt with the "apron" and paired it with a very interesting door color! Did you redo the panels on the apron or were they the existing ones? JudyG Designs - Somerville red color may be on the right track (or one that is specific to matching my brick) and then proceed with using it as a trim. Now to find a complimentary door color; Intense Teal is nixed; I can't bring myself to go with black; and we have (in our past) use a ton of Green (which I loved for the homes we used it on), but I wanted to branch out a little. We will be adding a small porch and trimming the door out substantially. I will try to post a picture of what we are thinking about. I am not pleased with the front of the house and want to add interest and I think changing roof line to add a porch would do that. We will be moving the driveway and eliminating cement - that will all be yard.

  • 10 years ago
    We redid the aprons. They were wood painted white with moldings identical to yours. We redid them with gentek aluminum in sable color. I was unsure about having them done in aluminum but was very happy with the way they turned out.
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    kelly..perfect visuals for malcomroad. Chloe? What are your thoughts?

  • 10 years ago
    Bottom left.
    malcomroad thanked Cheryl DeWitt
  • 10 years ago

    I am going back to the drawing board with my color thoughts and some of my design styles (isn't this what this great place to share is all about :)); Kelly's great visuals, along with all of your suggestions, is helping me redefine my thinking.