I think the smaller, as the copperish legs look good with the brown chair, and all the metal legs dont have to match.

It depends on where you are using it. The larger table looks better in the corner between the sofa and chair, but the smaller one is better at the other end of the sofa where the walkway into the seating area is.

much prefer the look and height of the shorter one. you could even get 2 of those.

Larger one in corner of the sofa n chair

I like large one for proportions and size of top and of course legs so nice. Small one for color. I have same colors going on in my home, wood looking tile, gray walls and here is my computer table

Large one between sofa and chair. Small one between the two separate chairs.

I also suggest the larger one since it has a bigger table top and is sturdier, which will be much safer than the other one.

I like the larger one and only have 1 between the chain and sofa. Let us know what you decide!

Would it be bad to have both? I was going to put satellite speakers for my surround sound on them facing towards the sofa.

You can always do a sofa table for the speakers

So would it be ok to have two different one as is or be consistent with two of the same?

You can mix. Put the larger one in the corner with the wall and the smaller one in the open corner between sofa and chair

I wouldn't keep both, just one. I would get a more solid look for a second table, if needed. These are too similar to have both, while not matching. Something like this one from Crate and Barrel would be a nice addition to the room as a second side table (if 2 are needed). Right now, if you keep both, all the tables, kitchen chairs, stools and coffee table are the same type of skinny metal leg style. Mix that up a little more with something different like this.

I am going to say "no" to either because they look too white and too spindly. I, like Ann, would prefer to see something more solid. I like her choice and I like this one because there are the colors of the coffee table and the leather chair in the wood...(from my monitor). Just consider the darkness of the coffee table...needs to be balance with a like color, IMO.

Haussmann Mango Wood Merlot End table 15 in D x 20 in High Mocha Oil · More Info

what about this?

Pick the sturdier larger one if you must use a round one.

A square one between two large sofas would look better -- but that's just a matter of personal opinion.

On that outer corner, I'd consider a rectangle table/lamp combo so cord could be run beneath the sofa .

The smaller shorter/lower round table makes me think of a kids table and/or stool -- leaving it clear on top and in an open corner might mean someone sits on it.