I have found a couple that might serve your needs. You will have to compromise a bit, but here they are:

This is very reasonably priced, although with chrome, you might have finish problems down the road. However, this is close to the shape you seek, but with a raised base for a 2 screw application.

Similar but looks like 4 screws. I like this one better than the one you posted. If you have to do 4 screws, this one is more decorative and not so utilitarian. But you may want the utilitarian look?

Close again, but might be a little too modern?

I like the Amerock one best so far. Will keep a eye out.

Flo thank you for all the suggestions - lol I like the last one the best. So the one you like least I like best :). It IS a little modern looking but it's the closest to the RH pull - the squarish design is much more appealing to me than the more rounded. It's funny - as I'm looking at all these I'm realizing that I think one of the other reasons I like the RH is that I like the exposed screws. Maybe because it's just a hair industrial looking or something. At any rate thank you so much - if you see more that you think might work please share, and in the meantime I'll check out the last one.

Could be pricey?

Here are a couple that I found on Build.com. They are available in multiple finishes and sizes. Granted, they don't have the exposed screw, but they do have a similar feel to them.

My reason for my choice was because of what I thought you wanted! lol. There are good options. You might want to go to a local architectural antique supply place. I'll bet you could get close to what you want. Alternatively you could do a mix of pulls! Just depends on what overall look you are going for.

Available in 6 finishes and very '30’s.

http://www.rejuvenation.com/catalog/products/arched-mission-drawer-pull/items/c1013-4-in-pn

http://www.kbhardware.com/Cabinet-Hardware_Cabinet-Pulls_Arch-Pulls/52-901-1775-0/list.aspx?bid=cat

This site has a huge selection and it appears they might have a few to your liking. Personally, I like the Aubrey pull. Don't worry so much about "in the future", if you love them buy them.

I think this is what you want. https://www.knobs.co/artisan-suite-cabinet-pull-b622-3-ab/?gclid=CIXz49qW2dACFYaGaQod6JoFqQ

Artisan Suite Cabinet Pull in Chrome, 1 exposed screw, square shaped.

Look at the LeeValley Hardware website. It takes a bit of persistence to navigate, but worth it in the end.

I have the artisan pulls that Joy posted. They are great! I have them in satin nickel but didn't see that as an option in the link she posted.

Definitely go with your gut that tells you NOT to use the four screws - because you are right - it limits future change (unless you use a "fill" or a pull that covers the holes).

Just for info, chrome requires a fair amount of maintenance simply because little marks from water and hand prints collect and show. I am not saying don't do the chrome, but do know that brushed nickel is more forgiving in this regard. Hands in the kitchen inevitably are wet and sometimes greasy etc., so put that into your decision-making hopper!

Flo is the same true for the polished nickle? I've never had nickle. I really want something polished vs brushed.

Oh but Chrome is sooooo pretty!

@ycity would you be willing to post a picture of the pulls that @Joy posted so I can see them? It's so hard to tell from a catalog what things will look like in real life. I like those the best so far but ouch - that price! Thank you @joy for the suggestion!

Thank you SO MUCH to everyone else who had contributed so far - it is very generous of you to help and I see several options that are worth pursuing!

If you love the chrome -- go for it. Nickel is poor substitute.

So playing around with the SKU number there is another pull likes this one. It sells for $11.70 per pull, but (there is always a but) it comes only in black, antique gold, or iron. SKU is Z622-3-AB. Type it into the search area of the last post that I made. Iron would be the one remotely close to what you want.

If you do not find what you are looking for, you can always custom design a pull to perfectly match your expectations and Knockout Knobs is the place to do it! We create custom 3-D printed knobs, pulls, and hooks to add to all of your cabinetry! You create a design and we create the product. All of our designs can be printed in a variety of metals and finishes. Look at our website to see if we have what you are looking for! Your Passion Your Design Your Hardware