Maybe something lighter.

Various Sized Carrara Grigio Countertop Quartz Slab, 2 cm. · More Info

Various Sized Iced White Countertop Quartz Slab, 3 cm. · More Info

It might make the kitchen seem a little dark & heavy.

Yes I think that is going to make the entire room look dark and heavy. Our cabinets aren't as dark as yours but we went with a lighter granite (Colonial Gold) for more contrast with the cabinets and to keep it from getting too dark.

Kitchen from Hell transforming into Kitchen from Heaven · More Info

Way too dark. Your cabinets have a lot of yellow in them and it will make going with grey very difficult. Best to stick with more beige or cream countertops that are light. Kind of like what you have. That will not clash with the floors, either.

Then you have to decide what to do with your sink. And your faucet. And.......

Once you start, you will have a lot of other decisions to make.

I think changing the knobs and pulls to a brushed nickel would really give you a big bang for your buck in terms of change. Plain , simple style.

Natalie, I like the last one. Light enough to contrast with the cabinets but not so stark. I think you might have a winner there.

Here's a quick look at that counter on your cabinets.

I don't think it is yellow enough for your tile floor. Especially based on Kevin's photo.

Here is the Cambria website and some suggestions:

Berkley, Bradshaw, Brecon Brown, Brown Hill, Buckingham, Canterbury, Cowswell Cream are a few that I think you should consider. MAYBE Aragon or Bellingham. These were just a few off the top.

https://www.cambriausa.com/Designs/design-palette/

Natalie, I don't think it is yellow enough. In your picture, see how it does not blend with the flooring?

Besides, pretty good is not good enough!! You want something that knocks your socks off!!!

The photos of your floor are all over the map, colorwise, on my monitor. On some they look yellow but they look pinkish grey in the photo with the dark samples. So, I'm confused.

@barncatz I'm confused too! Our floors pull so many different colors depending on the light and what's around them. I'm going to have a designer come over and help us so we get this right!

NO to the gray... you have a nice room, clean lines... you need to start with a beautiful backsplash... I would not spend on quartz.... it looks very functional and warm the way it is.

I cannot stand the countertops anymore! When you look closely, they look like crunched up leaves. I also am dreaming of an undermount sink, so something has to change!

I love your cabinets! I think you need to look for something with the same color tone/value as what you have.

An undermount sink is fine, but then you have to worry about chipping the granite/quartz when you wash pots and pans!!

Think about adding under cabinet lighting and painting the plug covers the same as the wall.

Actually, the countertops you have match perfectly. They hide a myriad of spills, stains and oopsies!! I am sorry you don't like them.

Since your floors are warm in tone, I'd pick a warm gray for the counter. A cool, blue tones gray would end up clashing with the floor.