Software
Houzz Logo Print
soobzoobriot

Interior paint "afters." Something is off... help!

9 years ago
Hi everyone! I haven't posted since September, I think, when we purchased our first home. My last question for you all was how to combat all the brown in my kitchen - to, say, ditch the rustic cowboy aesthetic without ruining the beautiful hickory cabs. We're at a pause in the upgrades right now, so we haven't gotten to the backsplash and countertops yet (which will probably be whitish quartz and subway tile) but we did get new stainless appliances, new light fixtures, paint, and rugs.

What do you all think about the blue walls? Honestly, I decided in a pinch because I was a little overexcited. When the paint started to go on, I panicked a little thinking it would be too baby-nursery blue. I was hoping for a tranquil spa feel. The blue doesn't bother me now, but...something is off. It feels kinda floaty or unfinished to me. Plus, it's been a real pain trying to match rugs and artwork to it, so we've got a real mess of 25 different shades of blue going on. We kinda gave up and hung a bunch of black and white stuff.

Please, if you can help explain the missing SOMETHING, I would be so grateful.

Comments (22)

  • 9 years ago

    is missing the right color, too nursery blue

  • 9 years ago

    Mostly, everything else is Way Too Much Brown! Ditch the chocolate curtains and consider painting or replacing coffee table/ottoman and dining chairs, at the very least.

  • 9 years ago

    Yeah, I know what a pain it is, but you should pick one shade of blue/gray for all the rooms.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I will use the word “disparate” to describe your space.

    I would like to tell you some of my reactions. Please do not take any of this as an insult. You have some good things with which to work, but some must go and some must be rearranged.

    It would be difficult to do the entire area at once because your photos don’t give focus to any one space or item.

    Window treatments/rod: change

    Pendants: reposition

    Wall decor: remove/reposition

    Throw pillows: change

    Rug: change

    Quick question: would the living room rug work under the dining table? The one you have now is too small. Easy way to judge is add 3’ all around your table for sizing the rug.

    I think the blue walls will work once you change the counters/backsplash to white.

  • 9 years ago
    The curtains and ottoman are really dark and heavy. I would replace them something lighter, both in color and structure.
  • 9 years ago
    JudyG, the things you listed were mostly pre-existing from all our years of renting. I'd love to change! I'm not sure the living room rug would work under the dining table (honestly I'm waiting for some room in the budget to do an entirely new dining area), as it's a small eat in kitchen space where the pantry and two exterior doors are. I'd hate to see a rug be ruined by all the heavy outdoor traffic- any suggestions?

    As far as the dark curtains, they are actually slate gray. I'd like light ones, with a pattern, but was advised not to have too many patterns AND that they should be dark as to "anchor" the room.
  • PRO
    9 years ago


    LEED Platinum Certified Residence · More Info

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Oh Wah. You're off the rails my dear. I understand the longing to finish an entire floor. Please stop. The cabinetry in kitchen is blurred into to the floor tone. The brown everything in family room and kitchen........not good with ANY blue, and all else is overwhelmingly brown. Save some money, PAY for some serious consultation time with a local design pro to help make you a plan that fits your budget over time and one that you can implement. You're wasting time and money and energy. All of which are yours.

    The goal of any project, paint or otherwise......should not be "it doesn't bother so much anymore" Take a break.....: )

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hmmmm, I don’t know who advised you on dark curtains, so I wouldn’t want to contradict, but I don’t think vertical anything anchors a room.

    A nice pair of light/white (outline of pattern in rug), lined, possible a chunky linen look would be nice.

    These panels are from PBteen and very affordable, plus sale going on now.

  • 9 years ago
    And I absolutely agree with disparate- this being my first home, I have a lot of mismatching stuff and am still trying to figure out my style (without knowing what each style even means)! Ha! When you say change the position of the pendants, what do you mean exactly? The living room fixture is in the center of the room, the pendant over the dining table is swagged from the center (where the existing baby ceiling fan was) to over the dining table. I'm not sure what other options I have! Or is it that you just don't like the spherical pendants for my space?
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Yes, I think too many pendants in one view.

    Could you take a picture of just the dining space? And, like I said there are plenty of things in your home with which to work. For instance, the dining chairs are good. Very versatile in style, but the table makes for too much early American…dark and somber.

  • 9 years ago
    Thank you, Judy! We have those curtains in the master. I will have to get more! Back when we were renting, my husband had to have dark curtains or his eyes would burst into flames or something like that- ;) but now that we know PB Teen makes heavy blackout white ones, he is more willing. Is the rod a problem, too? I was always told that the rod should match the metal in the light fixture, which is rubbed bronze. But that would look funky with white curtains, yeah?
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    So, how about keeping the dining chairs and just buying a new table? And, how about white? Counter tops will be white, so why not work with white for awhile. White counter tops; white table; new white draperies.

    Thinking a round table for the space.

  • 9 years ago

    After studying your pictures, the first thing I would do is change the brown curtains\drapes to white or off-white. Then see what you think. Since you are changing the kitchen counter and back splash, plus dining room won't comment on those...but I am not a blue wall person, I would suggest cream or even light sage green....also I think your over the sink curtain should be higher to cover the whole window....love the style of the light pendant over the sink.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I would change the rod…yeah. I would do my favorite from Pottery Barn in black (living room pendant is going some where else shhhhh.) Can’t see the rod or your windows, hang the rod 3” or so outside window frame an about 3-4” higher than frame.

    My favorite rod:

    I love it because of the way it attaches to wall and the curved rod which allows you to pull the fabric around.

  • 9 years ago

    I am by all means not a designer or even close, but if it were my space I would paint the trim around the window white. Just my humble opinion. ;)

  • 9 years ago
    Awesome. Brenda- FYI, I've already begun painting the trim, so luckily for me, we are on the same page there! Thank you :)
    I'm not sure there is room for a lamp next to the chair - it's a very small room- I think I've done the best I can for now, space wise, with that honkin 119" sofa.

    Okay, so- white drapes, lighter coffee table, bigger (neutral?) rug under dining table. I'm glad to hear these suggestions- it shows me that my thinking is off and/or I've had some not so great advice. The whole house is in progress- but I'd love to be happy during the transition. Thank you!
  • 9 years ago

    I happen to like the blue. :)

    Here's what I would do in the kitchen:

    • Paint window trim white
    • Add crown molding to cabinet tops (and ceiling, if possible)
    • Hang a Roman shade or box-pleated valance above window, close to the ceiling
    • Change out the white floor register to hickory
  • 9 years ago
    Sammy, it had never even occurred to me that I could class up the joint like that. We love crown- I just didn't think a little house like this could rock it. And the hickory register? Never thought of that. Amazing! You guys are a bunch of geniuses, I tell ya. :)
  • 9 years ago
    Judy- I was just telling my husband last week that I'd love a round dining table.

    Oh, and Sammy- thank you! I wouldn't have chosen blue if I didn't like it. And for the commenter above who suggested the same shade of blue throughout- it actually is, if you can believe it. I think it's Tidewater by SW, or something. It's on all the main area walls and down the hallway. Then there is a more denim (SW Marina Park) blue in my master bedroom. Alpaca by SW in the two other bedrooms and hall bath. I have mostly been pleased with my choices - but you know, I'll be sitting on the couch going "what is it about this color that just feels incomplete?" Maybe I should have chosen a deeper, more saturated hue. Maybe that's what's driving me cray.
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    @ Susi

    I hear ya hon. But I'd still get a bit of help : ) The right person can save you a lot of confusion, and help you max your dollars too!!!