Software
Houzz Logo Print
etta_turnerterrell

Beans together? What about cucumber?

9 years ago

Ok I was thinking of doing one 40' row of pole beans. Maybe 10' of 4 different kinds (yard long, purple king etc) I'm sure I can do this but will they cross pollinate? Bot be more septable to desease? Next question: What if I throw a 5 food section with cucumber? Will that be ok too? I want to try so many different verities of pole beans but don't want to go over board as it is only 3 living here but I would like to put up some too. Is 40' enough? Or to much?

Last year I only planted 2 cucumber (people around here said they would take over). But I only got maybe 2 a week if I was lucky. I would like to make a couple jars of pickles just to try my hand in pickling and also have enough to eat fresh atleast 3 days a week or more. (Husband loves cucumber salad!)

i love talking gardening and learning from people that's done it for years! I use to have a lady on here from Meridian MS (close to me) that we would text air talking gardening but I've lost her number. Anyways thanks to all that take time to help me! Digdirt I've learned a lot from you to so thanks for all your help on this site!

Comments (15)

  • 9 years ago

    Sorry to disagree a bit but just as with corn that crosses, with beans it is the seeds themselves you are eating. They just happen to be contained in a pod.

    So yes, cross-pollination can make a difference in bean seed color and flavor. I think I discussed this crossing issue in more detail on a previous post about the many types of beans that I think was your post. Beans are basically self-pollinating but all planted that close together is bound to result in some crossing due to wind and insects. How much of a difference the crossing makes depends on the varieties planted and is a personal taste thing. Some never notice, others swear about it.

    As for disease - that depends on the variety's resistance. But if one type develops one of the common bean diseases the odds are all will when planted that closely.

    Is 40' enough or too much? Depends on if you will be doing some canning and/or freezing or not. We usually do 2 50' rows of beans but we also can quarts of them every year.

    Dave

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I never thought I'd disagree with you, Dave, but I'm gonna have to...the reason cross-pollination affects THIS year's corn is because the part of the corn you eat is mostly the endosperm, and that bit is determined by the pollen that fertilized the seed (the second sperm, in the case of corn, but that's by-the-by, I think.) That's not the case with garden beans, which don't have endosperm once the seed is mature. If you have a bean that doesn't look like the beans from the last generation, it's because cross-pollination happened in that generation, not this one.

    Keep in mind that while you're eating the seed from both, beans and corn are more different than just being a different plant: beans are a eudicot (2 seed leaves), but corn is a monocot (1 seed leaf, e.g. grass, basically.) The seeds from the two are going to be different not just in what grows from them, but also the structure of the seed itself.

    Think about all the different seeds we eat - pumpkin seed, sunflower seed, peas, beans, celery seed, coriander...corn is unique b/c the structure of the seed is different than most of our other garden veggies. (For the record, I don't know if it's unique from other monocots, never having grown them.)

    Personally, I encourage cross-pollination for most things in my garden. I enjoy the surprises, and I feel like when I'm saving seeds from the best fruit/plants, I'm selecting for my garden's particular conditions. Sometimes I get a mutant - I've got a "tomato" this year that's just kind of sad and I don't think it's growing anymore - but that's fairly rare. And I've never had beans CP.

    As an aside, you say you do 100 row feet of beans and can quarts of them - can I ask about how many quarts you get from your 100'? And do you trellis or use teepees, or...? I mostly grow my beans for shelling, as you may have guessed, but I'd like to be able to put up some green beans, too. I'm just not sure how much I should plan for.

  • 9 years ago
    I am doing bush pink eyed purple hull for the 2nd year.... they were amazing and what really got me wanting to try more kinds. I also got black crowder and brown crowder, never tried... is crowder peas the same as cream peas? I want to try one of everything!! When I figure out how many kinds there are lol. So far I've heard of cow peas (pink eye purple hull?) crowder peas (have no idea just heard they were good here to grow a quick crop. Cream peas (want to find one to grow this year... are they bush or pole?) I know i an forgetting something but anyway, I just started last year with the peas/beans so have a lot to learn! I tried to grow some bush last year and they didn't do anything in my raised beds (being a novice gardener I'm still trying to learn what's wrong with these 2 beds)
    What are some of your fav beans? I don't like dry tasting like regulate black eye peas.

    2 rows of 50 foot? Wow what do you plant? I did just 5' row of pink eye purple hull last year just playing around and I fell in love!!!
    This year I'm doing 10 might be 20 after hearing your 100' but I want to try other kinds to. Every year my husband says I spend more money on my gardening and I can't grow anything! This year I'm going to show him!!! Lol

    Thanks for the feed back
  • 9 years ago

    Try some Good Mother Stallards (pole). Super tender and quite tasty. Actually, I've never found a shelling bean I didn't like, except the black beans you find in the store.

    My husband has said the same in the past, mostly 'cause my gardens have been too small to cover their own costs...so I finally broke down and laid out a nice-sized garden for myself. Of course he still complains about the cost, but at least now he can't complain about not getting anything out of it!

    As far as black eyed peas, it's ALL in how you cook them, you can't just throw them in water and go. Here's how I do 'em:

    Soak your peas - around a 3/4 lb, give or take - overnight, drain and rinse as usual.

    In a 12-inch cast iron skillet (that's important,) preferably on the grill with a good smoking wood, fry up three or four strips of good thick-cut bacon until they're done but not too crispy, then remove the bacon and drain on a paper towel.

    Toss a tbsp or two of butter in the pan with the bacon grease, let it melt then add a coarsely chopped up onion and a few chopped cloves of garlic (two or three, depending on preference.) Cook until just soft. Meanwhile, chop/crumble the bacon.

    Add the peas and crumbled bacon to the skillet. Stir a couple minutes to combine all the stuff and start the peas cooking, then pour in room-temp chicken stock until peas are covered by about half an inch. (Don't use cold stock, as if your skillet is quite hot, it can cause thermal shock and crack the skillet.) Cover and cook until peas are tender, adding more stock if necessary to keep just a bit of juice in the pan. Salt and pepper to taste.

    To serve, mound it on the plate with a depression in the middle and drop some butter in to melt, like you would with mashed taters or colcannon. Fresh cracked pepper over the butter makes it even better.

    Excellent with grilled ham steaks, which is convenient, since you can do the steaks over the same fire you do your peas. We have this every year for New Year's at our house. :-)


  • 9 years ago
    Oh wow never used my cast iron for peas! Thanks so much I will print all that first thing in the morning! Lol. I love to cook and always up to try new things or new ways of cooking! Thanks again..
  • 9 years ago

    Ditto. :-) If you try it, just keep in mind that I don't do those off a recipe, and am trying to remember amounts from memory, so take those with a grain of salt and play around with them.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I understand what you are saying Sloan but even with the endosperm out of the taste part of the equation you can still get some different flavor effects just as Provider doesn't taste like Purple King or Blue Lake or Blue lake doesn't taste like Fortex etc. Seed colors and texture can also be affected.

    So the point is that you plant different varieties apart from each other when possible rather than all mixed together. But are we talking green beans or peas here? Many green bean varieties are hybrids, most dried pea varieties are not.

    From 2 50' rows of Fortex pole beans we average about 30 quarts canned and plenty for fresh eating.

    We also grow 50' rows of Mississippi Silver Crowder (bush), Ozark Razorback (bush), and Violet's Butterbean (pole). We dry most all of them on the vine but harvest some for fresh eating.

    Dave

    PS: true "cream peas" are normally cream colored. Try Zipper or Elite

  • 9 years ago

    Ah, I think we might be on different wavelengths 'cause I usually just eat my shelling beans when they're green, if I want green beans...and most shelling bean varieties (at least the ones I grow) are heirlooms. Matter of fact, I don't think I've ever grown a hybrid shelling bean...

    Thanks for the yield info...it sounds like that might be just about the right amount to get us through a year. :-) Now I just have to figure out how to work 100 row feet of green beans into my rotation...you use 6" spacing?

  • 9 years ago

    Interesting. 1. Yard Long are a subspecies of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata subsp. sesquipedalis) they will not cross with common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris)

    2.Cross pollination among P. vulgaris is very small. Self pollinating and not attractive to beans. Closed blossom that has to be cut open.

    3. No hybrid P. vulgaris. For breeding purposes only . too difficult to produce on a commercial scale. Breeders are protected by PVP https://www.ams.usda.gov/services/plant-variety-protection

    4. Cowpea is a generic all purpose term for southern peas (Vigna unguiculata) Includes all the multiple shapes and colors from the tiny rice pea to giant crowders. Not all these cross relatively easy. Newer varieties are usually bush, but old timers can run quite a bit. They don't climb well but will take the opportunity if a suitable support is available. Cornstalks for example.

  • 9 years ago
    I do have some purple king seeds I'm going to try this year... I think they r a pole bean? Also I am talking peas and beans as I don't know which ones are shellies or like green beans... (I told you I'm just starting to learn
  • 9 years ago
    Ok for some reason 1/2 my post didn't go threw??? That was a lot of typing lol. The main part was I do have rattle snakes and asparagus yard longs I planted last year that I snapped and they were great I'm adding purple king, calima bush and six week purple hull... (are these easy growing and good flavor choices?) and the suggestions y'all have made I'm going to start looking into tomorrow, (I order a lot of my seeds online so I get to see reviews)
  • 9 years ago
    Dave can I ask why do you grow so much fortex over the other beans? Flavor or yield or something else ? Are they a snap bean? I love pink eye purple hull for their solid but smooth texture and flavor.
  • 9 years ago

    Sloan how many feet and what do you normally grow? How much does it yield?

  • 9 years ago

    To be honest, I'm not sure how much I'm going to get this year, since I just expanded my garden quite a bit, but this year I've got about 95 row feet (just over 100 plants in a wide row, with 10" spacing all around) planted with pole beans, and 60 row feet (don't actually remember if I did 10" or 12" spacing on those) of bush beans planted. Last year I only got about a quarter pound of shelled beans, all of which was saved for seed, b/c of one dumb mistake (I forgot to not add a bunch of compost to the area of my garden that would have beans) plus a ridiculous windstorm that took out my trellises. I had beautiful, tall, lush plants and very few beans, then they all fell down went boom. :-/ That was with just 16 row feet, though. This year I remembered not to dump a bunch of compost on my legume beds. :-)

    It's a little difficult to guess at yield, though, with no real prior data in this climate (the last time before last year I was able to grow beans was in MO, which is rather different from TX, yes?) It's made worse by the fact that my spacing is more than the standard 4-6". I wasn't able to find a lot of info about growing pole beans in wide rows (double rows, yes, wide rows, not so much) so I decided to err on the side of caution this first year with the new layout. I also remember reading a thread here on GW that talked about pole beans being more filled out and more productive with a little wider spacing - effectively making up for having fewer plants while saving seed - so I'm hoping that will offset the fewer plants thing a bit. We'll see how it goes. (BTW, I'm always experimenting in my garden, so feel free to take all this with a spoonful of salt.)

    As for varieties, my favorite pole varieties have always been Good Mother Stallard and Hidatsa Shield Figure. I also grow Hidatsa Red Beans, 'cause I can't not do red beans of some kind. This year I'm also growing Mayflower beans, and a Italian heirloom variety I've not heard of before called Monachelle di Trevio, which is absolutely gorgeous and supposed to be quite prolific, too. There are probably nearly a dozen more I'd like to try, but I don't want to have too few of any one variety.

    This is my first year growing bush beans for anything other than something for my kids to tend - with limited space, I've always gone for pole beans instead, since they take less real estate. Since I've got the space now, I'm trying some I've been curious about - Jacob's Cattle, Spanish Tolosana, plus a red kidney that's supposed to hold up really well in chili. I've got no idea what to expect in terms of yield on those, but judging by what I'm seeing on the plants, I might get around a gallon of beans unless something takes out the crop. (Completely coincidentally, I promise, the kids are now big enough to handle much more in the garden, and could probably be left to take care of the bush beans themselves. Still. ;-) )

    If you're asking about snap beans, I'm really not the person to ask - I get a little bored with regular snaps, and we eat a lot more shelled beans. I also like the fact that all I have to do for shelling beans is keep the plants alive and weeded until it's time to pull the vines at the end of the season.

    You might be interested to know that I don't separate my beans by variety - actually, I just toss them all in a bowl and whatever I pick up is what goes in the ground. Some years, I'll count out how much I want of different varieties and plant them in series. Sometimes I'll be choosy if I'm coming to the end of a row and I think the row's a little one-sided, but other than that, I pretty much wait to see what I get. It makes shelling beans kind of like opening presents. :-) I've never had any cross-pollination happen. Of course, that also means I don't know which variety of my bush beans has the nice lavender colored flowers, but finding out is half the fun.

Sponsored
River Mill Construction
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Delaware County's Customer Focused General Contractor