Software
Houzz Logo Print
yan_tao

Wrinkly Stem. Rot? Or thirsty?

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

So I have this Moonstone/Graptopetalum amethystinum. Repotted into a gritty mix about 3 days ago. Today I noticed the stem is a bit wrinkly and the bottom leaf has fallen off. Have not watered since I bought this. Which was about a week ago.

Any clue? I didn't immediately water because if this is early rot then I'll just worsen the problem. Although I doubt it is rot since I hadn't watered it, maybe it had already started when I bought it.


Comments (13)

  • 9 years ago

    Then pls. say how can that mix look so wet at the very bottom of the picture? Hard to see it well, but it could be rot on lower stem.

    Yan thanked Karen S. (7b, NYC)
  • 9 years ago

    Just above the soil the stem looks wrinkled and a different colour. I think I see rot there?

    Yan thanked gdinieontarioz5
  • 9 years ago

    @Karen That mix is absolutely bone dry. It's got black grit and various other coloured grit mixed in it accidentally. I don't know what makes it look wet? Could you elaborate?

    @Kara Ah I see. Seems like a lot of the plants I get from this seller is overwatered :/ So Should I cut off and try to propagate it now? Or just try to let it heal and not water it until it actually needs it, like when leaves get wrinkly.

    @gdinieontarioz5 So I should propagate the now?

  • 9 years ago

    I am not there, cannot see and feel the stem, but I would cut it off where the stem is clearly good, and reroot it. It looks like you should take the lowest leaf off to get some space for new roots to form. You can try to propagate that.

    Yan thanked gdinieontarioz5
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I also thought that was glistening wet black soil in the photo, but after Yan said something I looked closer and it's black gravel.

    I agree, the stem looks dark and mushy at the soil line. I'd cut it off ASAP at a firm, green section or the whole plant will be a goner. I've only lost one this way, an E black prince. It went FAST once it started dropping leaves, and it went all the way to the crown. I have many happy babies from its leaves but the original plant is history.

    :) kd

    Yan thanked bunkfree_4a_canada
  • 9 years ago

    @Gdinieontarioz5 @bunkfree Thank you for the advice! I will start the operation asap.

    @bunkfree Ahh I see, no wonder it comes off as wet. I will state that next time I show my mix to avoid confusions like this.

  • 9 years ago

    Update: So I didn't cut the leaves last night and today morning the stem got more wrinkled. And the fallen leaves are all wrinkled. See bottom right of the photo.


    Another angle, top right is the wrinkled leaf.

    Now I'm thinking this is underwatering? I touched the stem, it doesn't feel soft or mushy.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    When a succulent is dehydrated it takes awhile for the plant to go downhill. When a succulent is overly hydrated the plant can go downhill in days. See how quickly your plant has gone south in just a day? Dehydration doesn't work that fast. So I highly doubt your plant is having issues from underwatering.

    Remember when a succulent is over watered it can mimic dehydration. So it can be confusing, but if I was a betting woman I would bet the farm that your plant has been getting too much moisture. I'm not saying you did it. Problems could have started before you bought it.

    Usually rot starts from the roots up. So the plant hasn't been able to properly absorb water for a bit. So the plant may be a little thirsty because it hasn't been able to take in any water for awhile. So people will see their plant is dehydrated and water, but the roots have rotted. This is another reason why plants can look dehydrated while rotting.

    The only thing I could suggest is trying to save the plant by turning it into a cutting. It looks pretty far gone, but it may work. You could also try to propagate the leaves if the stem is too far gone.

    I think what happened here is the plant is over potted. Succulents do not do well when over potted. For this plant size plant I would have potted up in a 2 inch pot. All that extra material in the pot holds onto moisture that the plant does not need. I know a woman who is always overpotting her succulents and her plants never do well. I try to tell her, but she never listens. She never learns:)

    It's all a learning lesson. Just learn from your mistakes and you will have success:). Goodluck:).

  • 9 years ago

    Ah thank you Kara. Now I understand dehydration and rot better. Yeah, I might lose this but its all part of the learning experience. I'll just have to be more careful in the future.

    About over potting, this is the smallest terracotta pot I can find. Didn't want to use plastic pots since they don't dry out as fast, but I guess having less soil also dries out faster. I will get some smaller 2 inch pots.

    Thank you for taking your time to explain this to me. Do greatly appreciate it.

    Cheers!

  • 9 years ago

    You said you just bought the plant? I don't think I have ever bought a plant from a nursery that wasn't over watered :p

    when I buy from big garden stores I always unpot, remove bad roots and rinse remainders, and let the plant sit and dry for a day if I am particularly concerned.

    Unfortunately this pachy is really small, probably wasn't anything you could do.

  • 9 years ago

    Lol Gabby, I am starting to realise that now haha. Either its overwatered or there's mealies. I have a H.retusa that still has mealies despite spraying alcohol. Might need to get hold of some Neem Oil, or I'm just gonna have to keep spraying every 2-3 days.

    Now I'm thinking I should just spend a bit more to buy slightly more mature plants. That way, there is a chance of survival, or I could just go home and propagate them if there roots are not in perfect condition, eliminates bugs and rot problem in one go.

  • 9 years ago

    Oh yeah the older the easier!! Most my succulents are 1-2yrs old and when I finally got a good aged one I was mind blown at how easy it was to keep happy!

    but honestly nothing beats watching them grow, and the satisfaction of being a good plant parent haha.