Software
Houzz Logo Print
rental_camden

help identify mushroom around declining tree

9 years ago


Hi, all, our neighbor has a declining tree , not completely dead, but significantly died back with dead limbs every year. Recently , I noticed some mushroom growing around the root area. Is it a indication of decay or just because this spring is too rainy?

Comments (17)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    StinkHorn muchrooms. Thrive where rotting wood exists underground (dead tree roots). http://www.mushroomexpert.com/phallaceae.html

    rental_camden thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    You may be right gg.

    I just know my yard was devoid of trees when I moved here. They were all destroyed by a tornado. The roots were still present in the ground and about 2 years after the storm, the stink horns appeared in force. Had them for 3 years before they declined. I haven't had them in any of my mulch and I understood from the article in the link I posted, was that it was decaying wood beneath the ground that they thrived on.

    rental_camden thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Very common in wood mulch. In fact, I'd venture to say that's where they appear most often, even in very urban gardens with no sign of any rotting or dead trees or their roots.

    "They grow in damp wood mulch, emerging from a whitish, semi-solid “egg”."

    "Stinkhorn mushrooms grow on rotting organic matter. Remove underground stumps, dead roots and sawdust left from grinding stumps. The fungus also grows on decomposing hardwood mulch,

    "Fortunately, stinkhorn fungi do not cause plant disease, but simply grow as saprophytes, taking their nutrients from dead plant material, such as wood mulch, buried wood debris or rotting roots."

    rental_camden thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 9 years ago

    Well thank you gg for that great explanation.

    Of coarse with a tree that size, if it is declining, there may be some dead parts in the root system, enhancing the culture that those 'stink horns'' just love. :-)

    And to clarify, I didn't emphasize dead roots in an effort to alarm the OP, it was that I understood that underground rotting wood was the primary playground of this fungi. You learn a little everyday! :)

    rental_camden thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    So I should not be over worried about this as an indication of failing root system right? This tree across the border and hanging right on top of our driveway with deadwood emerge every year. We ARE constantly concerned about safety.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, they are not a direct indicator of a rotting or failing root system. However, if you have concerns about the tree and its continued health (or lack of it), then you should call in a certified arborist for a consultation. Look for one that is experienced in tree hazard assessment.

    FWIW, trees with heartwood rots can live and remain in place for years. OTOH, they can fall or break off large sections in even a mild wind storm. Check with an arborist to confirm the status and put your mind at rest :-))

    rental_camden thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 9 years ago

    I agree with the assessment by GG that these particular mushrooms are not an indication of a failing root system. They are feeding on the wood chip mulch.

    But the tree sounds like it's in decline, perhaps a hazard. It should be properly evaluated by an ISA (International Society of Arboriculture) certified arborist who will be able to determine its likely future.

    The die back is what you should be concerned about, not the mushrooms. Good luck getting your neighbor to do something about it!

    rental_camden thanked rhizo_1 (North AL) zone 7
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    vv

  • 9 years ago

    My dear neighbor is reluctant to do anything about the die back. In case anything happens, like property damage or personal injury, will they be liable? I have put them on notice by certified mail, together with arborist's report?

    The mature tree is suffering from construction damage since we are a new development. Most arborist reports mentioned that it is unlikely it will recover. We offered to split the removing cost, but they believe they are in no way responsible for the tree. And anything happens, it is act of God, we should just eat up by ourselves.

  • 9 years ago

    Looks like a pretty sizeable tulip poplar, judging from the bark. Looks very old and like the bark is starting to change at the base, indicating an older tree. A shame, because I love those trees. When it is a clear day, can you share a few photos of the tree's canopy? At the least, I would think that cutting back the dead wood might slow the decline, but I could be wrong in that assumption.

    rental_camden thanked (ryanga7a) Ryan M
  • 9 years ago

    In my county, I am responsible for clean up of any tree that falls on my property. It may be different depending on your situation. A guy posted recently about a similar situation, so you may want to check the most recent few pages of the forum. As an aside, I had a dead tree fall last week, and about 20 feet of it fell over the fence and broke off. I was kind and carried that piece of tree back to my property, but mostly because I want to bury the dead pine next to my lady slipper flowers. And my neighbor is 60 with arthritis and won't be carrying any tree anywhere :)

    rental_camden thanked (ryanga7a) Ryan M
  • 9 years ago

    If it is a poplar, I would be curious to know what its crown looks like. Some poplars can look raggedy in old age but still be healthy.

    rental_camden thanked (ryanga7a) Ryan M
  • 9 years ago

    I have put them on notice by certified mail, together with arborist's report?
    The mature tree is suffering from construction damage since we are a
    new development. Most arborist reports mentioned that it is unlikely it
    will recover. We offered to split the removing cost, but they believe
    they are in no way responsible for the tree.


    ==>>> i dont what more you can do .... have you spoken with a local attorney??


    i am not aware.. how one neighbor can force another to take action ...


    ken

    rental_camden thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 9 years ago

    If the dead branch eventually fall and hurt someone, they are legally liable since they were on notice, that is what my attorney said. I did not bother to spend money sending them attorney letter. Just wait for something to happen, and going after them in court. If it is a medical bill, it is possible they will go bankruptcy because of that.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    As to liability, it seems that if you never notify your neighbor about their dangerous situation, they will get away free if something bad happens. But if they are on notice but choose to do nothing, they may well be responsible legally.

    There is a difference between a healthy tree that you dislike, or a dying/dead tree or limb a normal person/arborist can see it causes possible damage. SO if you have doubt, send written notice, put it on paper trail. Your home insurance/attorney will need that in case of unfortunate.

    reference from attorney website

    https://www.lvglawfirm.com/legal-liability-for-tree-damage-in-maryland-virginia-and-dc/

    http://www.mcmillanmetro.com/articles/encroaching-branches-or-falling-trees-rights-and-liabilities-of-property-ow

  • 9 years ago

    From an insurance standpoint, the neighbor is liable if they were aware the tree was a hazard. Significant dead wood in the crown would likely meet that threshold. ...and their own insurance probably wouldn't pay out when negligence is at play.

    The Act of God outcome is when a tree (or branch) that is reasonably known to be in good health, fails. In that case, the insurance company of the party sustaining damage would payout. So, a branch lands on your garage, your insurance would pay. Different branch lands on the neighbors car, their insurance pays.