Software
Houzz Logo Print
misschocolatecake

Does anyone actually LOVE their honed quartz or quartzite??

I've had shiny quartz in the past (Cambria Newport) and it was maintenance dream. But I sooooo want a honed surface this time, particularly marble, but if I am honest with myself, I am way too OCD to live with it--but I REALLY tried, I took home honed and polished samples and 30 seconds of leaving vinegar on them was enough to make me forget it. Staining was not an issue but the etching, geez now I know what everyone's talking about.

So when I saw the honed quartzes at the stone yard I fell in love. I thought they would be the perfect combo of the organic honed look I want and the ease of quartz. I don't want a faux marble looking quartz though, I am doing a modern, minimalist kitchen (walnut and white) and want a plain WHITE honed counter. (I am not interested in Corian BTW).

However...the comments on here scared me. And my test didn't go so well. The one honed quartz sample I took home was a medium grey, kind of concrete looking. Vinegar had no effect but I left some cherry juice and a strawberry slice on there for a minute and I can't scrub the stain out. Maybe if I used soft scrub gel I could but I don't use it so none on hand to try.

So is there anyone out there who is NOT having problems with their honed quartz? Is it a problem with only the darker colors? Do these issues exist with honed quartzite as well? With all the complaints about honed quartz not being maintenance free like its polished counterpart, why is it being sold?? The woman at the stone yard told me it is just as stain free as polished quartz but clearly she hasn't sold much of it. I REALLY want to have it but worried I'll be deeply regretful if I ignore the nightmare stories on here. Any guidance (AND PICS) appreciated as always :)


Comments (20)

  • 8 years ago

    Based on our nightmare experience with our quartzite: if you're considering honed, be sure you view/inspect a pre-honed slab; i.e., don't trust a fabricator to hone after the fact. Our guy provided us with a honed sample: buttery smooth. What we ended up with in our kitchen was a gritty mess -- nothing like the sample itself. When I asked to see the sample again (I could've sworn it almost had a hint of sheen to it, and wanted to see if perhaps they applied something to the surface), it mysteriously went missing. The fabricator/owner also told me after-the-fact that he didn't have much prior experience with quartzite, being a stone that was fairly new to the scene and just becoming popular. I don't know about quartzite being new to the countertop industry or maybe just new to the Houston area, but I wish I had known ahead of time it was new to HIM! Good luck.

    misschocolatecake thanked javiwa
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    A hot pan pictured sitting on quartz. Not good.


    Trivet, girlfriend.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Joseph, that pan is full of prepped food, not cooked food. We are not crazy :-)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    malabacat, your honed counter is just beautiful. Calm, cool with an organic nature. I want that in white. However, I'm having some real issues with this one sample. I left some olive oil on it for 5 minutes then washed it away and even applied Clorox clean up and the oil spot won't go away. I can see this looking like a terrible mess. Maybe I'll try to find a white sample to abuse. Or get some soft scrub cleaner.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks for the advice, javiwa, I hadn't thought there would be problems with them honing it instead of buying one pre-honed. Did it ever get resolved?

  • 8 years ago

    I really want a 1cm/half inch honed countertop look as attached. Caesarstone doesn't make that thickness and silestone doesn't do honed. They have this "suede" version which isnt as matte as I would like. Is pentelquartz my only option left? Any help would be appreciated!!

    @malabacat Thanks for sharing your honed countertop story..everyone's negative experiences are really putting me off getting it, but yours gave me hope. I am waiting for samples to arrive.


  • 8 years ago

    We have honed Del Mar(e) - variously described as granite, quartzite, and "natural stone" depending on which stone yard you're at. I'm messy as hell when I cook and I haven't hurt it yet.

  • 8 years ago

    misschocolatecake: I'm so sorry that I missed your June 15 post; my day must have gotten sidetracked. I won't bore everyone here with the details yet again, so please find my update [here (scroll to my June 10 posts)[(https://www.houzz.com/discussions/countertop-seam-caulk-or-epoxy-filled-dsvw-vd~3960471). No, it didn't end well.

  • 7 years ago

    Does anyone have any updates about the honed quartz? I was looking at calcatta vicenza in matte ( honed) because when i went to MSI in Norwood, MA, I found that the matte wasn't as busy of a pattern and it was a lighter, more soothing design. After reading these reviews i'm nervous about the honed but I do like it better than polished, and I find that polished is more of an ivory and the matte is more of a white. Please help! I'm meeting tonight with the contractor.

  • 7 years ago

    Melissa, it looks like you've asked this question on several posts this morning. I've had Caesarstone Raw Concrete for about 9 months now. We chose it because it was the right color of gray for our kitchen (beige undertones), and my husband was dead-set on a concrete-look counter. It looks great in our kitchen, and overall I am pleased. I did a ton of research before making the final decision, however, so I knew what I was getting into.

    Here are the cons I've seen firsthand with the matte finish:

    1. The counters feel noticeably more plastic than other quartz counters. They don't feel quite like Corian, but they don't feel as stone-like as you might expect.

    2. The counters show grease, fingerprints, smudges, etc. For me, this was not a big deal. The house before this one had 80-year-old marble counters, and this kitchen had very busy granite before. So I'd lived with a counter that showed everything and a counter that showed nothing. I prefer the former. I use a microfiber cloth to clean it, and it works fine.

    Really, that's it. I am not overly careful with my counters, and we cook quite a bit. I haven't experienced any staining, even when we let something sit overnight. That said, I am a little more vigilant on this counter than I might otherwise be, knowing that there is a somewhat higher probability for staining.

    Here is my kitchen, for what it's worth.

    Sea of Tile Kitchen · More Info

  • 7 years ago

    WOW! that is beautiful!!! Thank you for your input. I've been stressing out because we find out the contractor is coming tonight and i've read so many reviews on here today that the honed quartz is awful but I do like how the design is more subtle on the honed and it's more of a pure white where as the polished looks like an ivory?

  • 7 years ago

    I had Caesarstone Honed Pebble installed in my kitchen (and a bathroom too) over three years ago and I love it. I did not want a polished counter in my kitchen, it was too shiny for me. The matte is so soft and calm looking imo. I also love how my counters feel. The matte finish is so silky and smooth compared to the polished.

    I did a lot of research before I got them, like alerievay1, and my advice would be to read the info from your specific manufacturer as to how to clean your counters, since it will likely differ from their polished counter recommendation.

    And get samples to test. Big ones if possible. It's so much easier to clean a larger sample than a smaller one. I was able to borrow some large samples from a nearby counter shop and the ease of cleaning of these samples compared to the smaller ones I had already gotten was surprising to me. I'd get samples of both honed and polished in the color you like, along with samples of other colors you're not interested in but can use to compare in general.

    I do see fingerprints and smudges, but not that often. Mainly on one side of my island where people tend to lean on it a lot. Those easily wipe away with a wet sponge or dishrag. They aren't glaringly obvious though. They are subtle and only noticeable at certain angles or when the light is just right.

    I do not have an issue with water spots. I have CS raven (polished) in one of my bathrooms and water spots show a lot more than on the honed pebble.

    As for staining, I have no real issues with stains. I was concerned at first since I'd read how honed quartz stained so much more than polished quartz, but relaxed pretty quickly once I realized my counters were super easy to care for. To clarify the staining, I should say that on occasion I've had "stains" not come off right away. We cook a lot of Indian food and sometimes turmeric stains the counters and leaves a bit of color behind. I'll wipe the counters down and all the color doesn't come off right then. It'll be subtle but still there. But by the next day it's gone or goes away the next time I wipe the counters. So I now know not to worry, all "stains" are not permanent. I've seen this a few times w/red wine too but it's rare. And again, the "stain" is never permanent. And I don't use some fancy cleaning method. Usually just a wet sponge. On occasion I spray method cleaner on my sponge or dishrag and wipe with that too. Here's an older picture of my kitchen. Still looks the same :-)


  • 6 years ago

    I have Silestone Lagoon quartz counters honed (suede finish) - have had for 5 years - They show absolutely nothing - fingerprints, stains, scratches - nothing. They clean up easily, and I actually set hot pots on them (I thought this was ok), and have not had any problem with that either. It is so perfect to care for that I am installing the exact same thing in another house now.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I love mine! BUT I'm single with no children. Polished quartz and granite so 2010...I just cannot...

  • 3 years ago

    We were not informed about the difference by our designer ! The honed is so much harder to keep clean , especially newsprint ! we now have to put placemats out to read the newspaper ! We were able to clean it all up with Barkeepers Helper & a microfiber cloth . Get polished , we’re stuck ;-/

  • 3 years ago

    I had Daltile One Quartz counters in the Lincoln white color. These were a honed finish. I had them for five years before selling the condo and absolutely loved them. They never stained, etched, or showed a smudge. Super easy to clean. I miss them and will surely go back to that product if and when I be the chance to choose countertops again.

  • 2 years ago

    My honed frosty carrina is really pretty. I’ve only had it two weeks but no problems whatsoever.

  • 2 years ago

    I have matte countertop in my kitchen. I chose Cambria's Pike's Peak. I have two seams which are nearly invisiable and I haven't had any issues with maintenance. I don't have direct natural sunlight entering my kitchen so I think because of that I don't notice fingerprints. There have been no staining issues.

  • 2 years ago

    I have loads of sunlight and no fingerprints or anything in any lighting.