We are doing a complete kitchen reno. The island we have planned is approx. 9'6" x 5'w with two levels - 45" at 30" (table height) and the remainder at 36". I took the lower dimension from our former dining room table. It is a comfortable size for most uses. We are doing the 2 levels for ease of sitting (in our 60's, so looking ahead), no room for a table AND an island (Hawaii - outside dining) and I am not tall, so for baking, etc the lower level is also functional. Plus - my husband likes to be able to sit down at the table for his breakfast and lunch in the kitchen! An eating ledge around the perimeter of the island definitely wouldn't work for him.

It is soo disappointing to finally see elevations for the space. The island just doesn't have any presence, with the split. So, I am caught between function and appearance. My problem is that I honestly do NOT like the look of a "table" attached to an island. We are putting as much storage beneath it as we can to prevent through sight lines - I had thought that would resolve it. But it still looks like an add-on. I'm pretty sure that normal height chairs are the best way to go, that we need them. But I am truly unhappy with how it all looks. And now I'm even wondering if the upper space will actually be as functional for entertaining as I had hoped.

Most discussions I can find are about counter plus bar height levels on an island. I haven't found much of anything with the split we are doing. Has anyone done it? Are they glad they did? Or are they regretting the choice? Is anyone wishing that they HAD done this? I had thought what we were planning would still have a solid substantial look. Right now, it doesn't. In my heart, I know we need the levels to suit our needs, but I don't like the look one bit. I would appreciate feedback on what anyone else may have experienced.

FYI - we are getting white cabinets with either soapstone or honed granite countertops on the island and perimeter. Is there a change-up there that could bring more substance to the appearance of the island.? Any ideas? Thank you! Any feedback or ideas will be gratefully received.