Houzz Logo Print
forhome0122

Material for Closet Shelves

7 years ago

My trim carpenter is starting next week to build closets, pantry and mudroom in our house. Looking for modern finishes. My carpenter recommended 3/4" Plywood. Is that the best material? Or should i consider 3/4 MDF or Melamine or any other products. Budget is a concern, so looking for economical options. Any feedback is appreciated.

Thank You!

Comments (11)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Why would you reinvent the wheel when there are so many closet systems out there that have parts and hardware necessary to assemble a well-designed closet? Unless you have tons of money, melamine is the way to go because it doesn't have to receive a finish after it's built and easy to clean.

    http://www.easytrack.com/

    http://www.easytrack.com/browse/pantry-organization/

    https://www.walmart.com/ip/Easy-Track-24-W-Closet-Tower

    http://www.simplyneu.com/


    Now they offer LED lights in the rods though it requires electric run to your closet. I would definitely consider the lights. Too hard to tell black from blue sometimes.

    forhome0122 thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Plywood is the strongest option and that's what I'd put in my closet. Just make sure that if it spans a length longer than 30" that it's got a support in the middle.

    forhome0122 thanked Carolina Kitchen & Bath
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    melamine should do the job

    forhome0122 thanked Anthony Perez
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Baltic birch plywood is a good alternative, depending on your other finishes.

    If you decide to go with your carpenter's suggestion, first ask about the alternatives for treating the plywood edges to be sure you like what you're going to get.

    forhome0122 thanked Virgil Carter Fine Art
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The shelf in my closet also is part of the support for my closet bar. The brackets are screwed into the studs and the shelf above. You may not be putting anything heavy ON the shelves, but if your closet rod hangs from it, you'll be putting plenty of stress on it. Melamine won't stand up to that, it's very easy for the screws to strip out of them.

    forhome0122 thanked Carolina Kitchen & Bath
  • 7 years ago

    You guys are awesome! Thank you for all the feedback!

  • 7 years ago

    Plywood installed by even a semi skilled carpenter will look better and last longer than any of the modular options out there. No brainer to me.

    forhome0122 thanked schreibdave
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I think plywood will only look better if it's a high end veneer, has veneered or solid strips on the front edges, and has a durable finish. I have a melamine closet system in my master BR that looks brand new after 15 years. I have high end CVG fir plywood cabinetry in my living room and kitchen, which looks good, but is showing the inevitable wear and scratches here and there.

    forhome0122 thanked kudzu9
  • 7 years ago

    I assumed that the OP's plan was to paint the units. In which case basic $30-$40 sheet plywood from HD and $1 a foot poplar 1x2 trim would be fine. I am a woodworking hobbyist and that's what I used in all the closets in my house. Pick through the stack at HD for clear and straight wood, sand, prime, paint. Looks good and will last forever. If it gets nicked up or looks dated you can repaint. If the plan is to stain and poly the wood ... that does significantly increase the cost of labor and materials. You would need higher quality materials and the carpenter would need to have more skill, spend more time and have better tools. Good luck.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I like the ELFA system from The Container Store. As your needs and wardrobe change you can reconfigure the closet space.