I would find a square or large rectangular tile to match the perimeter countertop. Let the island be the star.

Back painted glass in a silvery color?

We definitely agree with Sina. Choose a white subway tile.

Elegant Restoration and Update - Kitchen · More Info

It is very beautiful. Agree with above...simple, or it will become too busy

i am going against the consensus and saying you can inject some color in the kitchen with the b/s. everything doesn't have to be white or gray.... bring home lots of different samples and see if something strikes you. it doesn't have to be bold and in your face, but a subtle color, would be nice, imo

check out Fireclay tile at least for some color ideas. gray and white are neutrals so really almost anything goes!!

agree: inject something. You do not have a busy island. In fact, it is quite understated. I would put a clean looking herringbone, or chevron across your entire backsplash. Your choice : gloss or plain glazing...your choice: shade of white or multi tonal or slightly grayed white...... your choice: contrasting or matching grout or SLIGHT contrast to grout. With just the one small window, yet good undercabinet lighting, custom hood, you run the risk of TOO plain if you don't inject some detail. Chevron or herringbone would be my goal but select the piece carefully....it would be a beautiful classic look if you find one you like. I know: it's a lot of work....keep going....you're almost there.

I think color would fine, that doesn't go against being simple in my mind. I think by simple, people meant the SHAPE and the layout of the tile. You have two different cabinet colors, two different stones. As of now it is not busy IMO, but i think doing an ornate tile would definitely make the kitchen start leaning towards busy

Looking great!

Beautiful! Can I ask you what the name and color is for the subway tile you chose. Also what color grout you used. I am having the same dilemma for backsplash and my kitchen looks almost identical. I submitted a question on this website but have not had any suggestions yet. Thanks I am going to attach a picture.

Very nice choice for backsplash and truly stunning countertop!

Subway tile looks too small to me.

I think the overall look if perfect.

Thank you. Turned out perfect for what we wanted!

Enjoy it in the best of health!

I think the lightest or darkest color in the island for the back splash, so they relate to each other....and look designed.

Can you tell me what paint color you used in the kitchen. I’m have a very hard time deciding if it should be a gray or beige. ( with the Skara Brae )