Software
Houzz Logo Print
davidr_2002

Gas furnace sizing

7 years ago

It's time for a new hvac system in one of my rentals. I have several bids, most of which are for low end single-stage gas furnaces and 13-14 SEER air conditioners, and most of which are in roughly the same dollar range.

The existing furnace is the house's original from the late 1950s, a Luxaire something-100 (maybe that's SH-100, but it's hard to read the technician's handwriting on my last repair bill). I guess that means 100k BTU maybe?

Most of the bids are for 60k BTU 92-95% furnaces and 70k BTU 80% furnaces.

But I have one dealer who I kind of like, and they're suggesting 80K BTU in either efficiency. They admit that their suggestion is based on the furnace that's in the house now, not on an analysis of the house's heat loss.

The house has an added family room on a slab, so you could argue that the original furnace (if it really is a 100k) was probably already undersized.

The house is a single storey ranch/rambler, with cellar, about 1200 square feet, with not-so-great sidewall insulation (maybe none, except in the addition). It has 6" of fiberglass and another roughly 6" of (probably now settled/packed) cellulose in the attic floor. The windows are the original wood single pane, and only a few have storms.

Does the 80k BTU at 95% make sense for a house like this?

Do you think I should push the dealer to do a real analysis?

Thanks for your thoughts.

Comments (3)