Software
Houzz Logo Print
patti_yohe

Another new GFCI? Why do they keep going out?

6 years ago

6 years ago, we had an electrician install new GFCI plugs in our master bath. We have since replaced them three times. Does anyone have a guess as to what is happening? The first two we replaced started making a buzzing sound every once in a while. The current plug lasted 6 months. It still works, but the green light is off. Should we stop using it? What could be the problem?


Thank you.

Comments (23)

  • 6 years ago

    I've found that high humidity can shorten the life of GFCIs. You might want to consider putting in regular receptacles in the bathroom and have them protected by a GFCI breaker.

    Peke (Patti) thanked kudzu9
  • 6 years ago

    Hi, Wow replaced 3 times in 6 years. I wouldn't think they were all cheap quality. surely one would be OK. I would suggest when you replace the next one you Pig tail it in. You might be using the GFI at full load with the down hill load.

    Good Luck Woodbutcher

    Peke (Patti) thanked woodbutcher_ca
  • 6 years ago

    DO NOT just casually do what Woodbutcher suggests. The "down hill load" may actually require the protection.

    First off, let's get some terminology straight. The things you are referring to are RECEPTACLES not plugs. If you have multiple GFCI receptacles in the same bathroom, I have my doubts about your electrician. It's not necessarily an invalid installation, but it is uncommon and leads me to believe that there may be other issues (notably cascaded GFCI protectors).

    Peke (Patti) thanked Ron Natalie
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Thanks to all. The RECEPTACLES (I will probably call it a plug again because I plug into it. LOL)

    have been replaced twice by the electrician and once by my GC. When the electrician replaced the old ones in my old bathroom, it was only because I wanted white ones. The old ones were still working. He rewired everything back to the circuit breaker box. He has rewired the entire house. Then, he had to replace them because they started buzzing every once in a while. Still worked, but I worried about the buzzing. Two are GFCi and a third must be connected to one of the others because it is a regular receptacle. I have never had to replace receptacles before this house even in a humid location.

    Then, my GC was here, and he switched them out again. Now they are not buzzing, but the light no longer works. The receptacle does not trip and it still works. There is just no light showing.

    Should we stop using them? They buy them from the local electrical and plumbing supply house...not a big box store. Cheap supply? I am tired of paying an electrician every time they quit working. Not their fault, but geez, they need a new supply place.

  • 6 years ago

    If there's no light, that's supposed to mean that the GFCI is tripped. But you're saying that there's still power?

    If you press the 'test' button, does the GFCI trip and lose power?

    Peke (Patti) thanked greg_2015
  • 6 years ago

    I'm inclined to agree with Stax that there is something else going on here besides cheap receptacles...especially with the latest info. Maybe a different electrician can determine if the wiring runs are correctly done.

    Peke (Patti) thanked kudzu9
  • 6 years ago

    And this is kind of irrelevant to the OPs issue, but I just thought I'd correct this:

    Now lets say that you have a 15 amp GFCI on a 20 amp circuit, and you have a hairdryer that is overdrawing the outlet. Same thing. It should trip.


    A GFCI receptacle is NOT an overcurrent protector (like a circuit breaker) so it won't trip if there is an overcurrent event. A GFCI only detects imbalances in the hot/neutral.

    And a '15 amp' GFCI receptacle is allowed to be on a 20 amp circuit. It's rated for 20 amps and the only thing that makes it '15 amps' is that the 'holes' only allow a 15 amp device to be plugged into it.


    (Obviously a GFCI breaker has both the overcurrent and imbalance protection)

    Peke (Patti) thanked greg_2015
  • 6 years ago

    I would call a different electrician and have it checked, it does sound like it could be a wiring problem.

    Peke (Patti) thanked cat_ky
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I just posted pics and none showed up. Maybe they will show up tomorrow.

    Test button on left and larger reset button in center with lights on the right. Looks different than my GFCI in the kitchen. After pushing in the test button, the receptacle quit working and the light came on. When I pressed the reset button, the light went off and my mirror turned back on.


    Downside....it took a couple of years to find an electrician who actually had a license and insurance. The first two years, we went through 2 electricians who would leave after we asked if they were licensed. Never even got paid. Four said they were licensed and even had their number on their trucks. When we checked the numbers, they were not licensed. Those "electricians" left without asking for payment too. Makes me crazy!

  • 6 years ago

    If the test/reset feature works then that receptacle is ok.

    Peke (Patti) thanked elltwo
  • 6 years ago

    Even if the light is gone? This is kitchen one with light on.



    Before pushing test. No light.


  • 6 years ago

    after pushing test, the light comes on, but the mirror is off.


  • 6 years ago

    After pushing reset, the mirror light comes on and the receptacle light goes off. The light was on last week.


  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    It is not universal whether the light comes on when the receptacle is working or when it has tripped. Different brands do if differently. It sounds like your receptacle is working correctly. You can get a GFCI tester at the hardware store if you want to verify it. You plug it into the receptacle and push the button to trip the GFCI. It will also tell you if there is an open ground, or if the hot and neutral wires are reversed.

    This is a case where it would have helped you tremendously if you had just read the instructions that came with the GFCI.

  • 6 years ago

    Note that those plugin three-light testers don't necessarily test the GFCI properly which is why they have their internal test button.

    Peke (Patti) thanked Ron Natalie
  • 6 years ago

    The light looks yellow in the picture. Is it really yellow?

    Then I'd guess that it's working properly. Yellow probably means tripped for that brand. Can you see a brand name anywhere on the receptacle? You could google the brand and see what their lights mean.


    The GFCI receptacles that I'm familiar with have either green (Good), red (something faulty) or no light (tripped).


  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    And just to see if I understand the timeline and when things got replaced:

    (1) During a remodel, electrician rewired and installed two new GFCI receptacles

    (2) Buzzing occurred so electrician replaced BOTH GFCI receptacles or just one?

    (3) Buzzing occurred again so GC replaced BOTH or just one?

    (4) Current day, you think there's an issue purely because of the lights

    If the electrician replaced one GFCI and then the GC replaced the other, then it seems like it could have purely just been a bad batch of GFCI receptacles that the electrician installed initially and now they've been replaced and everything is fine.

  • 6 years ago

    Catbuilder, I would have read the instructions if the electrician had given them to me!


    Ron, thanks. So I guess there is no point in buying one of the testers. I could have sworn the light was on before...I must be mistaken.


    Greg, yes, it showed yellow after I tripped it. I have never seen one that had zero lights when working correctly and have never seen one with two lights. The first replacement happened when I was gone for the day 6 years ago. They were changed while the electrician was rewiring almost my entire house. I think the master bedroom and master bath did not get rewired completely...just new receptacles. Previous owners had dark brown and beige receptacles and I wanted white receptacles. A few years later, the buzzing started. The buzzing sound did not happen continuously. It lasted maybe for 10 seconds then it stopped. Most of the time, I did not hear anything.


    I went back and looked at my old remodeling bills, and I was wrong about the electrician coming a second time for those particular receptacles. He only came one time for the bath receptacles (2 GFCI and 1 regular). My GC was the one that replaced the buzzing receptacles with the 2 light receptacles while I was on vacation. I have no idea which ones he replaced.


    I couldn't see a brand name, but I used my phone to zoom in and took another picture. The receptacle says TEST, TEST MONTHLY, RESET, REPLACE IF BLINKING, and SEE INSTRUCTIONS. After I push TEST, the bottom light turns on and is yellow. When I push RESET, the bottom light comes on and is yellow. The top light does not come on but has a little bit of reflection of the bottom light. Maybe the top light blinks red when it needs replaced.


    Thanks for all of the advice. I will ask my GC when I see him next.


    I will assume the receptacles are working correctly, but I would swear there was a light showing a month ago.



  • 6 years ago

    "those plugin three-light testers don't necessarily test the GFCI properly which is why they have their internal test button."

    I don't know for sure what you mean by "don't necessarily test properly," but I can guess from the way mine works. It's a cheap made-in-Taiwan tester I bought on a whim at the cheap tools place several years ago, and I don't recall that it's ever failed to trip a GFI.

    It tests by simulating a ground fault, causing deliberate leakage from hot to the ground pin through an LED, probably a resistor, maybe a few other components.

    A properly working GFI should trip at 6 milliamps. There's a good reason for that number. Depending on the situation, a 20-30 milliamp shock can cause significant injury, and 100 miliamps can be fatal.

    My gadget generates a 24 milliamp fault, 4 times the spec. So it will pass a GFI that doesn't give the required protection. I wonder how many other pocket testers are similarly optimistic.

  • 6 years ago

    That only works if the GROUND PIN is connected to something outside the circuit that can sink current. There are two conditions that it can't test. So, yes, if it trips it likely means the GFCI is working fine. If it doesn't trip, that doesn't mean the GFCI is working, so that's why there's the test button on the unit itself which bypasses a small current around the sensor in the unit.

    Peke (Patti) thanked Ron Natalie
  • 6 years ago

    The new time line is:

    (1) Replaced for cosmetic reasons

    (2) One or both replaced because of a buzzing sound

    (3) Current day everything sounds fine.


    So now it sounds like there may have been one defective GFCI that was replaced instead of multiple GFCIs getting repeatedly replaced as you initially posted. I think you have nothing to worry about.

    Peke (Patti) thanked greg_2015
  • 6 years ago

    Yes, replaced twice, but the first replacement made the buzzing sounds. Thanks to everyone for their expertise.