In any situation like this, you need to purchase a sample and test in the same lighting in which the wall will be seen. Most cabinetry is preferred to be coated in a satin finish. Gloss is rare as is matte due to both aesthetic and wear issues.

Did you ever find a paint match for Ice White Shaker?

I didn't! This project got pushed a little and I haven't painted mine yet but per this blog post, from yellow brick home I'm going to try the Sherwin William's Extra White with the poly if needed. https://www.yellowbrickhome.com/diy-ready-to-assemble-laundry-cabinets/ I'll keep you posted!

Trying this right now - I think the extra white in satin is pretty close! We tried another white (ultra white) before and it did not match.

Update: the ultra white is CLOSE but not perfect. We are going to bring a piece of the toe kick to Lowe’s today and try to have it paint matched.

Your are my hero!! Thank you for sharing!! :)

You’re welcome! Hope it works well for you too!

Thank you so much for posting an update Kelsey. My contractor completely flaked on my home renovation project and left me up the creek without a paddle. This color information will help me finish up the cabinet fillers nicely. Many thanks!

Sherwin Williams color matched to SW Super White for us

Kelsey, did you brush or spray paint the cabinet trim?

We just brushed it, though we were getting ready to list our house so that played a role in our decision

This is so helpful everyone. I bought the forever mark crayon like gunk kit and the pen broke and the crayon got hard as a rock. Cost me a million dollars through a dealer online. It matched great and is good for small touch ups but I need to do a large area on the top molding. Thank you all so much.

Kelsey what color are
Your kitchen walls? Look a smidgeon darker then mine and I like it.

repose gray

I have just been through the SAME IDENTICAL situation. Using Forevermark Ice White Shaker cabinets. I had read somewhere that it was simply Sherwin-Williams Extra White. So, I took a door to my local **COMERCIAL** Sherwin-Williams store for a digitally scanned color and low and behold the associate said surprisingly, ”looks like it’s just Extra White”. I thought, this is too easy. Can’t be. But it was! The only hiccup was he said it was a Satin sheen. After spending $70/gallon, I realized he was wrong. Tint was dead on but it’s actually a Semi-Gloss sheen.

Sherwin-Williams Extra White Semi-Gloss sheen.. You’re welcome. :)

Thank you. And my experience the other day **was** subjective. He had to guess/estimate thw sheen.

How are your Forevermark cabinets holding up after a few years? Did you paint them because they chipped or peeled?