Which is your house?

The first one shown is, by far, the most attractive.

Good afternoon everyone. We are in the process of painting our 20 year old Spanish Colonial Home and looking to give it a new look. The inspiration house palette we are going for is the first picture in our picture deck. Our existing house color is a Khaki Tone.

The 2nd picture is a home very similar to ours in the neighborhood who painted the body the same white color we chose - "Pueblo White Dunn Edwards."

https://www.dunnedwards.com/colors/browser/det675

Our HOA requires 3 colors in the palette which is a new rule, so we are kinda stumped as to the best place to put what color. We would like to replace the terracotta trim in our neighbors house with more of a deep brown tone that will coordinate with our deep red and brown roof tiles - similar to that of Picture #1 - our inspiration house.

The color we chose for the Brown is called "Chocolate Chunk Dunn Edwards"

https://www.dunnedwards.com/colors/browser/de6070

The last picture we posted shows these color samples (Pueblo White and Chocolate Chunk) painted on our home so we could see them in the daylight. Ignore the light camel color as we are not using that one.

One difference our house has is we have a spanish style stair case in the courtyard unlike our neighbors so would like to make this pop somehow if we could.

Our home has a lot of inset niches. Not as many in the front as in the back which we've attached pictures of.

We also need to mention the colors we use have to have an LRV of >= 10 as the HOA does not want to dark of a color.

Any help with a "current" spanish colonial/santa barbara style exterior paint palette would be appreciated. The only color we are keeping for sure is the body is Pueblo White.

Thank you in advance.

Sorry - forgot to mention we have chosen Rustoleum Oil Rubbed Bronze for the Accent Metal everywhere you see metal (railing, sconces, gate, stair handrail).

Ours is #4 and #6, but pictures #2, #3, #4 are our neighbors house who has the same house as ours (just without the staircase). Yes, the palette of picture #1 is our inspiration.

@soleil72 what color did you end up painting? I myself is looking for a spanish coloe and cant decide on a perfect brown.