Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardenfanatic2003

Dilemma With Plant Vendor - Need Feedback

A few weeks ago I ordered an anthurium from Ecuagenera in Ecuador. When I received the plant, the foliage was beautiful but the roots were mashed tightly into a ball wrapped in very wet sphagnum moss wrapped in plastic and rubberbanded. When I unwrapped the roots, what was obviously at one time a nice root system was now as limp and lifeless as cooked spaghetti noodles.



I was very upset because I paid for a plant, not a cutting that needed to be rooted. I emailed the company owner and the general manager and included the above photo. I never got a response from either one of them.


In the meantime, I told a friend about the situation and he suggested that I contact the Ecuagenera store in Florida. I wasn't aware that there was a store in Florida, so I called and told the manager about the situation. She gave me her email address and I forwarded her the email that I had sent to the Ecuagenera in Ecuador. She said that she would send me a return shipping label so I could return the original anthurium that I received and she would send me another one from her store. I told her I was interested in

having 2 of these anthurium and believed that I might be able to grow new roots on the one in my possession, so could I receive partial credit for the new anthurium. She agreed to that and informed me that the Florida location has higher prices than the Ecuador location so I would need to pay an additional $50.


Earlier today I called her and paid the $50 over the phone. A few hours later I receive a package from UPS and it's another anthurium from ecuagenera! The return address indicated that it came from the manager of the Florida location. There was no note or return shipping label in the box with the new plant. Earlier in the week I had expressed concerns to my friend who lives in Florida that ecuagenera would pack my plant the same way it had before and the roots would be ruined again, so he offered to go pick it up for me since he lives not too far from the store and he would ship it to me himself. The manager of the Florida location was in agreement with that so I know the plant that arrived today is not the plant that I paid $50 for earlier today.


If ecuagenera in Ecuador had communicated with me and told me that they were going to have the Florida location ship me a replacement plant I wouldn't have called the Florida location and paid $50 to get a second plant.


I'm an honest person and I'm in a quandary as to what to do. Of course I want to keep the third plant, so I can't really be objective about the situation.

I'm kind of surprised the Florida store manager didn't recognize my name when she was sending out the same cultivar that I had contacted her about. I'm also annoyed that one person in the company evidently believed that I deserved a replacement plant without any extra cost, but another person in the company made me pay $50 more. I doubt the original anthurium I received would even survive the trip back to Florida. But like I said, I can't be objective because I want to keep that third plant.


Oyyy...Your thoughts??? Thank you,


Deanna

Comments (7)

  • 5 years ago

    I get what you're saying - I once returned a (unexpected) $20 gift certificate that came with an order because I returned the order, and didn't feel right taking the certificate when I hadn't really any longer spent the amount needed to get the certificate.

    But this is what I think. You contacted the proper people and they didn't respond. You had no idea what was going on. You then contacted a secondary person, and did what was asked of you. You got partial credit for a plant that may not make it (which will be your loss if it doesn't), or in other words, THEY got partial PAYMENT for a plant that might not make it. And you paid more for the Florida plant because the Ecuador people didn't respond. So I say, if there is no return label, keep all the plants. The place in Ecuador didn't let you know what they were doing, and if no return label is included, no return is expected. You did what you could to handle the situation, and honestly, in the big picture, they are not going to miss one plant and probably don't want to be bothered with any returns.

    Keep them all and enjoy with a clear conscience!

    :)
    Dee

    gardenfanatic2003 thanked diggerdee zone 6 CT
  • 5 years ago

    Pop mama, I'm not surprised that my story was hard to follow because I was very sleep-deprived when I wrote it, so I apologize for that. They didn't ask me to return the plant and didn't send a return shipping label.


    Dee, what you say makes sense and I'm inclined to agree with you. I'm going to contemplate the situation for a few more days and hopefully some other folks will share their thoughts. I just hope my sleep-deprived, convoluted story isn't too complicated for most people to follow LOL!


    Deanna

  • 5 years ago

    Yes, then I clearly misunderstood this part "They didn't ask me to return the plant and didn't send a return shipping label." If that's the case, then that's the answer. If they haven't asked you to return the original plant, then you are not obligated to do so.

    So what's the issue? Sorry I'm even more confused now.

    You now have two plants right? Or three?

  • 5 years ago

    I currently have two. When I receive the anthurium that my friend in Florida picked up at the Florida store for me, then I'll have three.


    Deanna

  • 5 years ago

    I think she received the first plant and then a replacement plant equalling two plants from Ecuador


    She has now ordered a third plant from Florida. She is paying more for the Florida plant.


    I would keep all of the plants and plant all of the plants. I would take very detailed pictures of all of the plants.


    I would write a thank you but I wish you had informed me reply to Ecuador.


    Also inform the Florida place that you have unexpectedly received a replacement plant from Ecuador but are still interested in the plant you have purchased.

    Or not.


    I don't know if you need to inform her but she may find out on her own that you have received a replacement plant with no extra cost to you.


    If that would bother you and it would me I would inform Florida of what happened.

    gardenfanatic2003 thanked yeonassky
  • 5 years ago

    I'm not sure I would inform the Florida people. They didn't know anything about your correspondence with Ecuador, so I doubt they'll find out about Ecuador sending you a replacement. Not that I would be trying to get one over on them but imo, it was a convoluted, rather customer-unfriendly procedure all along (by which I mean the lack of response from Ecuador and the Florida people not being able to connect your order to Ecuador and making you pay more), and why continue it? They sent a replacement, didn't ask for a return or send a return label, you already had to pay more than you planned because they did not respond, so why should you pay to ship back a half-dead plant that they will just toss anyway?

    Keep your plants (all of them lol!), plant them, enjoy them, and don't worry about it any more!

    :)
    Dee

    P.S. Not sure I would contact Ecuador either, even to thank them. I'd consider the whole transaction complete and finished, and move on!

    gardenfanatic2003 thanked diggerdee zone 6 CT