I'm team white subway tile too! It probably feels like that's what everyone is doing, but if you look at real estate photos, that's not what people are doing and most kitchens don't look so hot with their dated trendy tile from 10 years ago. Go with the white subway and let your counters be the focal point. They'll never look dated and you'll never get tired of them!

I'd love to hear if you made a decision. Any photos?