Please post an image of the full exterior front face of the home. Impossible to advise without knowing style, color, enhancements (brick, etc)....

Split levels can lean contemporary or colonial. Let us know what direction you want to go in.

Can you post images of the doors you are looking at? "Craftsman" can mean many things to many people...

Does it have to be for privacy?

Do you walk in to a foyer or directly in to a room?

privacy yes. walk into a small foyer

I think your current doors style works with your house. I would paint it black to match the shutters.