Software
Houzz Logo Print
5575

Starting search for window & door replacement

4 years ago

I’ve received an Anderson & partial Pella (need contractors quote) window & door quotes. I had them quote black windows interior & exterior. Biggest drive is to replace back window with a slider & possibly replace back door with french door, completely opening up the back wall of the 1325 sf ranch to the back yard & deck. Of course, every change connects to future exterior resurfacing options. I like MCM & don’t really like vinyl siding. So, would love any advice or design suggestions.

Comments (19)

  • 4 years ago

    "I’ve received an Anderson & partial Pella (need contractors quote) window & door quotes"


    Inserts or full framed replacements? First bit of advice I would offer is to forget anything Pella.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Check for a Weather Shield Windows Distr. in your area.

    https://www.weathershield.com/

  • 4 years ago

    Well, they seem more interested than Anderson. They sent some old salesman they pulled out of retirement after someone quit right before my appointment. He was not capable of offering any design options, I received an emailed whole house quote, but never received any follow through.

    Pella guy suggested the french door option for replacing the back door. Anderson could do a rendering from the inside, but left without taking pics, Pella can only do rendering from exterior. I had a brother pass as I was working on this & due to lumber costs it has allowed me time to do more research. I was just looking at our Zillow estimate, $157K at the IL/WI state line. We’re close to paying it off, but want to spread out upgrades, just in case we want to relocate in retirement.

    Your thoughts on another option for manufacturers…?

    We might work our way around the house, starting with the back wall. Every change seems to effect things like exterior siding & other interior doors/trim.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I do not have a lot of knowledge on windows, but I do know the Anderson black windows are very popular around here. As far as a french door is concerned - keep in mind the doors have to have room to swing. So you have to keep space in front of them AND on each side for them to operate. I prefer a slider because of that.

    I am not a fan of vinyl siding either. I do know that Hardie siding is popular too.

    I am going to be doing my house too, so this will be a great thread to follow!

  • 4 years ago

    Howdy! The french would open the same as the current back door (we didn’t want to loose that direct entry to the basement stairway), the other half would be a none opening or stationary section. There would be a very small section of drywall in between the window replacement (nice that it is exact same of a sliding door to preserve square footage in that dining area. It would truly make that whole stretch a wall of glass. Pella guy suggested their wood window clad in black with no muntins, so a very open view to the backyard, staying with a similar black trim (I guess it is back in fashion) & it would stay in the feel of the 1987 home. It’s a hot side of the house as the sun sets, so might consider blinds within the doors. A contractor will be needed as a longer header will be required to support both large doors.

  • 4 years ago

    I have a retired contractor friend who used Pella for years in this area & I consulted with a current construction family member that confirmed Anderson was what they were installing in $3-400K homes in Southern Wisconsin. I don’t want to overspend or put something cheep in either. Should I find a contractor first?

  • 4 years ago

    Up to you but I would for sure. I may even entertain a straight up window dealer who furnishes and installs.

  • 4 years ago

    Andersen is a decent to good product series dependent.

  • 4 years ago

    Black windows are going to affect a lot things in your home. Do you like black windows with the wood trim? Ask a realtor in your area if spending the extra money on black windows is a wise investment.

  • 4 years ago

    I was just doing research on ROI for home improvements. Adding light was a top suggestion, so opening up that wall & a full light front door could cross off a couple of the top suggestions. Changing to black windows leads my thoughts to my hollow core interior doors. They are just tired, no holes, there are ideas for building them up with trim, but I wonder how much I’m capable of. But I also see it would be hundreds to replace & I didn’t see them as an ROI topic. I wonder if a light sanding & refinish are an option, new hinges, new handles…? I’m capable of that. You are correct that every change connects to another feature.
    I’m also finding that a feature item like a sliding door could be a feature & not necessarily match every window. I was trying to suggest a wood trim on a black window after searching for a compromise, but the Pella guy discouraged or questioned the option. What he did suggest was a very low profile trim, similar to what we have. I guess that I really need to make a trip to the Pella showroom to touch some of the options or start looking for some professional design or contractor advice.

  • 4 years ago

    Personally, I would start somewhere other than with Pella but that may just be me......................

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    IMO the best is to find the windows at a supplier who also installs and BTW if MCM is your style french doors do not fit that style but a nice slider does and IMO a lot less hassle as far as taking up space either inside or outside,I agree the black should be a low profile in a house like yours. Are you completely finished with all interior changes ? The reason I ask is I would not be getting new windows until I am finished with any changes inside. I use Andersen often with good resyults but black windows will cost more sso make sure to shop around . I d like the same company that supplies install then no complication with anything that goes wrong.Is the plan to just do replacement or all new ?

  • 4 years ago

    I had to speak with a special division for each, because changing the back window to slider & back door to french door pushed the project out of the replacement commonly advertised divisions. Regarding the style of slider vs french, I was hoping we would be working to achieve a similar frame making them look like unified appearance across that wall. If this can’t be achieved, I would have to rethink that!
    I guess this is another reason to make the trip to the showroom. It was suggested to use the french door there to keep a similar access to the basement staircase that we have now for anything coming in & out of the basement. Anderson has certified installers & Pella was organizing a contractor visit to complete the quote. Also changing back door to french will require electric switches to be moved & of course additional headers, as additional cost. Both companies don’t make doors, so they quoted the doors with the company’s they each use.
    I keep staring at the back wall & wondering if I should consider just replacing the door in the back (same in front) with a full view door & just do a slider to replace the back window as a cost modification. It was 27° yesterday & we opened the front door while the sun was hitting in the morning, the crappy glass/screen full view door was catching most of the cold, but the light flooding in was good for our SAD January souls.
    So, wood would stay true to the home’s architecture & the windows Pella quoted are wood clad in black for the exterior which ended up being a better cost option & Anderson has a ‘special’ formula material for their windows, I think it was called Fibrex. I know that I don’t want a white vinyl window!

  • 4 years ago

    I did some research for Marvin suppliers in the area, maybe I should reach out to them as a third option. Sometimes that is good way to help sort between the first two. They aren’t one of those out there trying to grab you with their replacement advertising!

  • 4 years ago

    I’ve reached out to a local contractor & he recommended Gerkin windows & doors. I’ll post a picture from the local lumber yard. Recession, window style & exterior design has me fearful about moving forward. I’ve pinned a billion exterior ideas, after visiting a local supplier for siding, I left without finding good options & found that there is no design advice, which I’m also uneasy about getting that from the contractor. The contractor said that the window order time was 8 weeks, I’m waiting to hear back from the contractor to schedule a visit to the house to work on window measurements to complete a quote. He said that he felt the quality was great & cost would be lower than Pella & Andersen.

  • 3 years ago

    Here’s some updates. The exterior doors have been painted black. I’m currently sourcing garage door, fascia, soffit & gutters. Feel free to make any design suggestions, as always it’s difficult to find professional design advice.

  • 3 years ago

    Looks great.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Looks great! Love the Blue with the black windows!