Wayfair has two

Why match the vanity finish? Show the bathroom you have please? Add pictures , jpegs below.

I would not do a wood trim so I need context please which is a picture of the space posted here in a comment DO NOT start another post

thanks all.

I am attaching a pic of the vanity area. I want to remove the middle cabinet and replace mirrors

With your black counter, you could go with black mirrors. These are from Target and very reasonably priced.

the counter is brown (Silestone Amazon grey).

Maybe this image of the countertop material renders better: https://mobileimages.lowes.com/productimages/79f17929-04cc-45aa-ab63-ed87687a51f6/04946248.jpg?size=pdhism

Black mirror woudl make it easier, but do no like black, I prefer more ZEN....

The Amazon mirrors come in a dark walnut color too.

@RedRyder. Yes, but wouldn't the lighter one be a better match?

I could not find out what wood grain it actually is (light version)

Here is a pic of one installed:

https://www.wayfair.com/decor-pillows/pdp/joss-main-sherman-rectangle-accent-mirror-w010961476.html?piid=1255537668%2C1274044718

btw. I found out that the mirror at Wayfair is "poplar". I might still give it s try to see if it is close. P.S. price must have gone up...

I ended up getting the Sherman mirror form wayfair in natural. However, it ended up being darker than pictured

vs

https://assets.wfcdn.com/im/38808178/resize-h800-w800%5Ecompr-r85/2546/254641359/Sherman+Wood+Rectangle+Wall+Mirror%2C+36%22+x+20%22%2C+Natural+Rustic.jpg

Will you keep it or return it? The darker color is disappointing.

@RedRyder - return it.

I found this one: Natural beech wood mirror - but it is beech wood. So, it will be lighter than my vanity and not oak.

Else, I have to come up with something different all together.... I just feel black or white framed will stick out.

--> Edit.

I actually received a kate and laurel Valenti " dark brown mirror"

https://www.kateandlaurel.com/products/valenti-rectangle-wall-mirror

but ordered on wayfair:

Joss & Main - Sherman "natrual rustic"

found another one:

https://www.target.com/p/23--x-35--nordlund-framed-decorative-wall-mirror-natural---kate---laurel-all-things-decor--no-aasa/-/A-84147642

However, it is 24" wide which seems a bit much?

My sinks are 19" wide and the space in between is 12.5"

I can't visualize well how it woudl look. I was kind of comfortable having the mirror the same with as the sink. Not sure what a pro's opinion is on this?

Sorry but I don't see how adding two mirrors with radius corners is the right solution.

I think what you currently have is a better fit for the overall appearance of the room.

If you select a 24 x 36 mirror will that be too large?

Medicine cabinet with mirrored front

@BeverlyFLADeziner thank you for the rendering.

So, your suggestion is to keep as is? With the middle wall cabinet?

I like the existing set up better than anything you’re considering.

Consider one mirror to span the space, it's a calm aesthetic with all that's going on in that area so looking to balance with the countertop.

I have one large mirror in every bathroom in my house (not my idea, it came this way). The one in the master is HUGE and I would love to take it down and put up two separate mirrors. The big ones are a pain to keep clean and by reflecting what is behind us while washing our hands is not a great view.

I like the thin black frame idea from Beverly!

Thanks @BeverlyFLADeziner.

I am not sure that I am going to like a large one-piece mirror.

I am still struggling to figure out the right width for the mirrors. My sinks are 19" and distance in between 12.5".

What woudl be an appropriate mirror size?