Software
Houzz Logo Print
dcmohan

Open Mudroom Flooring: Tile or Wood?

last year

I am in the process of building a home, in which we will have a mudroom/laundry room that is visible when you enter the house (see photo, room 3, measurements in meters). I am in two minds about whether this area should have the solid wood flooring we will have throughout the rest of the floor or whether it would be better to tile it. I know in general tile is a better material for mudrooms, and that having a washing machine on hardwood is not ideal...but will it ruin the space visually? Any tips?


Comments (16)

  • last year

    if it's a separate room, I would tile the floor.

    a great tile for sure, something that sets the tone of the house and compliments the wood floor.

  • PRO
    last year

    Based upon the information provided: Tile.


    Has construction started? Are you open to layout improvements?

  • last year

    I am a huge fan of slate tile. It has a wonderful "warmth" that you can't get from porcelain and complements the natural wood flooring.


    Google Vermont Slate.


    I had black, green and purple variants in my last house. They looked great after 28 years, had a great feel under your feet and were not the same old, same old...

  • last year

    Normally the guest/formal entry of a house would just be a foyer. In the USA it is unusual to have a mudroom or laundry in that main/formal entry.

    Is this your formal/main entry or everyday/family entry? Your only entry?

    What is your climate?


  • PRO
    last year

    Thank you all for the responses!


    @Mark Bischak, Architect - construction hasn't started but we are in the process of ordering a LSF structure. Curious what improvements you may recommend!


    @just_janni I am also a fan of slate, it was on the top of my list :)


    @chispa - we only have one entry to the house - so it's a formal and everyday entry. We have young kids and a dog. We're in Central Portugal, so have a warm, midlly humid climate in summer and very wet winters.

  • last year

    Some of it depends on your practices. Are you going to have a porch with a good mat and get the snow/mud off your boots before entering? Or will you have kids who tramp muddy snow in the house? Do you live in a warm climate and stick to relatively clean sidewalks?

  • last year

    @just_janni - I am a slate fan also!


    @dcmohan - I am having dark charcoal slate from Brazil installed (4" x12" size in a herringbone pattern) in my mudroom/laundry room combination. I also have it installed in a bathroom upstairs. It's very durable and feels great.


    Mine is honed + gauged = easier for tile installer because pieces are the same size. There are some pieces that don't have a smooth (honed) surface - but there are quite a few that do.


    Slate from Brazil is very durable (Vermont slate is very durable also - I am not sure of all of the available colors). You need to make sure that you don't purchase inexpensive slate tile from China + some other countries.


    Slate from Vermont and Brazil doesn't flake (have cleavage/fractures) = the top layer peels off over time. Also, it isn't slippery (I had someone here on Houzz tell me how dangerous it was to use slate tile in a bathroom - but I had already researched slate from Brazil and knew that it wouldn't be slippery).

  • PRO
    last year

    A powder room that is 1.524m by 1.524m is sufficient. There is more space in the powder room than is required and that extra space could be better used elsewhere. I never put a barn door on any type og bathroom because it offers limited privacy in many ways.

  • PRO
    last year

    Thanks Mark! Local code dictates that the bathroom needs to be a little larger for wheelchair accessibility, and yes we’re already on revising the type of door - thank you!

  • last year

    You have so many great tile options in Portugal, and so I would definitely want tile. Wood is not practical for wet areas - or even damp areas - and I would not even put wood on a kitchen floor.

    I'm in Palm Springs, and all my floors are porcelain tile, but I have area rugs in the living areas, but not the dining area.

  • PRO
    last year

    Properly sealed wood is absolutely great for kitchen floors. I've had tile, laminate, and vinyl in kitchens, and my favorite and easiest to care for is wood.

    For a mud room, however, I think tile is appropriate. You just need to figure out the best spot to transition from the tile to the wood.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    "so have a warm, midlly humid climate in summer and very wet winters."

    Consider engineered floors (I don't mean LVT). Engineered hardwood is perfect for your climate. Install factory prefinished, it's tougher, and buy a small rug for the entry that you can wash.



  • last year

    I'm a white hardwood fan but draw the line at a laundry room. Tile it is. I would make the laundry / mud room subdue in color and texture. Draw the focus to elsewhere in the house to that your eye is lead to something other than laundry.

  • PRO
    last year

    I think tile is best and in Portugal the tiles are fabulous if this space is on display do one of those fabulous tiles in colors that work with the rest of the home.

  • PRO
    last year

    Beautiful, chispa! The transition was so very well done.