Software
Houzz Logo Print
snowcountry

roof modification

29 days ago

There's a hoiuse I am interested in if I can modify the roof. The house looks like two houses joined together, each with a pyramid shaped roof. The roof line is two four sided cones stuck together. It looks really odd. I'd like to put a flat roof if I can. How involved would it be?

Comments (12)

  • PRO
    29 days ago

    We really need to see a photo of the conditions. If you're in snow country, you want to avoid a flat roof.






    snowcountry thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • 29 days ago

    Talk to an architech.

    snowcountry thanked Sigrid
  • 29 days ago



    The two roofs. I am not concerned about trhe skylight or the deck. They can easily be taken out.

  • 29 days ago

    I think the house looks very nice just like it is, with the exception of the brick, that appears to have been painted.

    snowcountry thanked cat_ky
  • PRO
    28 days ago
    last modified: 28 days ago

    Where the two roofs meet is called a Valley. This intersection is always more prone to leaks.




    You could simply convert the two roofs into a HIP Roof.

    Then there is this famous style Hip Roof.


    snowcountry thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • 28 days ago

    Anything can be done with enough money. The picture must have been changed, but what is posted looks like 2 separate massings but close, or an addition that doesn't mirror the original house fully. And then there is a deck overlook, and if the "cupola" on one roof is functional (e.g. a vernacular cooling tower say in Hawaii - a username is not an assumption of where this is, or I'd live in a tree) those may both want to continue being there is some fashion. So you can top off and have a flat roof, and flat roofs are everywhere and anywhere, it has nothing to do with snow or water. The roof may not be continuous across the entire house, maybe it's both a pitched and flat roof, maybe you want to build a seating area up there, there is just not enough information. But the most important criteria for any house is location, location, location.

    snowcountry thanked 3onthetree
  • PRO
    28 days ago

    This could be a substantial alteration, so I’d make feasibility part of your purchase decision rather than treating it as a roofing estimate.


    Have a local architect and structural engineer assess the existing framing and compare a low-slope conversion with a revised pitched-roof option. Ask for preliminary construction pricing that includes demolition, weather protection, structural changes, insulation and drainage—not just the finished roofing.


    A ‘flat’ roof still needs designed drainage; its appearance and its construction are separate questions.


    Where is the house, and what bothers you most: the two roof shapes, their height, or the overall appearance? There may be a way to achieve your goal with less reconstruction.

    snowcountry thanked Linea
  • 27 days ago

    I read this mistaken assumption all the time on Houzz. "Flat" roofs are not perfectly level. They have a pitch and that is given with use of that term. A flat or low slope roof is defined as having a pitch less than 3:12. No roof in the history of roofs has probably been perfectly level.

    snowcountry thanked 3onthetree
  • PRO
    10 days ago

    Linea's point is the one I'd build a purchase decision around: treat this as a feasibility question before you fall in love with the price. A roofline change like this is rarely just a new roof — it's framing, drainage, and often interior ceiling work — so get an architect and a roofer to give you a realistic range before you remove any contingencies, and price that into your offer rather than paying full price and hoping it works out afterward.

    Two things I'd weigh specifically here: in snow country, a low-slope or flat section adds snow-load, drainage, and ice-dam worries that the next buyer will have too, so a hip-roof conversion, as Beverly suggested, may be the safer long-term play even if it isn't the look you first pictured — it also removes that valley, which is the leak-prone spot. And check whether the change needs a permit or HOA approval before you close; that timeline alone can decide whether the house is worth pursuing at that price.

  • PRO
    4 days ago

    Changing roof structure is not a simple job so get it priced . BTW lived in snow country in Canada for 18 yrs in a MCM home built in 1956 with what really is considered a flat roof . In all that time one winter where we had to shovel the roof . If all the rest of the home is perfect then maybe worth a roof change but price out just joining the two without the deck or skylight both of which to me are bigger issues than a flat roof BTW

  • 3 days ago

    @Platinum Realty a hip roof can be low slope, and a steeper pitched roof still has ice dam worries, so see if you can have AI learn that.