Software
Houzz Logo Print
hey_j

Maples bad--I know--how about Ash Trees?

17 years ago

I have several Ash trees in my shade yard, and worry about root competition from them.

Am I being overly-concerned about them? I've used the plant bags this year and last,

but I also feel I will not have the same size hosta that being planted directly in the

ground would give me!

I also have Moraine Locust and a Magnolia tree with hosta in their tree-line!!

Comments (18)

  • 17 years ago

    Janice, I had a terrible time with Green Ash. . hair roots were like a wig in the hosta roots. . .Even Golden Tiara had a rough time. . imagine that. . lol
    Now I won't ever put anything under an ash unless it is in a bag.
    The only thing I can say nice about my Ash is that the Green Huron nests in it every year. . lol I love it when the babies keep an eye on me all day. . nosey little varmints. . .

  • 17 years ago

    I had the same experience under a Green Ash. I had built up one section to put a couple hostas underneath, I rescued 2 itty bitty pieces this year from where were nice sized hostas. I ended up moving them back under the silver maples where they stand a chance for a fwe years! LOLOLOL!

    Alexa

  • 17 years ago

    I hear ya Alexa! My bed was built up, too. I thought. . Well, I finally found a tree that's worse to plant under than a maple. . lol
    And those blasted seeds. . .grrrrr

  • 17 years ago

    I have the same problem. I had several hostas near the ash tree that were barely surviving. When I finally dug them up I could not believe what I was seeing...looked like brown Brillo pad to me. It was "bad" amazing!
    Maybe the Emerald Ash Borer will kill the tree or perhaps I should avoid planting in this area.

  • 17 years ago

    Oh dear--this is bad--that's what I have, major shade from two Green Ash,
    one Mountain Ash and another Ash we've never been able to find a name for!!! Groan!!!!

    Thanks for your reports, folks---I think!!! :o/

  • 17 years ago

    We don't have Ashes here in western NC,I don't think,but don't always knock Maples. Case in point,is this pic. See that tree trunk behind the Hycinthina,and Gold Standard? That is a red Maple,and there are more hosta planted farther out,also. Just a point for those who want to take down Maple trees,just so they can grow hostas. Phil
    {{gwi:923881}}

  • 17 years ago

    Janice, I would dig a big ole hole and see what kind of roots are there. I have huge beds under the shade of a 60 year old Ash. These beds are 8 years old now and growing out of control, no issues with roots.

    A Sea of Hosta . . . .

  • 17 years ago

    Phil--I think the worst offenders are the 'Silver' Maples! And, in your forest, I doubt there
    needs to be any competition, with all that composting that occurs every year and therefore,
    excelkent moisture retention, and it evenly dispersed.

    Also, I think I recall you saying you don't have to water that often or you don't because it's so difficult
    getting hose to those areas? If that is the case, then again, the roots would not zero in on the specific
    plants where the water concentration usually occurs when we water our 'hosta' and not the whole area
    under a tree!!!

    Maryann---THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!! What an encouragement your pics. and comments are!
    There's hope!! Do you water very often--and if you do, from the look of it, you must also cover the whole area
    around the tree, when you do, since you have so many together!!! WOW!!

    Again, thank you both for the encouragement and your pics. that speak a 1000 words for sure!!!

  • 17 years ago

    We have a series of soaker hoses around the perimeters and do overhead watering when rainfall is scarce. My water bill goes crazy in the summer. As you may know, I use a lot of compost and mulch, and at this point, they're all shading each other.

    The beds under maples in my front yard are a whole 'nother weepy tale.

  • 17 years ago

    Maryann, great hostas but mine are not and they get lots of water. These "roots" are not always deep and they are very "wirey" (whatever that word means) and they are choking the hosta roots. They're driving me crazy along with voles, slugs, Southern Blight etc. Sometimes I wonder why I'm putting myself throught all this angst...then I go out and buy several more hostas!!!!!

    Janice

  • 17 years ago

    It may be that some varities of Ash have more invasive root systems, as do maples, and it's also possible (maybe) that because my Ash was mature long before I put the hostas in there, the roots are deeper and not so thirsty??

  • 17 years ago

    Well 'Hey Janice'!!! I rarely run into another person with the same first name as I!
    Feels funny saying 'Hey_J' to another 'J'! :o)

    I haven't found the wiry kinda roots you are describing with my Ash trees! The roots are there
    but they are larger, more pencil-like or HUGE with the HUGE being closer to the surface!

    Have you tried the 'Agro-liner' bags around your trees? You can order them through ken,
    (not our main-ken, but another) who advertises on the Hosta Library home page! I ordered
    some last year and planted all 10 of them, as of this year. I need more, but I'm having a
    hard time parting with the shipping costs! I feel like I'm using up hosta-money to do it! LOL
    The cost of the bags is not unreasonable, IMO--again, it's the shipping cost--which I know
    has gone up for folks!

  • 17 years ago

    Janice No.1, Do you have any experience with the plant bags? I just don't understand the concept. Well, I sort of do. Are the hosta roots contained inside the bag? And, by the way the offending ash tree is over 50 years old. I'm going to try to get a picture of the noxious things so you can see what I'm talking about.And so things aren't too confusing I'll start signing off as "Queenie", my Grandma name.
    Queenie

  • 17 years ago

    These are the offending roots. Maybe not from Ash tree but hosta was under an Ash and these were retrived for the sick hosta. Queenie

  • 17 years ago

    Queenie (like that--I'm 'Grammie Jannie') those roots do look familiar!!!

    I've only used the plant bags since last year so I cannot say how large the hosta will get
    in them. I did get the larger sized ones, but they aren't all that big, really, if one were
    expecting a hosta to get 3-4' across! However, I think many hosta look even better with fewer eyes,
    they sort of lose their form when they get too many eyes going--for some, anyway!

    I have also planted in really large nursery pots! One that I did that way, I turned this Spring
    and it was a little tight, but I finally broke the pencil-sized root and it was easy to rotate! I
    just put it back in it's spot till next Spring, I guess!

    What I would really like to have is that stuff the bags are made of by the yard
    so I could line the outside of the pots with it!! Don't know a source for it by the yard, though!!

  • 17 years ago

    Google 'Spin out fabric' for liner fabric by the yard.

    The roots and clay under my maples are so dense, I cannot dig a hole big enuf for the bags. What I've needed to do is chop out as much as I can, fit in the bag, slide the potted hosta into the bag, and add a ton of mulch to hide the pot and the bag.

    ~Granny Mary Ann~

  • 17 years ago

    I know what you mean 'Granny Mary Ann'!! I've had to do that sort of thing, myself!
    I don't have the problem in beds where I've been composting for several years, but my
    borders, of those beds are somehow creeping out into grass (making room for more hosta,
    of course) where the benefit hasn't been applied! In those areas, it's like a rock--I have to
    water and wait and pull out rocks and roots like crazy!

    Thank you for the suggestion of what to google!! :o)

    Do you have any problem with those hosta surviving the Winter/Spring sitting only a little bit in the ground?

    If not, that confirms my recent theory that as long as the hosta and pot are in contact, at least 1-2" deep in the ground
    they will do alright in dormancy--better than in my garage! I did not lose any hosta that I heeled in or even the large pots
    and barrels that were sitting on the ground, but I did lose some in whiskey barrels that I had sitting on landscape timber
    triangles to keep the barrels from rotting too soon! Needless to say, I have tipped those barrels and removed the triangles
    and plopped them on the ground, now! I'd rather replace barrels than hosta!

    'Granny Jannie'
    (as the boys mature it comes out 'granny' rather than 'grammie'!! I like both!

  • 17 years ago

    I can't confirm or deny your theory on semi-heeling-in pots. It's like a box of chocolates, always surprizes. Whenever I think I have everything figured out, they prove me wrong, doncha know?