My mother had her outdoor chaise lounge chair cushions reupholstered by a local person who does this sort of work. They came out nice. I know she did not pay a lot of money to do it as she is very frugal. I would think that any professional upholsterer could make cushions?

Well, I guess that could be an option. It's just a shame because the other chaise cushion is "perfect"-basically new and so I'd be getting rid of a cushion that has nothing wrong with it. I like the fabric too.

If you are into funky off-beat decorating you could do a 'patch' but make it decorative instead of trying to get the patch to blend in (they never ever really blend in).

Have the patch be a butterfly or palm tree or something. If you want something that looks more elegant and less whimsical put a neatly finished bordered patch on with your monogram embroidered on the patch or maybe a clever phrase. Depending on where the damage is located it could even look like you purchased them that way. Just some ideas to play around with...........

I was thinking along the same lines as dilly dally.

Another idea would be to take the fabric off the back of one of the cushions. Since it's a chaise, how about the bottom part that you sit on? Would it make a difference if the underside had a different fabric? Just a thought.