Software
Houzz Logo Print
vascularry

New Construction- Water in Basement

11 years ago

We are building a new home and we noticed water coming into the foundation. The house is completely framed with shingles and windows installed. They have already started framing the basement and we are worried we already have a foundation issue. I posted a few pictures of what is going on after a recent rainfall. There is standing water a few inches from the foundation.When I talked with my realtor she didn't seem too concerned since the grading hasn't been done, there are no gutters and no sump pump installed. I feel like this shouldn't matter since this proves the seal has been compromised and water can get into the basement.

Should I ask to meet with the builder? What are your thoughts?


Comments (33)

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, I would definitely meet with the builder BEFORE any drywall goes up. He needs to fix the problem or give an honest explanation!

    Ryan thanked Stephanie Sims_Arnold
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Hi, Ryan,

    Yes, you should bring this to the builder's attention before any insulation or finishes are installed in the basement. If you are purchasing the home and a Realtor is involved in the transaction, they should accompany you to any/all meetings as your representative.

    Ryan thanked Charles Ross Homes
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You need to inspect the wall from the outside and show us some photos of the exterior face of the foundation wall. Was waterproofing applied to the foundation? Is there a footing drain?

    In the first photo the water appears to be coming from the top of the foundation wall which suggest the problem is a poor flashing detail at that point. There should be flashing under the sill of the stud wall that has a drip on the outside and is turned up on the inside of the studs but I don't see any evidence of that.

    Can you also provide us with the detail of this intersection of materials? Perhaps a typical wall section.

    Ryan thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you all!

    My realtor is setting up a meeting with the builder.
    I will post more pictures once I get over there later tonight.

  • 11 years ago

    Here are a few more. I got a few close ups and some of the outside. There is one of the foundation with water half way up and it appears to have a very small crack in it.

    We are both young and ignorant when it comes to all this and would love any help we can get on what we should discuss with the builder. Thanks in advance.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There are a few vertical cracks on the interior that should be addressed but that is minor settling. I am not sure there is a proper flashing at the sill plate, which is probably the real problem here, and that is including the fact that there is a lake up against your house. That water needs to be pumped out so the crew can actually work on your house properly. And it should be graded ASAP, since the foundation and waterproofing is done. The only thing stopping them from grading it is that it is too muddy to do right now (and that is why they should pump the water out so it can dry and get graded before it rains a bunch again).

    Ryan thanked Vith
  • 11 years ago

    I have yet to meet with the builder due to him being a vacation. We hope to do so this week. We are getting frustrated. The work on the house continues but after another large rain there are some other issues in the basement. We didn't receive enough to where it comes in through the foundation and the framing but look at the floor. The cracks are very small in the floor, hairline if anything and there is moisture around them. Also, there are several areas of moisture around the border of the room. I'm very concerned with this basement but no one else seems to be. We are having second thoughts about finishing the basement but have already wrote a large non-refundable check for the house upgrades which includes the basement finish.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The beginning of a nightmare.... Let me start
    by saying to get any of my questions answered by their builder, I have to go
    through my realtor who then talks with their representative and then they talk
    to the builder.

    I
    express my concerns with the basement hoping they will get back to me and put
    an end to my worries. In response, we get this answer, “Trust the building
    process, we know what we are doing, we don’t come to your job and tell you how
    to do it"Imnot exaggerating this. I am shocked at their lack of
    customer service. This is one of Iowa’s largest home builders and they say they
    take pride in customer service before, during and after the sale. I have yet to
    see this.

    After many phone calls of trying to get a meeting set up with the builder. We finally
    meet with the site foreman on 5-8-15 and discussed a few minor issues and the
    basement. I asked them if the sump pump would be up and running before
    insulation and drywall installation and they assured me that it would be. At
    the time I thought this was too good to be true but took their word for it. I
    was excited to see things move forward in a positive direction but then the
    events on 5-14-15 took place…

    4-25-15 = First sign of water coming in the basement
    4-25 through 4-12 = HVAC, Electrical and Plumbing Installed.
    5-12-15 =
    Insulation starts to be installed
    5-13-15 =
    All insulation installed with no sump pump
    5-14-15 =
    We received between .5-.6 inches of rain. Drywall was delivered as this is the
    next step. As soon as we look at the basement we see water. I proceed to look
    under the insulation and I can see water running down the side of the
    foundation. (pictures posted below). I called my realtor as I was upset that
    they lied to me at our meeting and that nothing was being done about this on
    the builders side. Still no sump pump, no grading, no
    siding/gutters. Apparently this builder does all this after drywall is
    installed which doesn’t help our situation as we have proved to them water does
    get in. They are not concerned by this at all.

    15th-16th = My
    realtor gets in contact with their representative. They continue to tell us
    that we don’t understand the home building process and that building a home isn’t
    right for us and that we are micromanaging them. They serve us with a release
    of contract notice. We are devastated. All my fiancé and I wanted was our
    concerns put at rest and to move forward with building a beautiful home but
    they would rather terminate our contract then deal with our worry.

    We have wrote non-refundable checks to them during this process- $1000 earnest
    money and $5000 for upgrades. The $5000 check has already been cashed. We are
    hoping they tear up the earnest money check and give us our $5000 back. I feel like
    we have gotten scammed. We fear that
    this is something that is going to go to the court system.

    On Monday our realtor is meeting with their representative’s boss to discuss these
    things. Hopefully they go well. Our realtor is doing everything she can to help us out with this and we are grateful for that.

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry to hear about what you are going through.. There is one thing about "trusting the builder", however in the end it is YOUR house.. You have to live in it.. As a builder they should be understanding to this.. I write my builder directly almost every other day.. Sometimes they get back to me right away, other times it takes a day or 2 but they ALWAYS return my messages and discuss whatever it is.. Your builder seems to not be concerned with this and just want to get the house built on their own schedule and not take your concerns into account.. With big builders you sometimes run into this and don't get a more personal type of relationship with them.. I have met with my builder on numerous occasions for build related matters which turn into personal conversations that last a while.. Just a few weeks ago I met to sign off on some paperwork and we ended up b.s.'ing for over an hour.. Unfortunately you are in a tough place.. My guess is that their "release of contract" was to scare you into keeping quiet for the remainder of the build..


    Ryan thanked njbuilding143
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I am so sorry for your experience. Like bry911, I can't believe the builder is not more responsive. Putting on finish materials when the foundation leaks elevates the risk of mold/mildew which will turn a bad problem into a really bad problem. It's best to deal with the problem before it gets bigger and that's what you have asked them to do.

    You could involve an attorney at this point, but I'd suggest one intermediate step before you do so: Get the Real Estate agency's broker involved. They are your representatives and are already being compensated. If kicking the problem up to the broker level doesn't produce a reasonable solution, then an attorney is a logical next step.

    Best wishes for a successful outcome.

    Ryan thanked Charles Ross Homes
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    HOLY COWS look at that lake! Were they going for a lakefront property here? Utterly ridiculous. I personally would cut ties with these goofballs and sue for the money back for the basement finishing at small claims. You have all the evidence needed for any reasonable judge to totally be on your side.

    Ryan thanked Vith
  • 11 years ago

    You can sue in small claims for under I believe 6k. You have the pictures and then you can also ask here on the forum what is considered proper procedure and show to the court. Additionally you could hire a building inspector to be your advocate too.

    Frankly, if they are cutting corners now with this, do you really want to have them continue to build your home? What else are they cutting corners on?

    Ryan thanked cpartist
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you all. Charles, I believe my realtor is meeting with their broker on Monday. I am hopeful that they come to their senses and settle this outside of court. I will let you all know how things go tomorrow.

  • 11 years ago

    Good luck Ryan. I hope you can settle this out of court too. If you back out of this with this builder, trust me a better choice will come along.

  • 11 years ago

    Be glad they are letting you walk away from this disaster waiting to happen. I hope you get your money back fast. I'm amazed they put in insulation in while water is streaming through the walls. Wow, just wow. Walk away without regrets.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    OMG. I am so happy you are getting out from this house!!! I can promise you with this attitude and this complete lack of response from their builder. There are other problems down the road. You are so lucky to end this!!!! I hope you are able to get your money back. With this said. It is better to be out the 6000 than move Into this house. They have no respect for you or your home.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Ryan,

    Im SO sorry to hear about this. You seem like you have your ducks in a row, but definitely keep ALL documentation on every word said from both your Realtor and the building company. Keep the pics, every little detail even if you dont think it would help. This builder needs to be put in his place. I can't believe this is happening, its really disgusting how a builder (of all people) would just sit there and do nothing about it. Again, im sorry to hear about your issue and I really hope it gets fixed ASAP. Keep us posted!

  • 11 years ago

    I would run away as fast as possible. Any builder who cares this little is building garbage and you are going to spend a whole lot more then $6K to fix whatever other problems pop up once you move in. I would certainly hire a lawyer if they don't give you the $6K back but I wouldn't let them try and get me to continue on a build that is clearly not moving forward correctly. We are building a house and if the builder spoke to us like this I would be mortified. It's hugely disappointing as this is probably a home you already saw yourself in. Hope you get some resolution!

  • 11 years ago

    Unfortunately developers or tract home builders are generally lacking in many areas, be thankful he is giving you an out. In my opinion take it and run, the six grand is a lot of money but better to suck it up now then find out later what else they have no clue about.

  • 11 years ago

    If you're only on the hook for $6K I'd regard that as a cheap escape from a bad situation.

    We had water in the basement of our last house, but figured out it was coming in the window due to improper grading a very poorly placed downspout. That was easy to fix. If they haven't properly flashed your sills or applied waterproofing to your basement walls that is much harder to do anything about.

  • 11 years ago

    This is not my area of expertise but before you walk away from the $6,000, see an attorney. I can't see any contract where the terminating party gets to keep any money without a transfer of benefit.

    Generally, at contract termination you are responsible for paying the reasonable value of the benefit transferred to you, but there are some exceptions. These exceptions are kind of the "but for" parts of the contract, these look something like, "if you had not chosen X tile, we would not have put X tile in, therefore you have to pay for X tile when you terminate the contract." However, these things require an action on your part that damages them, you terminate the contract (action), and they are stuck with your ugly tile choice (damage). If they terminate the contract, then you didn't provide the action required for them to collect damages.

    Before someone points it out, laws can vary state by state. So my advice is to see an attorney in your state.

  • 11 years ago

    I am no expert, but you just can't tell me that having water run down behind your insulation is acceptable at all. And if they seem of no mind to correct something so glaringly wrong.....it would make me wonder where else they decide to do shoddy work. We have only seen water in our basement once during the build (and we built through the spring - 7 inches of rain so far this year -) and they immediately let us know it was because the hose they were running up to jet the front porch area had a small leak in it. So we had a small puddle of water right by the drain and the hose. Never have we seen it running down the walls like that, and we went to check during heavy rains. I would be freaking out if it did! Are any other homes being done by them close to where your site is? Would you be able to talk with other owners and see if they are having similar trouble? The other thing I would wonder is if you talked to former clients before you built - did they have anything good or bad to say about the builder?

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    OMG - what a _____ Show. The home's exterior building envelope needs addressing. The home is clearly settling and foundation cracks are a bad sign. Perimeter drainage around the footings and rain water leaders need to be installed.


    I would hit the breaks. Get the envelope outside tarted out. Get a soil engineer and structural engineer to check the foundation.


    Make all repairs.


    Don't let them cover this stuff up!



  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    And replace the insulation as that is ruined after the leaks have been addressed of course!!

  • 11 years ago

    Update!
    Thanks to our awesome realtor, we just signed a release of contract that states we will receive our full $6,000 back.

    Thank you all for your responses and support.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Good news, take it and run!

  • 11 years ago

    Terrific. Something better will come along.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Glad this worked out for you. I wonder how long it will be before we see a "help mold in basement!" post from the folks they will eventually sell the home to.

  • 11 years ago

    Give that realtor many recommendations! Glad you got away mostly unscathed!

  • 11 years ago

    I'd have a consult with an attorney next and see what kind of bad things, if any, would happen if I forwarded these photos to the next owner.


    Good grief you are so lucky they cut you off.


    And not to be ... well, apologizing first doesn't help anyone.


    If 5k was a huge big deal to you, you are not ready to be home owners let alone build. Keep saving. I say that assuming that 5k would really hurt you if you hadn't gotten it back. I mean, I'd be PO'd about 5k, consider small claims, but at the end of the day it would be a blip. If 5k is a "lot" of money in a way that equals long term pain, keep renting.

  • 11 years ago

    I'll bet that the builder let you walk because of the combination of knowing that there was a problem and seeing that you were advocating for yourself. He probably didnt want the hassle of fighting with you after closing on the house. Now he can sell it to someone who doesn't know about the problem.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You were smart to walk away and with your money.

    We were like you when we had our last house built. Young and inexperienced. We trusted our builder which was a huge mistake. We saw a crack on the side of the slab but excepted the explanation the builder gave us. Eventually we had structural damage in the same area where the crack was formed. Every pipe under the master bathroom was broken and separated. When you have cracks (hairline or larger) in a new build it is time to get an independent inspector involved. Losing money is hard but dealing with major issues years later is worse. Remember, the builder usually walks away after a year. Even trying to sue is not always the solution since some builders close the business and reopen later under another name. We were lucky since the builder provided a warranty plan that covered structural issues but we had to fight everyone tooth and nail to get things covered. Consider this a life lesson for you. We did. You never look at builders the same way and you spend the extra money to have someone inspect all areas during the building process.

    I am glad you were able to get out of this nightmare. However, I feel bad for the person who will be buying this house.