Software
Houzz Logo Print
ohfirsttimecustombuild

Dual HVAC - New Construction

I'm trying to educate myself on the latest in HVAC as I investigate a new construction build in Ohio. My builder says his HVAC installer uses Carrier, and that the proposed home (3500 sq ft 1st Floor, 1500 sq ft 2nd Floor, 1700 sq ft Walk out Basement) would have Dual HVAC units.

How does that work? Does one unit do the Basement and First Floor and the other the Second Floor? Does that mean the Second Unit can be 'smaller' than the First Unit? I've read about zoning of HVAC, but I don't think this solution is like that.

My current home is 2 story with a basement, and there can be what seems to be 20 degree differences between basement and 2nd Floor Master Bedroom. At least it feels like that. But I only have a single HVAC system.

No info has been provided on 'allowance' for HVAC, nor the models that would be used. I asked about Geothermal, but was told that from a cost perspective that would be substantially more than that a dual unit. But I'm trying to make sure I have the right info so that when the 'Better' unit is proposed to me, I can ask for the 'Best' unit, if it's only a $600 upgrade or so.

Any Carrier features or functions I should ask for ?

Comments (31)

  • 11 years ago

    What is your heating fuel? I will assume premium building and insulation qualities for your home. Obviously a single system for the 2nd floor should be fine. For the large main floor and walk out basement which I assume will be finished living area, I would want top of line system with zoning controls. Carrier offers the best integrated residential zoning controls on the market. I would want modulating furnace with variable speed condenser. You need to verify dealer's qualification with zoning, definitely not a novice install. Details matter. You, GC, and HVAC dealer should get together for a sit down to discuss.

    IMO

  • 11 years ago

    Fuel is Natural Gas. Good to hear Carrier is top notch. Any particular 'line' of Carrier I should ask for ?

  • 11 years ago

    Carrier residential

    Infinity Modulating furnace, Infinity variable speed (VS) AC condenser, Infinity zoning controls for main floor and basement. I would make basement one of the zones, and split up main floor into different zones. Of course, you need to qualify your Carrier dealer's expertise with zoning and good ductwork sizing/design. Again, you, GC, and HVAC dealer should get together soon for a sit down to discuss.

    IMO

  • 11 years ago

    I highly doubt you we will able to upgrade to the "Best" equipment for $600. Be prepared for sticker shock.

    Most builder's will budget the low end model for the HVAC equipment. They are able to do this because most home buyer's are not familiar with the equipment. If the buyer wants to upgrade he may pay much more than the actual cost of the differences in equipment models. The extra cost becomes profit for the builder.

    This is a big house and you want it to be comfortable in winter and summer. Ask a lot of questions and gather the information.

  • 11 years ago

    We have a pair of carrier Performance units for heating and AC in our two-story home in Chicago. The upstairs and downstairs systems are different sizes, but they are the same model. Our heating/cooling requirements are a little different than yours, but not a ton different. I have been very happy with our system.

    For what it's worth, in the summer we use our upstairs AC every day. We use our downstairs AC maybe once a week. In the winter, we use our downstairs heat a ton, and we only use our upstairs heat when we are sleeping.

    In hindsight, I wish we had upgraded the downstairs furnace and upstairs AC (or downgraded the downstairs AC and upstairs heat) because that's what we use the most. Discuss putting more efficient AC upstairs, but don't go overboard by putting the same model downstairs.

  • 11 years ago

    Final plans are in, and the home ended up being 3575 on first floor, 1425 on the second floor and 1925 finished in the walk-out basement. I know this is a huge home, but there was discussion of using 3 units, one for each floor. I don't know if I've heard of that before, and certainly didn't budget for that. I'm a bit confused on 'sizing' of units too - it seems like 5 ton is NOT enough for the first floor and basement, based on the way I have heard to ballpark it - 1 ton for 500 sq ft. I think they called my 'bluff' when I asked when they would do a Manual-J calc - like I'd even know how to read the results if they were presented to me :)

  • 11 years ago

    Basements normally do not need large AC units, especially the rule of thumb sizes.

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry, but your builder "calling your bluff" is BS. Tell them that while it's true that you may not be able to understand all the details of a Manual J, it is their responsibility to talk you through it all. You will certainly be able to understand the basics of design temperatures, etc. Draw the line in the sand now. The builder shouldn't treat you like an idiot, ever.


    You probably do not need any AC in the basement at all, and it seems totally reasonable to gang the basement and first floor together. You definitely do need a second system for upstairs.

  • 11 years ago

    I agree with advice to this point and reiterate what Tiger said,qulifycations of installer is as important as equipment, even more so where zoning is involved. Equipment can usually be fixed,bum installs are forever.

  • 11 years ago

    A walk out basement may need some heating, but very little cooling. You house is not typical so no rules of thumb will come close to estimating the actual heating and cooling loads.

    Have the load calculation done and post the summary here for review. If the builder refuses tell him to hire another HVAC contractor or hire your own.

  • 10 years ago

    It's taken some time, but I've been asked to attend a HVAC meeting with my builder this week. I'm looking forward to what information they provide on how they have sized my house, and what equipment they are proposing.

    Any last minute info on questions I should have prepared for the meeting? I know nothing about HVAC :)

  • 10 years ago

    Get the load calcs in writing and understand the design temps that were used both for cooling and heating, in and outside. If zoning controls are to be used, you need to qualify dealer's experience in this area both equipment selection and ductwork design. Insulate, insulate, insulate...relatively cheap and is a one time expense that pays for itself over and over.

    IMO

  • 10 years ago

    Zone 5 (barely) in Southern Ohio. Specs Say R-19 bat in 2x6 walls, R-50 in blown attic space, R-30 in vaulted truss/other areas

  • 10 years ago

    You have above average insulation. This will affect the load calculations. The numbers you posted should be included in the calculation. If they are not then it is wrong.

    Most of Ohio has a winter design temperature of 5 degrees, and summer temperature of about 88 degrees. The usual indoor temps are 72 for winter and 75 for summer.

  • 10 years ago

    HVAC Meeting went OK, but key was budget. In budget, I'm spec'd for a 5 Ton Comfort Series 95% Efficient on the Main Floor/Basement and a 3 Ton Comfort Series 95% for the upstairs. They are going to email me all the actual model numbers, etc. for me to look over.

    The Comfort Series, as I read it, is single stage / fixed speed, which I told them I did not want. They are going to email complete specs of equipment I have 'in budget' and upgrade options. Anywhere to find list prices or selling prices of Carrier Equipment? I also asked for copies of the load calcs, which they said they would provide.

    One other option that came up was moving from R-19 Batt to Mineral Wood Insulation - something I'm not aware of. Said that is a cost effective thing to also increase the comfort of the home.

    I guess I won't be getting Infinity Greenspeed :(

  • 10 years ago

    I'd be curious what the extra cost of mineral wool insulation would be... generally 2x6 construction with mineral wool would be R-23, so you're talking about an increase of R-4 in your walls. Unless the price difference is really marginal, it seems like you'd get more bang for your buck elsewhere.

  • 10 years ago

    My Carrier options - 2 Systems (5 Ton Main Floor/Basement, 3 Ton Upstairs)


    Included

    Furnace - Comfort 95 (59SC5A)

    A/C - Comfort 13 (24ABB3)

    Thermostat - Honeywell


    Better - $3,500 Upgrade

    Furnace - Infinity 96 (59TN6)

    A/C - Performance 17 (24ACB7)

    Thermostat - Infinity Touch (SYSTXCC1TC01)


    Best - $6,750 Upgrade

    Furnace - Infinity 98 GreenSpeed (59MN7A)

    A/C - Infinity 19VS (24VNA9)

    Thermostat - Infinity Touch (SYSTXCC1TC01)


    No zoning with these options.





  • 10 years ago

    I am doubtful given the insulation values and location that your house requires 8 tons of cooling. Did they specify the sizes of the furnaces? Did you receive the load calculation? If you haven't gotten it by now, then have a feeling it doesn't exist.

    Is the quoted better upgrade include both systems? If it does, then that would would be a good investment in my opinion. You would be going from single stage to variable speed 2-stage equipment. You don't want that 5 ton condenser constantly cycling on and off on a warm spring day. You will also get much better humidity control. Ask if they would be willing to substitute the Infinity 24ANB7 condenser for the same price.

    The best upgrade is nice, but not worth the money. The modulating furnace is nice, but it is not going to save you any money. The 24VNA9 19 SEER is overkill for your climate. You will never see a return on your investment.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    My post is from scribbled notes I took on the phone. I have not been provided with any additional details via email yet. They did say that the upstairs might only need a 2 ton unit and that they were going to check their loads again. I'll assume 2 ton is cheaper than 3 ton.

    Quoted prices are upgrades to BOTH Systems. I double checked that. I asked about having the BEST option on my main floor and BETTER upstairs too. They said they could do it, but the units will look different outside.

    I wondered myself about the matched Infinity/Performance vs. all Infinity for my BETTER option. I will ask about the Infinity 17. Should I be asking about the Evaporator Coil? I've seen that mentioned online too What exactly is that ? And a Humdifier too.

    Thanks for you input.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    You should not have to scribble notes from a phone call. The HVAC contractor needs to provide a complete list of all equipment with model numbers and sizes.

    "They did say that the upstairs might only need a 2 ton unit and that they were going to check their loads again."

    This statement is further evidence to me that no load calculation has been done. The fact your are questioning their sizing is causing them to rethink what they plan to install. If you propose 3 tons, you don't suddenly drop to 2 tons by rechecking the calculations.

    The evaporator coil is a set to tubing which carries refrigerant from the condenser at one end, and sends it back from the other end. It sits on top of the furnace. The furnace push air through it so it will be cooled. The air then up through the main supply and vents. You want the matching Carrier coil and not a third party cheap substitute. This is why you need model numbers for everything you are getting.

    A new house should be tight and not need a humidifier. It can be added at a later date if it is really needed.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I would not want the Comfort Series...I would ask dealer for a Performance Series quote both furnace and AC condenser...I would want a zoning control for the main floor and basement areas...anyone considering Carrier which has been a top end brand should be aware of the recent major announcement to close Indiana manufacturing location and move this operation to Mexico which results in the loss of 1400 American jobs.

    IMO

  • 10 years ago

    Just looking over everything in my budget, I'm going to have to go with the BETTER option, unless I finance the $3,200 difference over 30 years :) I got 'hard' pricing from the HVAC Firm to know what my upgrade cost for the units was vs. the initial Comfort Series model. But I have no way of knowing if that's good or not. HVAC is not like buying a car - no way to know a 59TN6 is $2200, a 59MN7A is $3500, etc. and NO ONE will give you an wants to give you that information. I simply asked a couple of Factory Authorized Dealers 'what is cost of the Comfort 13 and what is cost of the Infinity 96' and that is not information they will provide.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    "recent major announcement to close Indiana manufacturing location and move this operation to Mexico which results in the loss of 1400 American jobs."

    Sorry for the off-topic comment, but actions like this aren't new in the Rust Belt. Consider the blame may be with the worker's union, whose actions in such circumstances often lead to salary levels that are too high and unaffordable to pay for having an unskilled factory workforce. When labor costs get out of line, manufacturing plants are moved to lower cost areas.

  • 10 years ago

    for above poster...an employee video tape of the announcement is on the Internet...think about it for a moment...if you knew you were losing your job at the end of 18 mths regardless how you performed, would you put your best effort forward as far as building quality into the end product?...some employees might even consider worse actions...I think it's something any homeowner should take into consideration before a Carrier purchase...sad to say but it's true...

    IMO

  • 10 years ago

    Frankly, SnidleyWiplash's comment is completely off-topic and should probably be removed by the mods. But as long as it is being left to stand, I'll add the other side:


    Consider that the blame may be with the company executives who care more about net profit than paying their labor a fair, negotiated rate... Or about a quality product, for that matter. If Carrier wants to roll the dice in Mexico, that is their right. It's also my right to prefer to buy products made in the USA by union labor whenever possible.


    Factory workers are not unskilled.

  • 10 years ago

    I've talked to my Builder and HVAC company about options for zoning. We would take my 'Better' (Infinity non-greenspeed system) and add Infinity A/C. Their options:

    2 Zone - Main Floor / Basement - $4500

    4 Zone - Main Floor (3 zones) / Basement - $5600

    Any additional zones $575


    I guess my questions for the experts is that while I realize there is a zoning controller that is required ($2k ?) what really is changing about the ductwork? They were going to get me an example of how my ducting would look in the basement since it was going to be larger to support the zoning. I was trying to keep my basement ceiling 'nice' looking, without a lot of huge HVAC drops.

    As for insulation, the product nuWool was proposed as an option. Blow cellulose product in the walls. They said as little as $800 upgrade, so that seemed like a no brainer to me.

  • 10 years ago

    Duct work changes would depend on the layout of the house. Air flow has to go to the one zone calling for heat and cooling and have a return back to the furnace. You need another thermostat with wiring, and dampers. The Infinity dampers are very expensive. Builders have big profit margins on upgrades. In most cases it is hard to justify the cost.

    I am not familiar with nuWool other than watching the YouTube videos. It looks like it has the same insulation value per inch compared to a fiberglass batt. I can see it would be better at stopping air infiltration. I think applying a house wrap may be just as effective, but perhaps nuWool has data that shows there product is better. You can see installing nuWool is a less labor intensive than installing batts. So there is a lot of savings in labor costs. There must be a reason why nuWool has not displaced traditional fiberglass batts in wall insulation. Perhaps some insulation experts can offer their opinion.

  • 10 years ago

    Going to piggyback on this. We are doing an addition / renovation which will expand the main floor, add an upstairs floor and also a basement to our split level. We currently have about a 5yr old 80% furnace. The existing AC condenser is shot. We'll be putting in a furnace and AC for the 2 upstairs bedroom floors, and the same for the main floor and basement.

    One guy said to move the existing g furnace for the upstairs and put in new more efficient unit for the downstairs as that will be doing most of the work (heat rising), which makes intuitive sense to a layman. But the other guy said no, keep the unit where it is, and add the new efficient unit upstairs. Which is correct?

  • 10 years ago

    The answer to your question would depend on the size of the current furnace, and the new sizes of the first and second floors. It might turn out that neither contractor is correct.

    Start a new posting and provide more information. You will get more responses then piggybacking on someone else's thread.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Tell the builder you want to see the HVAC load calculations.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals