Cool house.

Are you wanting restoration windows that exactly match the arched windows (I e single pane wood) or replacement windows that look like them (like aluminum clad wood with sdl). If aluminum clad nail down your color scheme so the windows can be ordered in the final color.

Hi, I’m looking for replacement windows.

To me it looks like the style of your home doesn't work with the current double hung windows. Looks like casement windows would be more appropriate.

Yes, I definitely agree casement is more suitable. Thank you for the input! I love that second green but I thought if I went with a more neutral window I could always change trim and paint more easily if I wanted to change the color scheme in the future. The entire exterior needs fresh paint, including the arched first floor windows. I was thinking either black, white or tan/beige for windows. Do you have thoughts on the color?

Black seems too harsh for your brick and colors so I would vote for something softer

You have a bungalow. It's not Spanish. The windows in these homes often have dark frames. Green windows are often used because they complement the style of the homes built during the Arts & Crafts movement.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2022-02-09/how-the-bungalow-brought-chicago-together

I would not do dark frames on your house. They would stick out like a sore thumb and dominate, obscuring the charm of the house. I like the photos that Beverly FlaDeziner shows EXCEPT the second and fourth ones.