Software
Houzz Logo Print
a1an

Isolated Ground with BX

19 years ago

Out here in BX land, the BX serves when connected to our steel boxes is out isolated ground.

With that said, if I am using a IG receptacle, will the screw that attaches from the yoke strap to the screwhole on my box be fine or should I run a ground wire from the ground screw to the box itself ?

I'm not necessarily using the IG receptacle for the IG properties.....it's a long story.

Comments (23)

  • 19 years ago

    If I understand your question, it depends on the receptacle. Most IG receptacles have a "clip" of some type that provides a positive connection between the yoke and screw, allowing the screw to serve the function of the ground wire to the yoke. There has to be a ground wire to the receptacle ground connection.

    While technically OK, you are using a receptacle that is not installed as listed (as an isolated ground device)and is marked for something it isn't doing - providing an isolated ground. Not a particularly good idea and skating on the thin line between legal and illegal......

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks bill. I never seen or ran a ground wire myself as per the OP, the BX to the box is served as the ground. So just short of runnnig a short wire from the ground screw to the box itself as well, I did not forsee a problem.

    Here is the reasoning why.
    The switches I am using are Lutron Maestro line *satin finish*. Their receptacles are basically a cheap receptacle with a faceplate that fits over it. This faceplate has the matching finish of the switches.

    On the duplex receptacles, I've looked at, all the manuf lines I checked - I did not see one that is as described below. The goal was to replace the cheap receptacle with a better grade one yet still maintain the same finish/color line of the switches.

    On the receptacle itself I needed a duplex receptacle with a wallplate screwhole on the top & bottom of the strap. Similar to what you normally see on a Decora style - Square style receptacle except I needed the screwholes on a regular duplex unit. The faceplate are designed to snap onto a regular deuplex receptacle. The ONLY one I was able to find were these Cooper IG ones. I'll try to take a pic when I get home if this is unclear....

  • 19 years ago

    The armour jacket on BX is not considered an isolated grounded conductor. It is a mechanical ground. An isolated grounding conductor is insulated and seperate from any mechanical grounds and terminates back at the main distribution panel's neutral bar.

  • 19 years ago

    One other short note. The grounding connection on a IG outlet has no physical connection to the yoke (as ordinary outlets do). A IG outlet should never be connected by jumper to the electrical wall box. Doing so prevents the ground from being isolated.

  • 19 years ago

    Understood on the the function of the IG.

    I was asking if the the screwholes on the strap to the box, in addition to a ground wire from the recpt. to a screw on the box will serve sufficiently as Ground in this function.

    I don't need a isolated ground receptacle. It's just the only one they have that had the screwhole on the top/bottom of the strap to accept a wallplate ~ala~ the Lutron Faceplates I want to put on this receptacle.

  • 19 years ago

    "I was asking if the the screwholes on the strap to the box, in addition to a ground wire from the recpt. to a screw on the box will serve sufficiently as Ground in this function."

    Yes.

    For AC cable the pigtail goes from the box to the device.
    Be sure to use cable connectors rated for AC.

    The typical method of grounding when using metal boxes is to run a pigtail from the threaded hole in the back of the box to the receptacle, and the cable ground (for cables with a separate grounding conductor).

  • 19 years ago

    I would suggest you define what you actually have. BX is not used anymore, although there are houses that still have it in use. Recent similar cables are MC (metal clad) and AC (armored cable). They are both similar in looks but the AC has a bare internal bonding strip of either copper or aluminum which the MC does not.

    If using AC, the sheathing is acceptable as a ground. MC sheathing is not and requires a seperate EGC to provide a legal ground pathway.

    If using AC, the (correct) connector does qualify as providing an acceptable ground to the box. If using MC cable, you must use a seperate ground and it must be connected to the box. If the receptacle is listed as self grounding (every IG recep I have used was either self grounding or had a plastic yoke), you are safe with the yoke connection but since this is an IG recep, you must also connect a groundwire to the ground terminal on the recep.

    If youhave actual BX or MC, there needs to be an actual ground conductor for the ground path. If you do not, you do not have a (new installation) legal installation.

    any ground conductors should be connected to the box as well

  • 19 years ago

    I would SERIOUSLY recommend not installing the isolated ground receptacle if you really do not have an isolated ground conductor in the wiring. Why on earth are you doing this?

  • 19 years ago

    It is AC cable - just used to calling it BX . Kinda how we call NM - Romex.

    If anyone has a better suggestion, please feel to make a recommendation.

    Goal - Match the receptacles to the same satin finish of the switches. Manufacture - Lutron does make the matching receptacles.

    The receptacles are a *decora* style outlet. In reality, it's a square faceplate that snaps onto a cheap receptacle.

    The goal was to replace the cheap receptacle with a better grade receptacle. It needs to be a 15 amp duplex receptacle WITH screw holes on the top and bottom of the strap for the wallplate - similar to the screwholes you see on any Square-Decora Style receptacle.

    I have looked at all the major manuf lines - 5262 model series in Hubbell, Leviton, Cooper, P&S, etc and NONE make a duplex with the holes on the strap.

    My supplier has Cooper IG receptacles that have the holes on the top and bottom strap. The Reason why I need those holes is in order for the the wallplate for the receptacle to SCREW INTO.

  • 19 years ago

    So, let me see if I got this straight. Lutron only makes junk receptacles in the "Satin Colors" line, and you want something of better quality. So you propose to take apart a Lutron receptacle, and combine part of the Lutron receptacle with a Cooper receptacle, and call it good?

    Somehow, I don't think UL would approve...

    If if were me, I would be looking for some other way of providing switches and receptacles that doesn't involve hacking up UL-listed assemblies and mixing and matching parts. There are way too many different receptacles around for me to believe that you can't find standard switches and receptacles that will fit in the same plate.

  • 19 years ago

    ROMEX is a brand name for NM

    AC and BX aren't the same at all other than there casual exterior similarilty.

    30 seconds of googling show that Lutron does make satin color receptacles. No need for butchery.

  • 19 years ago

    ronnatalie:AC and BX aren't the same at all other than there casual exterior similarilty.

    True and MC is also similar in appearance. Many folks use the term "BX" interchangably with either MC or AC and of course, there still is BX out there in use. Just suggesting OP clarifies. It makes a diff as to what is needed to have proper installation.

    solar: I do not believe what the OP is doing is contrary to UL listing. Unless the only listed use for a decora wallplate is to be used only with a decora recep or switch, he is simply putting a recep that fits in the trimplate in the hole. If it requires a trimplate to be UL listed for a specific brand of device, I think we are all in trouble. I do not neccessarily by P&S plates for P&S receps and Hubbell for Hubbell but simply install a trimplate that provides proper protection as required.

  • 19 years ago

    Dozer,

    As I understand what he said, the Lutron receptacle itself is actually an assembly of a conventional "smiley-face" receptacle combined with a plastic piece attached to the front that is in the shape of a Decora opening. He wants to disassemble this assembly, and mix and match the pieces with a receptacle from another manufacturer.

  • 19 years ago

    BX predates AC.
    It can pose a hazard if the armor is relied on for grounding.
    It does NOT have a bonding strip and the ground impedance can be high enough to prevent tripping the OCD in the event of a short.

    AC has a bonding strip and the armor is acceptable as a grounding conductor.

    MC has a run ground (insulated conductor).

    BX has been a sort of generic term for spiral armored wire for at least 60 years.
    In residential use AC is the NEC designation for what is usually used (you could use MC though).

  • 19 years ago

    Fromn Left to Right

    Lutron Receptacle *OEM is Cooper*
    Faceplate
    Leviton 5262
    Arrow Hart IG receptacle

    img src="http://www.pingablesolutions.com/images/receptacles.jpg";

  • 19 years ago

    {{!gwi}}

  • 19 years ago

    In my area, AC is not widely used where MC is. The last time I spoke about this with an out of state electrician, he told me the east coast area is big on using MC as well. The biggest use of AC is (in my area) in med facilities where the bonding strip, along with an insulated EGC fulfill code requirements.

    As to the grounding in the MC; although I will admit I have never seen it without an EGC, I see no requirement per the NEC to include one. It becomes very limited in use without one though since the sheathing is not listed as a proper ground. Due note that there are uses that would not require an EGC but I would think they are limited.

    Actually, I would like to see you find any code that actually listed BX as an actual cable. I understand that it has always been AC but the old "BX" days did not have the bonding wire. I don;t believe that BX predates AC at all. I understand BX was simply a name such as Romex only for that companies particular brand name for AC and stuck as a reference to AC.

    Sorry, further research does show that even "BX" had the bonding strip eventually but it was a flat wire that broke too easily and was eventually replaced with the current wire we see today. There were other problems with the "BX" style AC as well.

    anyway, that solves nothing the OP is looking for.

    chefwong, what the dickens is that thing? If the faceplate is an integral part of the recep, then solar has a point. That face plate is the oddest looking thing I have seen.

    I see from this website:http://lutron.com/CMS/CMSSystem_entry.aspx?appid=1023&id=5528

    that a 20 amp recep is offered. Have you looked at them? I have not seen the faceplate you have shown so I suspect it may be an integral part of the recep. It does not even look like that faceplate would fill the rectangular cutout in the outer trim plate. It looks like some crappy blow molded piece of plastic designed as an afterthought. The pics on the Lutron website don't look anything like that.

  • 19 years ago

    In the pics, it's exactly what you see is the *frontside* of the receptacle. I took off the plate and what you are seeing is the backside. It sits snug on a regular duplex and if you look closely, there is a nub in the center of the faceplate where it sits in the screwhole of the duplex receptacle.

    The frontside is satin-has slight grain texture to it just like their switches I'm using. Like most products these days, their recpt. line may have been cheapened....

    In my previous house, we used Lutron throughout as well and their receptacles was a single piece unlike the current ones

    And yes, when I opened the box and saw how the receptacle was....and said why didn't they design the entire thing as one piece.

  • 19 years ago

    You guys had me working on pics and I just went scrounging for *electrical stuff from old house* box and came back with these. These are from the Nova T series.

    Faceplate snaps and fits onto regular duplex . It had me thinking and I did a test fit which was a no-go. Face plate from the maestro series fits just fine. However, the screwless wallplate does not fit onto the Nova T receptacle due to the integrated metal plate that is part of the Nova T receptacle. The metal plate is slightly larger than the Maestro plates and it will not sit flat against it.

    Thanks for listening at least ;-)

    {{!gwi}}
    {{!gwi}}

  • 19 years ago

    Now that you say that is the reverse side of the plate, I can see how it works.

    Did you cruise the page I gave. 20 amp receps are often built a bit better than the 15 amp ones. Maybe those would be acceptable.

    As to using the plate on some other recept; I would have to go along with solar on this one. That plate is designed to fit on a recep of specific design. If you notice, the IG receps you have do not have a flat face (it recesses where the prongs insert). I do not know that it would be against code but I would tend to be hesitant in recommending your action.

  • 19 years ago

    Let me swing by the counter one day and check out the 20 amp versions.

    I did not notice it but I see the recess now. Care to enlighten me on the reasoning for this recess.

    Looking through my stash of receptacles, the hospital grade ones have this recess as well.

  • 19 years ago

    I believe it is simply a choice of design. I have seem some with and some without the recesses.

    I can't remember what brand I have used but there is at least one that has a flat face.

  • 19 years ago

    The theory of the recesses is to make it easier to plug in a plug, by guiding the prongs into the slots.

    I've played with some of each type, and it does indeed make some difference. Enough difference that I would choose the type with recesses for my home, but not enough that I would say that it's really much of a big deal.