Software
Houzz Logo Print
greentea8

Help me choose a Benjamin Moore white color for kitchen cabinets

11 years ago

We really need to place our order for custom kitchen cabinets, shaker style, with tubular pull handles. Our overall color scheme is white, grey, taupe. Hardwood floors will be a medium to dark brown, with grey undertones. I don't want cream white, bright white, or white with green undertones.

We've narrowed it down to:

  1. Chantilly Lace
  2. Decorator's White
  3. Simply White
  4. Cloud White

*Our counter top is Caesarstone "Frosty Carrina." Floor tiles are undecided, but along the above color scheme. Backsplash is being left until everything is in place.

TIA! (thanks in advance)

Comments (30)

  • 11 years ago
    The most popular white right now for cabinets is BM white dove
  • 11 years ago
    Decorators white is a very bright white, I would not use that one. I personally love simply white.
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    is BM sea pearl too not white? thats the color of my cabinets and i love it.

  • 11 years ago
    I used BM Frostline on my shaker cabinets and all the house trim for that matter.
  • 11 years ago

    BM White Dove.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    @brandi and @v f - Re: White Dove - yes, I’ve seen that color
    mentioned on several design sites.
    Thanks for the suggestion.

    @howellmsue – thanks for the tip on Decorators White. I concur,
    it’s too white. I’m scratching that one
    off my list.

    @nnigrt – seapearl is a lovely color, and thank you for taking the time to include pictures.
    Your cabinets look awesome. I saw
    seapearl on the BM website and it looks like it has undertones of green and
    grey, but your cabinets look white. I
    know the lighting in everyone’s home is different. I can’t even determine from my own kitchen
    because we will be getting pot lights.

    @juudean – did you mean Frostine? Your cabinets are very nice! Thanks for the pictures! I saw hints of green
    on the BW website, but your wall color is blue, yet, it all ties in nicely. I personally don’t want anything with green
    undertones though.

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    I went to a BM store last night to pick up color samples for the
    rest of our house, and based on our new color scheme, the suggestions for white
    were White Diamond and Vanilla Milkshake. I didn't need anymore whites ... lol

    White Diamond looks very similar to Decorators White, so I’m
    leaning towards Vanilla Milkshake, Simply White, or White Dove.

  • 11 years ago
    Sea pearl or pale oak by BM
  • 11 years ago

    We used Sea Pearl not only for the cabinets, but all of the trim in the house. For reference, here is the stairs and trim in Sea Pearl.

  • 11 years ago
    Ann...yes, it is Frostine! The color on the BM website doesn't accurately represent what we ended up with. I'm not seeing any green hue in my cabinets/ trim...
    Ann thanked juudean
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    We used Sherwin Williams Kemvar conversion varnish and we had it matched to BM Winter White OC-21 for the cabinets and trim in this kitchen.

    Farm House · More Info


    Farm House · More Info

    Farm House · More Info

    Ann thanked Hanson Carlen
  • 11 years ago

    @Hanson - that's a gorgeous kitchen, thanks for sharing!


  • 11 years ago

    Hi everyone - thanks for your feedback and advice. I decided on BM Chantilly Lace, and when I look back on my post, it was the first choice :)

    Appreciate the responses!

  • 9 years ago

    I know this thread is a year old, but do you love your choice for Chantilly Lace?

  • 9 years ago

    Hi joviboys, the Chantilly Lace was a good call :)

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you for commenting, Ann! Do you have any pictures? I have to give my cabinet guy my colors next week.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    Yes, please share a pic of the chantilly lace. I'm in between white dove or chantilly lace
  • 9 years ago

    I haven't had a chance to take any yet. I went to the BM store and selected all the whites I could find, then I went home and just taped them to my existing cabinets, then I looked at the paint chips at different times of the day, and with lights on/off. We had over 12 different whites. The Chantilly Lace is a very bright white and to me, the tone looks neutral, but our kitchen is south facing. I would suggest you do the same to narrow it down because the Internet doesn't really show the true colors as opposed to in your own home. It would also depend on your wall colors, counter tops, flooring, etc. Does your cabinet supplier have samples to show you? Ours had a sample in Cloud White and we took it home to compare. I hope that helps.

  • 9 years ago

    I have many samples as well. I hated the white dove. It looked dingy to me. I just wanted to make sure that Chantilly Lace doesn't look icy blue or yellow once it is in the entire kitchen. I saw one poster say it looked yellow....another said it was cold/stark. I never knew how hard it would be. Do you see either of these colors in yours?

  • 9 years ago

    Keep in mind that other colors you have in your kitchen including your lighting, what direction your windows/door faces, wall color, counter tops, floor tiles, back splash, etc. will affect the color. It wouldn't be fair for me to say what tone "my cabinets" look vs. what yours may, because I have grey tones in my entire home. With everything that I've researched and had purchased and installed, in my kitchen, the cabinets look pure white. I can't detect any tones at all. The choices are indeed overwhelming and the process is very stressful. Just look at the paint chips as I mentioned above. Good luck!

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks so much for your input! My perimeter counters are a light grayish Quartz and my subway tile will be pure white (larger than 3x 6 ).my island will be a deep charcoal with whitish Quartz on top. My home colors will be on the griege-side since I'm trying to meld some of my brown and tan from the Tuscan trend. I just can't get rid of all furniture, but still want the freshness to go with the white kitchen. I'm definitely down to Chantilly Lace or SW Extra White. Thanks again, Ann!!!

  • 9 years ago
    I had my cabinets painted white dove. Had planned on doing some brand of Quartz in a marble look. After my cupboards were painted I took a door to several quarts places. None of them looked too good. I would highly suggest you take a larger sample of your colors and go to someplace that has several brands of Quartz. Then you will be much more likely to select something you are happy with.
  • 9 years ago

    @Winterberry Lane - thanks for the suggestion of Oxford White. I recall it was one of our sample colours, but I don't remember why we eliminated it from our list. Our renos are completed though, and I hope we never have to go through it again - it was extremely stressful!

    @life4real - great idea!

    @joviboys - I forgot to mention that we got a nice sized sample from Ceasarstone and put that in our kitchen with our subway tiles and wall colour, all side by side, and it helped us narrow down our choices.

    Your home colours are similar to what ours used to be (taupe, browns, earthy colours). We had our entire home repainted with BM and now it's pure white, a bit of greige, and different shades of grey. It'll all be worth it in the end!

  • 9 years ago
    Ann, your house sound beautiful!
    Ann thanked life4real
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks life4real

  • 9 years ago

    Ann...just out of curiosity, what colors did you paint your kitchen, family, dining and powder room? And maybe entry? Thanks!

  • 9 years ago

    I have loads of white cabinets, wainscoting, painted brick, T&G and trim throughout my house and all of it is in BM Simply White. For me, it's perfect!

  • 9 years ago
    May be too late, but I would add that the same color will look very different in several homes. So get a sample and paint on a big poster board and view it in your house with your lighting and outdoor reflections. Colors will change quite dramatically.
  • 9 years ago

    I have a ton of samples. I was just curious :)

  • 8 years ago

    White Dove is one of their most popular whites. They sell it by gallons in their stores. I have it on all my crown molding and baseboards....very classic.