Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_979133467

alternate entry addition center hall colonial

2 years ago

We live in a small brick center hall colonial with a tuck under garage having a typical not so attractive side addition. The side addition has a leaking roof so we are currently deciding what to do with that space, including figuring out heating/cooling options to make it more usable. Our home has very little space in the front main entry way with no coat closet and we are a family of six.

Any ideas on how to add an alternative entry door to the front of the addition area (side setback is only 5’ and prohibited from building per zoning so we have no room there) over the garage that wouldn’t look hideous from the front so we could use some of that space for a mudroom/entry? Going around the back is not ideal as it’s a bit of a walk at night and we keep our fence locked (we’re in a city).

We are also contemplating adding a second story (may require a complete rebuild) to the addition for an additional office space upstairs also. Our other option is building more of an enclosed portico off the front door but we can’t easily expand to the left in the view due to the gas line/meter to the left of the front door and I’m a bit hesitant to commit to putting cold shoes on in the morning!

Thanks for any advice/ideas!

Comments (17)

  • 2 years ago

    Best to post floor plans of the house and land plot for any comments on this site.

    But my best advice is the best money spent for you is to hire a local engineer/architect to develop visual and cost effective solutions within your budget and local building codes.

  • 2 years ago

    ^ agree, it’s hard to say but I would be tempted to make the garage the family entry and heat/cool/organize as needed (cheaper than lots of other options)

  • 2 years ago

    Existing floor plans:

  • 2 years ago

    " Any ideas on how to add an alternative entry door to the front of the addition area "


    Stairs from the driveway? But that would make the garage less useful. Why do you want a side entrance? Do you have one in the back of the home? Floor plans with rooms and dimensions would help us help you.

  • 2 years ago

    The basement is currently used for home offices-one on each side, so using the garage/basement it as the family entry mudroom doesn’t work the best as it comes right into one of our home office spaces. The sunroom addition is currently empty.

  • 2 years ago

    I guess I’m wondering if there is a way to make almost a cantilevered balcony off the front of the sunroom addition with steps to the side so that could be the alternate entry, but I’m not sure how that would look curbside appeal wise.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    You need more help that we are ready to give on this project since you will need an actual architect for sure . I have no clue where you live but looks like maybe you could have acarport and then make the garage the mudroom. IMO that addition is just plain ugly and in no way works with the house . I aslo have no clue how you plan to add a 2nd story to an addition that is not functional now .

  • 2 years ago

    If you made a narrow porch that ran from your front door across the front of your sunroom changing the window to a door with a complementary railing that might look ok. Whether you can cantilever over the garage or need support down to the driveway you need to find out.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Is that whole side really dedicated to storage?


    can the sunroom be modified for office space so you can better utilize the garage?

  • 2 years ago

    Get an architect. Add a vestibule.

  • 2 years ago

    I understand we’d need an architect, but in our area it’s over $5k just for a conceptual design and we’re not quite ready to embark on the project yet we don’t think vs just looking for ideas to help us understand what measures we should take in the short-term while being mindful of a long-term plan.

    Basement isn’t used for storage (it’s just labeled like that), but is a home office on each side + guest space. The sunroom was previously the office space, but the roof is leaking and it’s freezing in the winter so we’re trying to figure out how to best use the space now (would love to move kids play stuff in there to a dedicated area from our living room), but also looking to the future. To replace the roof that has been fixed multiple times and address the heating/cooling is about $8-10k in our area, which if we decided to do something bigger with that room, we might look to do it sooner to put the $8-10k into the bigger project vs. just a band-aid project for now.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    A vestibule and enlarging your living room and dining room entrances would open up the entry.


    Any sunroom addition should have looked more in keeping with the house’s architecture and with your topography will not be an easy fix. The leak might not be the roof. The addition looks shoddy and might not be properly joined to the house. Tearing down and rebuilding might be the best fix.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Do you usually park in the garage or in the driveway? Do you usually enter through the garage's interior door to the house or through the front door?

    Inexpensive change: add a wall or sliding shoji screens in the "storage area" (now an office) to channel foot traffic from the garage interior door to the stairs.

    Get a copy of the permits for the sunroom to see how it was designed. See if floors and walls are insulated. Check for air leakage and heat loss from the windows. Then talk to an HVAC contractor about heating and cooling the room since what you have now is not working well. Rebuilding the addition as a real room, not an occasional-use sunroom, may be cost effective.


    Here is a shoji screened room.


    Chinese inspired bedroom · More Info


  • 2 years ago

    We park in the driveway 75% of the time with about a foot of space on each side as our street is busy and cars get sideswiped often, but we walk daily and don’t drive a ton. The garage is not big enough for a car unless one climbs out through the trunk, but does store bikes/tools/outdoor gear. We’ve thought about coming in through the garage/basement and replacing the garage door with just exterior French doors for easier garage access, which is probably the best option but I was hoping for something on the main floor of the house so bringing in groceries/packing kids up for school etc. would be easier (and the other family members would actually use the “family entrance”-I grew up with a family entrance vs my husband did not and doesn’t see the need, but his house also had a fairly sizable front entryway with a large coat closet that we don’t have (our coat closet is about 18” wide and I’m the only one who accesses it.

    But thanks all for the ideas/thoughts at this point in time.

  • 2 years ago

    We have a vestibule and it doesn't add very much useful space TBH - family comes in through the garage and we have a short back hall with hooks, baskets and benches and that works so much better - it is not very big but tons of utility


    adding on is so expensive with roof lines etc I tend to think that optimizing what's already there will be a better ROI

  • 2 years ago

    My vestibule had a bench , boot tray and a coat closet which were instrument when kids were younger and the op mentioned not having. Now i replaced the bench with a desk to curtail mail, bills, passports, cards, etc etc. I think aesthetically a vestibule will be better than jerry rigging a cantilevered entrance on the sunroom but not better than working with what you have.

  • 2 years ago

    We would need to move the gas meter and gas line most likely to put on a vestibule big enough ti be useful but it’s a thought-are these usually conditioned spaces? The glass ones look nice but we’re in the DC area so it would be a greenhouse in the summer as this side faces west and gets the afternoon sun. Trying to match the brick/mortar would be difficult I would expect and siding doesn’t look great usually, but it’s something to think about. Thanks.