Looking for feedback on our bathroom remodel

last year

Our primary suite is on the 2nd floor of a 3-storey townhome. The bathroom is somewhat dated, mostly because of the jacuzzi tub and the tiled surround. We've decided to have the tub removed and replaced with a freestanding tub. We will need to replace the floor tile as well as the existing tile on the pony wall facing the tub. Everything else will remain in place (tiled walls, showers, cabinetry).

The house was built in 2008, so it's unlikely we will be able to find the same mosaic tile. So I am thinking of just using the same tile that we choose for the floor, but I'm not sure if that means white, beige or grey tile, since all of those colors were used in the room. I would be grateful for any input you have!

Featured Answer

Kathryn Weiss
Original Author

last year

Thanks for your opinions. I still wish someone would have answered my question about floor tile. FWIW, a full remodel will never be in the cards. I also never said that I don't use the tub. I do. The tile surround makes this tub very difficult to clean, hence the decision to get a freestanding tub. Also, the current tub has airjets and one side no longer works. The builder did not include an access panel, so I would eventually have to tear into it to get it fixed. We figured we might as well replace the tub with something we could enjoy for now, rather than spend the money before we list it. Regardless of my reasons, I see that all of you disagree, so have a nice day.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

PRO
BeverlyFLADeziner
last year
So you want to change a bathtub you rarely use for a bathtub you'll rarely use.

Your bathroom doesn't look dated. Plenty new bathrooms appear similar

I'd turn the mirrors so they are VERTICAL & I'd either paint or select a wallpaper for the walls an call it finished. Everything you have so far works well together.

Figure out a way to get all that junk off the countertop. Change the mirrors to giant medicine cabinets.

No blue linens in this room. White, Taupe, Gray or Charcoal only

I think a wallpaper like this would add some sophistication to the space.

https://zoffany.sandersondesigngroup.com/product/wallpaper/zkem312650/

https://www.etoffe.com/en/wallpapers/35491-guinea-wallpaper-zoffany.html

You could change out your fixtures to polished nickel that always makes a bath look special.
thinkdesignlive
last year
I agree w what Bev said and I’ll add - you have the space to rework the mirror wall and to add sconces on either side of the mirrors. If you can recess medicine cabinets and add sconces and maybe wallpaper the wall around the mirrors and lights you will go a long way to update. Believe it or not some people are actually switching their freestanding tubs to built ins as the wider deck space is easier to maneuver.
Related Professionals
Kirksville Home Remodeling · Bridgeport Kitchen Remodelers · Orangeburg Bathroom Remodelers · Glenwood Springs Bathroom Remodelers · Pine Bluff Interior Designers & Decorators · Rochester Interior Designers & Decorators · Sarnia Interior Designers & Decorators · Dayton Architects & Building Designers · Lubbock Architects & Building Designers · Marinette Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Hilo Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Bridgeport Bathroom Remodelers · Sheridan Bathroom Remodelers · Newburyport Tile and Stone Contractors · Riverside Tile and Stone Contractors
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
last year
Mozaico, you really are ridiculous now, and your comment makes absolutely no sense. She hasn't done A THING yet!
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
last year
last modified: last year
"So you want to change a bathtub you rarely use for a bathtub you'll rarely use." LOL Bev.

Does the bathroom function? You get water out of all the faucets? No leaks? No broken tiles? If the answer is yes, then leave it alone--it looks fine. Sure, it's not what most homeowners would choose if they were starting from scratch in 2025, but removing and replacing the tub could open a can of worms and won't really add anything. Wait until you can do a full remodel instead of pecking at it piecemeal.
PRO
Norwood Architects
last year
Will the tile of the shower stay or will it be replaced as well?
thinkdesignlive
last year
Norwood it was going to stay.
PRO
Minardi
last year
Leave the whole thing alone until you are ready to blast it all into the dumpster. You aren't making wise financial moves at all here. Your change is a complete waste of money that does zero to create more function, or more beauty. The tub you have is actually far more usable than a free standing one. It at least has a place for towels and wine.
PRO
BeverlyFLADeziner
last year
In looking at the room again, I stand by what I recommended, but the room desperately needs new lighting over the sinks and in the balance of the room. It's dull and flat. New lighting will help all the elements of the room look better.
thinkdesignlive
last year
With your open style shower you may have an issue replacing the floor tile at each entry point - have you had a tile contractor out to assess this? The mosaic tile along the floor will more than likely get damaged. It really is a can of worms.
la_la Girl
last year
For the floor tiles - it is hard to suggest colors based on what shows up on monitors - I'd def avoid grey with all the existing shower tile and would probably choose something in the putty, cream or beige family - but I think it will be lots of trial and error bringing home samples and checking them against the tile that is staying (FWIW no one knew the tub was not functioning properly based on your original post)