That is some beautiful wood. My vote would be not to paint it. Accessorize the mantel, put a nice firescreen in front of the hearth and maybe display something on top of the cabinets. Once it's painted the original beauty of the wood is lost forever.

I think it is lovely and would not paint it. However, it is your home.

In the picture, the room does not look to be dark at all.

What about getting glass doors for the top tier? Maybe the middle too? Then put some nice light ceramics or chinoiserie in there?

I would paint it, but since you are unsure, go ahead with your suggestion of embracing it ... with lighting, wall paint, furnishings etc... and then take another look at it.

If you feel the wood is heavy and are tired of that look, PAINT IT. It doesn't look to me to be historic or mahogany or some other valuable wood from the photo shown.

You could do it in various shades of white and dove gray and get a very light, relaxing mood in the room. Another idea is to keep the columns and the fascia right around the fireplace in wood and paint the rest. Or you could strip the wood and do a different treatment or stain, light whitewash or even a wash color and keep the wood grain but change the tone.

Here's a photo that has paint and wood tones and I think the effect is pretty nice. Some wood is just not worth it. And once it's painted, you can update it as trends change. If it's always wood? It's always wood and sometimes wood tones don't fit a room.

If painting, I would also replace the columns on the fireplace with some with straighter cleaner lines, it would take some of the heavy look off it, and be more updated.

It would look beautiful painted white

I wouldn't paint it. White paint will highlight the door style, which is a bit dated.

You can definitely work with it to achieve a better look to the whole room (the wall color isn't helping).

This is an example of a different way to finish cypress using lime paint.

Maybe try taking all the doors off and then having them be open shelves?

The wood is warm and lovely. And the cabinetry looks beautifully made. But you're right that the side sections are kind of monolithic. Talk to a cabinet maker and see if you can have some glass inserts in place of some of the panels. That will break up the "wall-o-wood" without spoiling the gorgeousness of the material.

Paint the fireplace mantle only then take the finish off the rest of the wood so it looks more raw.

If you do paint them white, maybe leave the mantel as stained wood.

Thank y'all for the comments. There were a lot of ideas I hadn't considered. Groveraxel, I appreciate you taking time to make the visual. It was extremely helpful.

B
M
T h

I think what feels so "heavy" is that the whole wall is the same material. I suggest that you might highlight the larger center portion, perhaps leaving just the mantel the natural stained wood and paint an accent color on the rest of the center section. Or you could reverse it and paint just the mantel and the side cabinets leaving the center section the natural wood. You have to admit, the wood is beautiful. I think painting everything one color will give you the same heavy effect, even if it is white.

Below are two photos of the same fireplace, the white is the before, the black satin painted mantel is the after. What a dramatic difference!

All the best in your decision making!

I would paint, take off the doors and have open shelving. The stain and door style look dated to me.

That is beautiful wood! It looks like the rest of the trims/moulding in the house are white so it is really an accent rather than too much. What about painting/whitewashing the brick to lighten that up a bit? I also think some pretty things on the mantle or above the side cabinets could take the edge off the expanse of wood. I think other suggestions to remove the upper doors or install glass in them are good ones. I think you should also play around with wall color a bit to see if you can tone down the yellow tones coming from the wood and furnishings. Maybe warm grey or grey-green?

What is with wood....it was machine made! If the wall was brick would you leave it brick because it was installed by hand. If it were turquoise tile would you leave it tile because it was organic...it is OK to say, I hate it and I want it removed......Why should someones else's choice dictate how you live....you paint for the house, now make it what you want.

we bought a house with a lava rock wall; all natural. We covered it with sheet rock and moved on.

grover's examples make me think painting it white would be a mistake.

Grab a screwdriver and remove the top doors. Then please post another picture.

I like MS colors idea of of whitewashing this . The whole thing just has such a monolithic look to it! It bugs me that the mantle seems to end short over the top of the columns. I think this could be redesigned a bit better. Agree about removing the doors and and making this open shelving; it would create some breathing room. A cabinet maker may be able to rework this for you and bring it up to date.

Man I'd be tempted to but up millwork on the other walls to really showcase this exceptional beauty!

I vote for liming the wood.

Or this is a foyer in pecky cypress which is very interesting.

Here is a kitchen in pecky cypress. I think you can do something more creative than simply painting the cypress.

While I think the center portion is way too dominant, even overpowering the FP mantel and surround, I would not ditch the whole thing. Consider taking the finish back to something light like this cypress armoire. Can you match the brick around the firebox? If so, then you might carefully remove the oversized center portion and build a chimney breast in that space. More brick would keep the warmth factor and a lighter finish would keep the room from feeling too heavy.

Paint. Maybe a light grey or blue?