Software
Houzz Logo Print
ellessebee

Kitchen drawers or cabinets with roll-outs?

13 years ago
I am trying to decide whether to outfit my new kitchen with deep drawers or roll-outs behind doors. This would be for pots and microwave cookware, mixing bowls, small appliances etc. I will have twice as many base cabinets as uppers. (I prefer to keep my table ware in upper cabinets but cookware below counter.) I currently have cabinets with pull-outs. Some of the cabinets have 2 deep roll-outs, some have one deep and one shallow and one cabinet (for pots, pans and lids) has 3 rolls outs at different heights. I have found this to be a good system, for the most part, although sometimes fall off the back of the roll-out if not stacked properly. I think this system gives me more flexibility to move things around as my needs change and also greater visibility because I can see everything in the entire cabinet when I open the doors. If each roll-out were a drawer, I would only be able to see what is in that drawer and can imagine having to open a couple of drawers to find what I'm looking for if they've shifted location. That said, I know that drawers are all the rage because you don't have to open a door and then a roll-out. I'd love to hear from someone who has used both roll-outs and drawers. Thanks.

Comments (26)

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I have some of both. Love having my pots and pans in the drawers, you will get used to what's in what very quickly. You can see everything that is in the drawer at an instanct. I do have a couple fo roll-out shelves behind doors for the bigger items I don't use every day such as mixer, stockpot, blender, etc. but opening a drawer and looking down into it is so much easier than opening two doors and then either bending down to look into the cabinet to see what's where or to now roll out the pull-outs.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I have both and once I memorized where I put things, as the entire kitchen was reconfigured I prefer the drawers, all day, every day. The doors with pullouts are affectionately known as the doors with fall offs, real pain when something falls behind and then gets stuck. Even my pantry has these silly roll outs, behind the doors. Real pain and a total waste of money. I can't even tell you how many times, I envision the door getting ruined as someone shuts it, without the roll out being all the way in. The back side of the doors are already scratched up.....My cabinet installer made me 2 drawers for above my fridge, that pull out, soft close of course but you access each of them from the outer sides. Full height front, full height back, one side full height and the other shorter so I can see and reach inside....genius!!!
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I've had both and vastly prefer the simplicity of deep drawers, which is what we put in our renovated kitchen. But since drawers usually are more expensive than cabinets (even with the cost of roll outs added), if you prefer the cabinet pull out system you should stick with what you like. (I do suspect, however, that if you switched to drawers you would soon prefer them).
  • 13 years ago
    olldcan, how do you see into such tall drawers over your fridge? Sounds like a great idea since my stainless fridge doors are now scratched from a ceramic platter stored vertically above that rolled out when I reached for something next to it, but I can't imagine using such high drawers. You must have to stand on a step stool to look in, no?
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I agree with just pull-out drawers as it doesn't require that extra step of opening a door first which has a risk of being damaged if it's not opened completely while the drawers are pulled.

    Kitchen remodel · More Info
  • 13 years ago
    I don't have them, but when I do my kitchen I am getting drawers.
  • 13 years ago
    Nope, I don't need a stool either, let me take a picture of them after brekkie and I'll load it here so you can see.
  • 13 years ago
    You must be tall, olldcan! I need a stool just to get to the cabinets over my fridge!
  • 13 years ago
    Or have a short fridge!
  • 13 years ago
    If you have a lot of cabinet space in the kitchen, I would do one roll out cabinet, and the rest in drawers. Reason why is because there are some big pots that require a lot of room, and they're going to fit in the roll outs better. But the roll outs are a PITA for the most part, so I'd only do one, and that's if you have quite a number of larger pots. A shelf in the pantry would also do for those and you could eliminate roll outs entirely.
  • 13 years ago
    And here's the drawer on the left.
    Okay you two, smartie pants!!!! :)no i'm not really tall 5'6" and if I keep having a brekkie like the one I just had, I'll be just as wide in no time!!!!
    If you wan't dimensions with a quick sketch I can do that for you, or even the height of my fridge :/ You can see 3 sides of the drawer are full height, the access side is shorter so I can see and access the contents but tall enough so nothing rolls out to the side when I pull or push on the drawer handle. Both drawers have 3 full extension slides, soft close a,d there is a gable between the drawers. Access sides could have both been on the right or the left but I chose one of each.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    The drawers are almost as deep as the fridge, which makes a huge difference compared to the ones that are only 12-15" deep, not only are they useless, there hard to reach :)
  • 13 years ago
    I love the utility of the drawers but love the look even more
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Hi Ellessebee,

    I completely agree with drawers being far more useful than pullouts, for exactly the reasons you and others here have mentioned. Because the majority of the projects we build use custom cabinetry, if I do spec pullouts then I make sure the sides are tailored to whats being stored in them. I don't spec them very often, but they are good for under kitchen sinks and a few other places.

    @Olldcan: I LOVE those fridge drawers! great solution for an odd storage area. We've either installed adjustable shelves or shallow pullouts for large platters etc for above fridges, but I really like this as an alternative for a different kind of storage. Thanks for sharing

    Steve
  • 13 years ago
    We just got new cabinets. They are awesome. (If you are budget conscious, I recommend CliqStudios.com.) Anyway, one of the best choices we made was a large pantry with double doors and pull-out trays. It's the best. We hardly use any other cabinet for food! With regard to storage of equipment, we have a pots and pans drawer base that is extremely useful. We use one drawer for tupperware stuff, and it allows for excellent organization. The other drawer is great for large, heavy pans. Some of the remaining cabinets are pull-outs and some not, and I do recommend having both. You lose some storage with pull-outs, but it allows ease of use for stuff in the back that is used frequently. And an additional drawer base is excellent to have for kitchen linens or similar storage. Best of luck with your decision.
  • 13 years ago
    Personally, I would choose drawers over pullouts anyday. Everything is right there at your fingertips. You loose valuable space inside your cabinets to accomodate the sliding track with pullouts. I love drawers so much that I had three put in beside my fridge instead of the traditional pantry. Then I had the pantry/broom closet installed above the drawers. The broom side of the cabinet is only about 8" wide and the other side is shelves that go right to the ceiling. They house cleaning products, paper towels, etc. I have a small kitchen so I tried to maximize storage. I don't think you can have too many drawers.
  • 13 years ago
    olldcan - absolutely brilliant! A simple concept that I've never seen before - executed so beautifully. Thank you so much! I will be using this idea in my bathroom, too, with 9' ceilings and linen cabinets almost all the way up this will be a lifesaver for me. What other tricks do you have up your sleeve?! I'm downsizing - and building for the long haul. Want to get it right...this time!
  • 13 years ago
    Ditto pull out drawers. I have both but the pull outs need extra space! Plus, the pull outs do get those plastic lids stuck in the back! But, we do have narrow pull out "pantry" shelves on the right of refrig (for door opening clearance) and pull out pantry on the bottom right of stove for easy accesible spices.
  • 13 years ago
    Drawers, drawers, drawers. As I age, getting down on one knee to retrieve the rolling pin in the back of the cabinet is a pain. Drawers !!!
  • 11 years ago

    I am a single retired woman who had the same problem with a pullout shelf in my 2-year old kitchen. (I agree: deep drawers are better, but I use my pullout for crockpots, stand mixer, wine carafes, pitchers.) So I emptied everything out, got down with a flashlight and eventually discovered a flat thin piece of wood laying in the middle of the cabinet. I could feel sharp points sticking up like it had been attached to the bottom of the pullout shelf and had fallen off. It was now blocking the shelf from pulling out. I pried it up with a flat screwdriver, enough to pull the shelf out. Removed the shelf completely. The flat piece looks like it is intended to brace the shelf from the underside but it was only stapled on, and it had fallen off. I think some gorilla glue should hold it in place. I guess I will do that and keep the pullout. Alternatively I could remove the sliders altogether, and use the cabinet space. That actually gives a bit more room, but then you have trouble getting things out from the back. Hope this helps someone!

  • 11 years ago
    I went for mostly all drawers in my lower cabinets. They haven't come in yet but I'm really excited. It just made more sense to me to have drawers as opposed to pull outs, and was less expensive! :)
  • 10 years ago

    olldcan I'm hoping you get this comment even though this is an old article, I'm so glad to see your experience with the drawers over the fridge. We are thinking of doing a bank of drawers instead of a all in one pull out pantry - I have been looking for someone who had drawers up high like that. are you still happy with them? What is your opinion about a bank of drawers that go up to 82"? My hubby is a bit concerned about how they might look. Opinion about that too? cabinet and drawer fronts would look much like this vanity he built for our 1/2 bath out of white oak. would love your thoughts, am I missing something to consider about having drawers up high (we will use blum ones that are low with a rail on both sides).

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    lobolrw, I have turned that house into a rental property and my tenant absolutely LOVES them. I miss those over the fridge drawers dearly!! If my memory serves me, the top of those drawers measured 87" and the bottom of the drawer was at 74" It works perfect for tall cereal boxes too, so don't be afraid to have a taller drawer. I think to make the bank of drawers not look odd, a consistent size of drawer face would be key. I think if you have one drawer, not two side by side like I did/do, you can access the drawer pretty easy and not have to worry about items falling off the side. That's another reason why I opted for a full height side, along with back and front, so taller items wouldn't tip over. Also it provided a lot of strength allowing me to have that third glide and put heavier items in those drawers at times.

    btw, nice job on the cabinet!

    I'm currently racking my brain on how to deal with the cabinets above my new fridge!!! They do have independent drawers inside, behind the cabinet door (total pain) but the bottom of the door is at 83" and the top is at 104" making them virtually useless.............for now :/ but im on it!!!



    Ellessebee, this might come too late to catch you before you build........just finished that myself! Anyway, one thing I did in the bathrooms was to flip the sink basin cabinet upside down and make a drawer out of that false drawer front that's usually at the top of the cabinet. It's come in super handy.

  • 10 years ago

    olldcan thanks for the update, the consistent drawer front size is something DH mentioned too, great minds think alike LOL. I'm so proud of DH and the work he and


    son did on the cabinet. DH has finished putting the cove n bead woodwork on 2 walls of the 2nd stateroom, pic above and below, and it looks amazing!! this is what will be on all of the walls when we are done (in the next 50 or so years, ha ha).

    I had been struggling with figuring out the best way to use the closet that he sits in front of in the salon (it will be a mini office supply) then it dawned on me that we could do a bank of drawers for that too. File drawer on the bottom, scanner in a drawer, printer in a drawer, supplies and binders in drawers. When you are looking forward in the salon you would see both drawer banks so will work out how to make them similar enough so that the size of the drawer fronts blend together. I'm always excited to find that 'just right' solution for utilizing the little space we have. So glad that we were not able to gut and reno the place right off the bat as with time and thought and living aboard we've come up with much better storage, layout ideas than we had at first.

  • 9 years ago

    olldcan can you tell me again what you used to store in the over the refrigerator cabinet drawers? I just brought this idea to my cabinet guy to make for me but wasn't sure what I would be storing up that high that would be in a drawer. Thx.