Software
Houzz Logo Print
jrb451

Tesla's New "Wall Battery"

11 years ago

Right now, all of the examples I'm reading have to deal with storing solar power for use at night or during high peak times. Couldn't these be used just like a home generator storing power from the grid for use during a power outage? Seems to me that the price for these will go down and compete for this business. I'm looking at $8,000 to $12,000 to retrofit my home with a NG whole house generator.

Comments (7)

  • 11 years ago

    We would like to be able to do the same thing, use PV with batteries instead of a generator. You would have to consider - if the electricity goes out, how long do you think it will be out? Figure out how much electricity you need to cover that time period. Would any of that electricity be generated by the PV or will you need the batteries for all of it. We figure three days for a hurricane or ice storm and not sure what the skies would be like for generating power during those three days.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Generators dont store electricity, they 'generate' it with a motor and stator and some form of fuel to run the motor, in your case natural gas. Generators make alternating current, the same as your power line.

    Storage requires a battery, and is direct current. Direct current needs to be converted to alternating current for house use. People looking at using solar have to get the solar panels for energy capture, batteries for storage, converter for house use, and of course the labor to install it correctly. This is why solar is normally a decent sized investment.

  • 8 years ago

    Anyone installed one of these? Just wanting to hear what your experiences are.

  • 8 years ago

    Considering the fanfare for the Powerwall launch a few years ago (2015, I think) it's surprisingly hard today to find reports of successful implementations.

    Tesla has a small, low-traffic forum for the Powerwall here. What I read isn't too encouraging, I'm sorry to say.

    I've read elsewhere that Powerwall availability will be pretty limited for a while, at least until the Tesla "Gigafactory" is fully up to speed. And I suspect that keeping the automotive assembly line supplied will be a higher priority, so it could be quite a while.

    I'm far from an AE expert, so I defer to those who are. But if I were building an AE system today, I'd be more inclined to store my energy in something less proprietary, more readily available, and more user-maintainable than a Powerwall.

    jrb451 thanked DavidR
  • 8 years ago

    I signed up on their website a few months ago to be contacted when the batteries became available in my area. I spoke with an electrician who said he knew of a developer that was wanting to put a wall battery in his new builds. Not sure if it would be Tesla's.

  • 8 years ago

    Davidr posted a very nice summary of battery chemistries that might be available for home power. Anyone interested in this thread that has not read it probably should.

    The problem with implementing some battery types might be inverter and charge controller compatibility with respect to voltage. It might not be a problem at all, but might share a common problem with the batteries themselves and that is the manufacturing economies of scale.

    The trouble with batteries is two-fold. They are not perfect and don't give back all the power that is put into them. Second, they don't last forever. For a typical homeowner looking solely for a backup energy source, a genset will outlast a set a batteries every time. Trust me, the solar installers all know this.

    Nickel-iron batteries last a long time, but come at a cost that most homeowners won't consider when they see the lead-acid alternatives that are more expensive than a genset to start with. ROI for the iron-nickel is going to be longer than the lifetime of anyone thinking of buying them. The market is more like boutique rather than lead-acid commodity.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio