Can I build a raised garden on top of old stumps/roots of tree system?

7 years ago

Hello,

I had 5 very old and large rhododendron in my front yard that was blocking a window. We are remodeling the kitchen and that window has now become the sink window and has become a much bigger deal to have light and sight out of. While the rhododendron were pretty for a few weeks of the year, the rest of the time they are fairly ugly. I also wanted to repurpose that area as a vegetable garden. We decided to completely remove them but cutting them down at the ground level. This leaves a stump and I assume a substantial root system under the ground. If I wanted to turn this area into a vegetable garden, could I just build a raised bed on top of the old dirt/stump/root system? Do you see any issue doing this? Will it work? Do I just need to make sure the raised bed is deep enough on it's own to support the plants?

We also have a juniper that either smells like natural gas or cat piss next to the front door we want to remove. I also want to remove it for the smell reasons and turn that into a garden area as well. Same questions applies.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

digdirt2
7 years ago
The toxicity of rhododendrons aside (although I'm sure that would concern some folks) cutting them off at ground level doesn't kill them. They regrow and the roots continue to invade easily so you would constantly be dealing with those issues no matter how deep you make the bed. You really need to first deeply dig out as much of them as possible.

And if kitchen light is the goal keep in mind how tall many garden crops get, especially in a raised bed.

Lastly keep in mind the damage that can result to your siding having the garden flush up against the house wall. You'll want to insure the slope is sufficient for good drainage, that sun exposure will be adequate, and you might want to consider using one of the many pest barriers between the house wall the the back of the bed.

Just some thought to consider.

Dave
0
Embothrium
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Rhododendron roots underneath not a problem. These shrubs are not going to grow new shoots up through a bed of sufficient depth to grow vegetables - especially root crops like carrots - and their slow-growing, sod-like, aeration sensitive roots are anything but invasive. Likewise these plants being poisonous if eaten does not pertain to this situation.

The shading of the vegetables by the house, protecting the house from the soil in the new bed, access to the side of the house for maintenance and repairs, access to the bed with the house right up against one side, those are the kinds of things that will be likely to become problems if a raised bed is built in that location.
0
Related Professionals
Bridgetown Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Peabody Landscape Contractors · Aloha Landscape Contractors · Brockton Landscape Contractors · Duarte Landscape Contractors · Natick Landscape Contractors · Tamarac Landscape Contractors · Teaneck Landscape Contractors · Wilton Landscape Contractors · Tyngsboro Landscape Contractors · Fairfax Driveway Installation & Maintenance · Grand Rapids Driveway Installation & Maintenance · New River Driveway Installation & Maintenance · The Woodlands Driveway Installation & Maintenance · Rochester Hills Driveway Installation & Maintenance
glib
7 years ago
dead stumps are good (they provide better soil than regular dirt, due to micro-channels and fungi), stumps that are still alive are bad. Consider what Dave says, my pole beans regularly get to 12 ft, and tomatoes can get to 8. If it is all low-growing vegetables (eggplants or lower), and if it is in the sun, it should work fine.
0
Jason
Original Author
7 years ago
Hi All,

Thanks for the feedback. This particular bed is one of 5 areas so I will make sure to select vegetables that do not get too tall and leave the tall ones to the other garden beds. The area gets good sun and I will have access on all sides of the bed. The note about protecting the house is a good one and I will take that in mind.
0