what else are you planning to do? patio furniture, planting? painting the front door should be on that list as well.

The fence is gone and there is landscaping all around the front/side now. I just didn’t have a clear recent photo handy.
I am thinking yellow for the front door. Maybe brown for porch floor, porch furniture is natural wicker/wood. I am not sure what to paint the shutters and sidelights yet.

It is the same roof in both photos.

Is the paint in bad shape? I'm not understanding why you need to re-paint for sale?

Leave the porch the color it is, remove the itty bitty shutters. yellow would be nice, I dont think its too dark, and I do think a bold blue/gray is current.

Yes. It is severly faded and blotchy where siding was replaced after a storm.

I like the color it is right now. I would be painting it the same color. With the dark roof, nothing darker than what is there now.

There is a row of paint dilemmas below my post starting with Help, painters tomorrow! I guess we all have a crisis of confidence the night before. ☺️.

Going very dark on your siding will eliminate a portion of the buyer pool for your home.

Since you are selling the house and painting it to sell, consider a lighter color preferably not in the blue family. Buyers have a very strong reaction to blue: they love it or hate it IME. I'm a Realtor so I see this divide with strong colors in my area. A good agent in your area can tell you what colors work for resale too.

Depending upon the final color you select, the yellow doors would be fabulous. Here are a couple of combos for your consideration with different front door colors:

^Yellow siding and navy front door with white trim including sidelites.

^Blue with yellow door. You can see that this is beautiful, but would eliminate some buyers right from the beginning.

^Very neutral siding.

^Sage green

^If you end up selecting dark gray, then use this yellow front door and white sidelites with the brass/gold tone lamps. It looks very clean and welcoming IMO.

What area are you in? I am an hour and 1/2 outside Atlanta in the mountains. Craftsman style houses are super popular here. My house isn’t craftsman by any stretch, but I thought going with more of that type of color scheme might be a plus?

Gray has kind of “had it moment and moved on” here.

My first thing would be to remove the undersized shutters .I agree the same as it is with a yellow door will look nice .

Your home isn't Craftsman. Don't try to make it one. Select a lighter color for the body that is complimentary to the roofing shingles. The Georgia sun is hard on dark colors and will reduce your pool of buyers. Get rid of the shutters. They are fake and look fake. For your pop of interest, paint the front door a brighter color. Clear yellow and bright red are great colors. If you are putting it on the market in the next few weeks, yellow mums in pots will look great.

Any suggestions besides SW Outerspace? That is the lightest of the color samples I got and the one my husband is lobbying for. It looks French country blue on my house!! I can’t see a buyer wanting it either. It photographs much richer than in person. .

If it is not too late, check out SW Pewter Tankard. I used it in a color match by BM in Aura. My exposure is west/southwest. Our colors seem similar.

This is an older picture before new landscaping, etc.