the dull finish from soaking is b/c too much sealer. The best you can do is apply with a spray bottle and hope you get as much surface as possible w/o turning each and every stone. but wind and fallen leaves will always get in the way. Seems like a lot of work for limited result. Besides, perfectly shiny stones might look fake.

Perfectly shined stones looked great two years ago :-) The current dull look in the picture is just dirt (not sealer residue). I tried cleaning a coupe of rocks only (with detergent, sealant etc.). Washing in a bucket of water with detergent one wheelbarrow at a time works well (I have a laborer who is ready to do it) - the rocks are much cleaner and shinier than what you see in the picture after the simple wash, but I want the original shine back. Spraying that many rocks is just not realistic, alas :(

Sorry I wasn't clear. You said that you read online that soaking in sealer would result in milky residue. I was addressing the why of that particular statement, not to your pic. The white residue thing happened to me, that's how I know. Seems like spraying sealer would b easier than loading rocks and washing although spraying is not the most uniform application.

oh, gotcha. So you think if I soak in sealer, and put the stones in some sort of makeshift strainer to let the excess sealer to drip off, then it should be fine?

The stones are artificially 'tumbled' that is to say, they are worn smooth (in a way nature would) but undergoing a much faster process, by the addition of metal grit, which wears them away, and finally, by use of a chalky powder, or pumice, to create the shine.

This is done on an industrial scale, so the process is not as refined or precise, as one would achieve by tumbling small amounts of stones, as | have done...

Over time, due to exposure to the elements and to one another, the 'shine' is worn off.

In order to restore the shine as it once was - you either need to polish them with chalk dust (as a mild abrasive) or re-tumble them.

I used a sealer high gloss (chomatin high gloss paver sealer) the stone on didnt work this one is thicker, consistency more like glucose syrup) i just chucked them in a large container with holes at bottom and place that container into a larger one, then i poured the sealer into bucket and once i was satisfied all rocks were covered I pulled the inner container out and left them on a new clean white sheet and let them dry till next day.

Dinah, Did you ever land this? I have a ton too(!) of polished stones in landscape. Mine are 1-2" Mexican stones (mostly blue) and looked amazing for the first year and a half, now dulling.

I'm not sure if u have solved your rock luster problem since the last post was in April. But, in case you have not, i decided to chime in because I now have the same problem and feel as though I've come up with a rather brilliant, economical, labor/ environmentally friendly, & (not totally sure yet, but i think it may have) some longevity.

I just sprayed Pam over the rocks and they look brand new. Just regular 'ol, nonstick spray & they're original luster is back.

So, you may want to try it and let me know if you have the same results.

William, I am just seeing your question. I did solve this: by hiring smb to manually wash the rocks. Bucket by bucket he was removing them, washing (in a bucket of water with cloth, then rinsing) and putting back. Took him about 4 hrs for 1 ton. Wasnt too bad - labor is cheap in Texas

Here are pics of the Pam sprayed over my river rock...

Sounds brilliant! Its It's too bad I cannot try this solutionsolution- we have sold the house. Maybe I should email the new owners and suggest them this method!!!

Hi guys. I have read all your posts. I have recently added 3 tonnes of 40ml river pebbles in my yard. They were too heavy to shovel it across and finally accomplished that. But I hate the dry looks. I really love the look when wet. Can you pls help me with a solution to make them look wet without costing a fortune? I tried searching for PAM but looks like it’s not available in Bunning.

I am having this issue. My issue is the lime that collects on the rock. I ended up taking large plastic buckets and soaking the rocks in Lime-a-way until the rocks stopped bubbling (until the chemical stopped working). This removed all the collected lime but still didn't get the shiny polished original look. It got me 50% there and got all the white lime off.

Hi everyone, I have the same rock dilemma. Has anyone else tried the “Wet Look ”sealer? I’ve actually used oil such as an inexpensive olive oil in the past. Has anyone else tried that?

I diluted mineral oil in water and sprayed a section and so far it is holding up well. has not rained yet so I am not sure if that will change things.