Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
njohs

Refinishing honey oak staircase

njohs
7 years ago

We are refinishing and darkening our honey oak flooring and staircase that was built in 1999. We would like to go from the light, poly on oak color to a walnut stain. We have a professional doing the floor and treads of the stairs. We are going to attempt to refinish the railings and newel posts of the staircase ourselves (the balusters are painted white). I would like to get the oak down to bare wood so the same Dura Seal stain used on the floor can be used on the staircase. I do not like the look of gel stain or paint for the rails and newel posts. I have purchased Franmar Paint and Polyurethane Soy Gel Stripper to start removing the polyurethane on the staircase. I'm concerned about getting the polyurethane out of the grain of the oak to allow us to stain it a darker color. Due to the detail in the wood, I don't think sanding is an option. I'm scared to screw this up because it would be an expensive fix. Does anyone have any suggestions or advice?

Comments (4)

  • User
    7 years ago

    About the only sure way to do what you want done is to have a professional shop do the stripping. It is almost impossible to hand strip oak, for the reason you noted.

    My best advice, if you try this yourself, would be to use a stiff bristled nylon brush(like in the link) after letting the stripped sit and soak.

    Be aware, this means the detritus and chunks will be flung all over the area and make a HUGE mess.

  • Debbie Downer
    7 years ago

    Hate to be Debbie Downer but If you are a newbie at refinishing - you couldnt have picked a more difficult project due to the intricate nature of a staircase railing ..... as opposed to something flat like table or door. I would see if I could negotiate something with w professional - ie if I was to do the grunt work of stripping off most of the old poly maybe he would give a discount for doing the final futzing with stripping/sanding and applying the finish.

    If you arent a newbie, if you know how tricky it is to get into all the tiny nooks and crannies and can get your hands on or canfashion some tools for getting in to the small places then what the heck, go for it - it can be a labor of love and so it takes you a while - a post every weekend is a realistic goal. Of course it would be better to do this before the treads are refinished - that goop has a way of getting everywhere

    If it was the old hide glue you could disassemble it to refinish but I dont know if that's possible with modern glues.

  • chas045
    7 years ago

    Wouldn't it be vastly easier to simply remove the old railing, spindles and posts and purchase new everything? Aside from the huge length of working time, stripper is expensive. Or perhaps throw all removed parts into a commercial stripper tank?

  • klem1
    7 years ago

    I've never seen stripped wood take a nice stain unless sanded first.

Sponsored
Traditional Hardwood Floors LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Your Industry Leading Flooring Refinishers & Installers in Columbus