Don’t listen to your neighbors. I’ll bet they all have shutters. I’d go with the darker blue.

I also like the darker blue.

Up close I think both work. In your further away picture I think the dark blue wins!

I actually like the lighter one, and might even go for a lighter more teal one. Are you going for a pop or a POP?

I vote dark blue!

i thought both were too swimming-pool-bright. I'd go with a duskier blue.

the lighter one or neither! I'd look at more blues with undertones that would complement your brick. The lighter one is ok but another color would be better

A dark navy or black...

I think the blue in the bottom door rug is better...more gray, less bright. I would get rid of the top door mat and the wreath.

What are those blues? I agree, they are too swimmingpool-ish.

Your brick has too much pink for those blues. I would try for a bright navy like the first picture here: https://www.atticmag.com/2017/05/front-door-blues/

Or a deeper navy if the entryway is bright enough to keep the navy from feeling like a dark hole (like Hale Navy).

Or a grayer blue like Bunglehouse blue:

Anna, one of my very trusted Houzzer's also suggested Hale Navy. I like this Bunglehouse Blue too and will look at both!

I prefer a darker blue color or navy blue like previous people have suggested!