

Olthof Homes
https://www.houzz.com/pro/olthofhomes copied to clipboard
Home Builders
About Us
Welcome to Olthof Homes, your premier new home builder! We currently have beautiful communities throughout Indiana in Dyer, Schererville, St. John, Crown Point, Cedar Lake, Chesterton, Portage, Valparaiso, Fort Wayne, Westfield, Noblesville, Cumberland, and Brownsburg, and Illinois, in Plainfield. We offer collections of new home plans including single family homes, maintenance-free villas, paired villas, and townhomes.
Olthof Homes commits to provide the best home building experience through offering a variety of communities, floor plans, and options to design your new home, as well as award-winning customer service.
In 1961, Fritz Olthof started on his home builder path constructing his first set of new homes in Lansing, Illinois. He performed much of the building process himself and that personal touch is still evident throughout Olthof Homes today.
At Olthof Homes, our mission is to inspire better living by building better homes and communities.
Services Provided
Floor Plans, Modular Home Construction, New Home Construction
Areas Served
Cedar Lake, Crown Point, Dyer, Merrillville, Saint John, Schererville, St John, Chesterton, Westfield, Valparaiso, Portage, Plainfield, Noblesville, Brownsburg, Fort Wayne, Cumberland
Awards
2019 AVID Award for Customer Service, A+ Better Business Bureau Rating, 2020 Times Best of the Region (9 years running) , 2020 Best of Northwest Indiana Business (5 years running)
Write a Review











67 Reviews for Olthof Homes
Newest first
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5|67 reviews
Work Quality4.2
Communication4.7
Value4.2

HU-937177132
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
Both Derek and Paul were extremely helpful and professional! They made me even more excited to be purchasing my home! Thank you both!!!!
April 5, 2022

HU-953684267
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
Great working with Maggie. She is keeping us informed on the entire process. Looking forward to moving into our new home.
March 21, 2022

HU-921471330
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
Just listen. I know builders get reviews great to horrible. That is the business they are in. My job isn't to oversell, or to demolish. The reason for my review is to do just that. Review. I am a fair judge of character and my perceptions are usually based on fact. That being said thos is what I think of Olthof homes. Incannot soeak for every home or owner, but the experience my wife and I have had has been very good, if not great. They have been honest, and helpful, friendly and patient. We had a long road on our side of the transaction process and Shelley Jones was right there with us step for step, the whole way. Her great attitude and ability to listen and provide helpful information to two very needy people, that changed their minds more than the weather, was so instrumental in the success of our decision. She gave great feedback and prompt response to whatever we needed. She is a pro and the template for how to treat customers. That being said, the house is beautiful, the service and craftmanship we have had is solid. They have a hardworking professional named James Huddleston that went above and beyond so many times for us we can't even count. Any maintenance question, concern, or request was handled immediately, and almost ALWAYS way beyond what we asked for. He is so friendly and helpful, I really can't say enough about his help during inspections and walk through, and beyond. This team works very hard and they have our gratitude!
November 19, 2020

jennifer_hucek
Average rating: 2 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
We purchased a spec house from Olthof in Walden Clearing subdivision almost one year ago. We just had our 11 month warranty walk through and I have to say, am beyond disappointed in the handling of some of our issues. We were told that some defects were not "bad" enough to be fixed. While our experience with the sales team was genuine and all the employees that we have spoken with have been extremely courteous, the answers we have gotten have been on the cold side. The concrete in our driveway is cracking and breaking off and we were told to seal it ourselves with waterproof caulk. Our cabinet doors are splitting and again we were told we should be able to fix that ourselves, while they will fix the "really bad" ones. The paint used in our house must have been extremely watered down because it is just absolutely terrible. Although Olthof will come back out and fix some things, for the price of the house, these little things should not have been "forgotten." I.E. sanding our banister and adding the protective top coat. Our home itself is beautiful and we are thankful for it but the issues coming up and lack of care is truly disappointing. We purchased a new home because we did not want to have to fix previous home owners shoddy work - well now we just have to fix the builders shoddy work - pick your poison, I guess.
October 23, 2020Last modified:October 29, 2020

HU-638589865
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
This company built our house
We moved into our new home at Walden Clearing St’John .. The whole process was so smooth .. Steven Hoeflich was our contact person from the very beginning, he is one of the most amicable and helpful persons we’ve ever met and was always readily available. The whole team of Olthof Homes deserve a shoutout. We never had any major issues or hiccups and whatever minor issues we had were taken care of at the first month inspection. We are very much content and are enjoying our new home. Thank you Steven and the entire team of Olthof Homes.
Anirban and Paromita Chakraborty
September 18, 2019Last modified:September 18, 2019

Ivery Williams
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
I am writing this letter to personally compliment several team members of Olthof Homes on their exceptional customer service delivered to me. Shelley, James, Bill and Stephanie was very professional. Shelley was amazing at helping me find my very first home. From the best layout, to color choices, to even down to some help with some security measures, she answered all my questions even on her days off. They all helped me through the entire process & this has been a long process, but the time has come to close, 4 days away. They truly deserve the appreciation. Please keep up the hard work and thank you again for all your assistance and help throughout the entire process.
August 19, 2019

Byron Delcid
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
none
I started to look at Olthof Homes about 2 years before my wife and I put our old home on the market. I made contact with Adrian Pedraza at Olthof Homes in Plainfield and he was so helpful providing me with all the information I requested and the liberty to come in multiple times to see the different model homes that I was extremely pleased with him. Then we found out Olthof Homes was coming to the new subdivision two miles north of my old home in Romeoville and I started to talk to the wife and we got the wheels in motion to purchase one for ourselves. We met with Adrian and asked about building new, he took us through two brand new models ready to sell to see what we liked and instead of building new and waiting 9-10 months we bought one of the homes we walked through which is our dream home. The purchasing process was so easy with Olthof homes, they were up front about everything and even now 3 months after we bought our new home olthoff keeps in touch with us to make sure our experience with them is the best and you know wehat? it is! my wife and I highly recommend Olthof Homes.
April 3, 2019Last modified:April 3, 2019

jd22283
Average rating: 1 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
These people built my home last year and it is actually awful. Paint has runs and overspray, drywall work is sloppy, the walls literally ice up inside the house in some places on cold days due to poor insulation, the floors are creaky, the home is impossible to properly heat or cool and our NIPSCO bills are $400 - $600 trying to do so. They really don't seem to care about anything after you are in the house and will just send you a canned letter for everything that basically says it is not their fault/problem or else they make you wait months to fix something and you go back and forth via email and phone. The warranty is a joke.
March 23, 2019Last modified:March 23, 2019

John Livingston Jr
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
The process of purchasing the home was fantastic. Steven was very helpful and knowledgeable. He was extremely polite as well.
The selections process was very smooth and they were very helpful in terms of interior design decisions.
The quality of the home was slightly below satisfactory in my opinion for the price. The wholes in the dry wall for the outlets and fans were cut too large and show past the covers. Some areas of the trim/drywall are uneven and appear wavy. I also have experienced lumps underneath the carpeting. The paint quality is terrible as well. In my opinion, the construction of the home was focused more on speed than quality.
March 19, 2019
Comment from Olthof Homes:
We are glad that you had a fantastic experience with purchasing and designing your new home, John! The issues that you mentioned were noted during your warranty work day and will be taken care of quickly! We will work to make sure those items are addressed and rectified in the future. Speed is important but quality work is more important. If there is anything else we can do for you in the meantime, please let us know!

JoAnna Campione
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Buyer
My husband and I decided to build a home with Olthof this past March, and we have been completely satisfied with the whole process from beginning to end! Steve was very helpful and knowdlegeable about the whole process, and was very patient with me and the many questions that I had :). Everyone with Olthof, from our selections meeting to or walk through, have been great to work with. We love our new home and our new community here in Silver Leaf!
November 15, 2018

Mandy Gilson
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
I'm very happy with Olthof Homes. I love my new home and this subdivision. There were a few hiccups when we moved in, but they were taken care of immediately.
October 22, 2018

Shelia McElfresh
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Relationship
Client
We are very pleased with our experience buying an Olthof home. Derek was very helpful and willing to answer any questions we had Richard, the project manager was equally helpful during our walk through. Everyone has been very friendly and easy to work with.
October 4, 2018
Contact Olthof Homes
Find Custom Home Builders to Help Get the Job Done
Tired of reading all the DIY tutorials? We are here to help. With over 1 million home professionals on Houzz, you’ll easily find the trusted Custom Home Builder for your next project in Saint John, IN.
Read Reviews from Saint John Homeowners Like You
Read homeowners reviews before hiring the Custom Home Builder to help with your project in Saint John. If you have questions, read other homeowners’ reviews or our discussion forum for a second opinion.
Easily Contact Trusted Custom Home Builders
If you’re browsing Houzz and have a contractor in mind, then you’ll quickly find that requesting a quote is easier than ever. From one simple dashboard, you can manage all the Custom Home Builder quotes you got.
Home Builders near Saint John
Professional Categories in Saint John
Saint John Interior Designers & Decorators · Saint John Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Saint John Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Saint John Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Saint John Landscape Contractors · Saint John Swimming Pool Builders · Saint John Cabinets & Cabinetry · Saint John Carpenters · Saint John Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Saint John Door Dealers
5 Comments