A picture of my layout might help

I think having 5 lights hanging down might be a lot...will you also have a chandelier over your kitchen table? We were going to put a light hanging over our sink but opted not too. We also have the same lanterns that are looking at. I love them!
Here's a pic:

It's you! Your kitchen is where I first saw them - they look so nice, I just fell in love : )

I was afraid it might be too much. Now what to do? I could put a recessed light over the sink since there's a hole there already but on either side of the range? I dunno. Look harder for a small ceiling light that I like and can afford? Help me, please.

My opinion is that the two lanterns over your island and the hood will be too much with the two pendants next to the hood in the same line of sight with all of that and the windows. The hood and two pendants and windows is plenty to focus on. If this were my kitchen, I'd make those two recessed and do the pendant over the sink.

We had an open plan where it could have easily been overkill with a lot of hanging fixtures. We have three pendants over the island and an informal chandelier over our parallel dining table. Along with that I put small Hudson Valley ceiling fixtures (Sutton) over the sink and window seat (in the dining area). They're unobtrusive and high enough that they don't disrupt the flow of everything else the way a pendant would. That could be an option for you. You can search my finished kitchen to see what we did. You may even want to opt for something like that over the sink (instead of a pendant) and recessed next to the range hood.

Babs711 - wow, I totally missed your kitchen (I'm a sporadic gardenwebber), it's beautiful, as is your whole house (did you frame the drawing from your dd?) I wish I was done. We are also going to have a dining table parallel to the island and a windowseat too.

So, you say recessed lighting over the island. That must be pretty radical, no? I really like the little lights that you have. I couldn't do those with the lanterns? How about smaller pendants instead of the lanterns?

I love the lanterns and wanted them but ended up going with a hexagon shape. But I still covet the square.
I would only do the island pendants and maybe a sink.

finestra - thank you for chiming in. Well, it seems pretty clear that it would be too much with everything.

I kind of think I could use some lighting on that range wall. Those will just be open shelves on that wall so I wasn't planning any ucl. Although I gues I could. Should I try to get over those big beautiful lanterns? Something like this instead?

Would that still be too much?

No no! I think you should do the lanterns over the island. But I'd nix pendants at the windows because I think I will make things cluttered. I'd do either recessed or a small ceiling fixture as we did over our sink. I'd do a matching treatment over your sink. Either a small ceiling or a recessed. But definitely do the lanterns!!

Thanks for the kitchen compliments. The thread was going for a while! I'm glad I could help!!

Thank you, babs711. Okay two lanterns and three small ceiling lights. I would love to get yours but I would love to spend less money even more. I'll see what I can find even though I feel like death warmed over. Why is my whole family including me sick? Why can't Mommys call in sick?

Sorry for the whine. I think this will be the light over my dining table - because we're silly.

Still okay?