Perhaps BM Chelsea Grey or if you want lighter Revere Pewter

I like Irenes choices of colors as yes your home needs a new look, look at your neighbors homes to go between them and see if the gray color would go with others.

Ken

Thank you for your responses. I am attaching a couple more photos to show the main color of the house, which is kind of a brown mustard...not sure how to describe it. I just want to make sure that the main color of the house is shown.

Another of the main color of the house.

Garage Door Refacing

We've decided to paint the entire house now because we think that painting just the trim and not the main house doesn't make sense. We were thinking of a white for the main house and a brown for the trim, garage doors and the pergola....but we are not sure what white and brown would be best for our home. We are open to other suggestions as well. We would appreciate if you could provide the names and brand of the paint being suggested.

In your idea book, the house with white paint is trimmed with Wenge (BM) which would be a nice contrast with your tile roof.

What Irene posted is lovely.. I would do the same.

What you be a good white (on stucco) to go with the Chelsea Gray? I'm liking the idea. I've also seen white with brown trim and gray highlights?

is more of a calming off-white and almost has a more ‘creamy/greige’ feeling

White Dove by BM with Chelsea Gray IMO would be pretty. Doesn't lean yellow

We ended up going with Sherman Williams bohemian black for the trim, ivory lace for the house and Chelsea gray (BM) for the garage doors and the other doors of the house. Thanks for all your help!!

Some lighter trim and then return the pergola to a stained wood!