Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
3pinktrees

De-Tuscan-ing: faux finish fireplace ideas

3pinktrees
5 years ago

We moved into a beautiful home that was styled ‘Tuscany.’ I love the home and the bones and am planning to take it in a English gentleman’s Country home direction (is that a thing?). Sort of opulent minimalism? Anthropologie meets actual farmhouse? Because it’s also on a little farmette. Anyway, I want to move away from the yellow walls and golden faux finish to something that lets the limestone fireplace shine. I was looking at BM Century Blue Muscari, but when I moved into this place, it looks wrong in the light.


The furniture, etc, is from the previous owners and is gone.


The floor is Brazilian cherry. The built-ins are quality and we will not be painting them.


Thank you so much for any ideas you have for me!




Comments (52)

  • tartanmeup
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I can see opulent and minimal together, if I understand opulent to mean "having or indicating wealth" (Collins' first definition). You can have minimal furnishings that are all obviously high quality. The terms aren't contradictory to me. :)

    I agree with Patricia that the surround does not work well with the built-ins. On this chimney, the surround actually looks superfluous to me. I'd be tempted to go with a minimal (marble?) tile surround. This kind of look (except better because your surround would harmonize with your floor :)):


  • drdeb1234
    5 years ago
    Your description of what you would like is quite confusing. Maybe spend time browsing the millions of photos on houzz and save and post some inspiration pics. It will help the people here get a better sense of your vision.
  • tartanmeup
    5 years ago

    Googled "opulent minimalism" and found this blog post. Here's a minimal but opulent fireplace:


  • Mary beth Grice
    5 years ago

    For sure start with wall color change ! Change to a rich color on fireplace area,moving to a lighter or complimentary lighter color on walls. Taking colors from the painting over fireplace would be perfect. Perhaps a red-brown on fireplace jut out and solid tan on the walls, like SW Canvas Tan,or a navy on fireplace wall jut out with a cool grey walls. If the artwork is gone, find art with the feeling you want to put forth and work with it.


  • wmsimons85
    5 years ago

    Lovely home but It would be interesting to see some mock ups especially with those dark units painted. I LOVE the fireplace in Tartanmeups inspiration photo. Gorgeous! Perhaps you could change the sides for something more simple like that one and maybe take out the insert?

    I agree Patricia‘s comment about painting that faux wall white for now to help decide what to do with it.

  • tartanmeup
    5 years ago

    Just had a look at your ideabooks, 3pinktrees. You saved the type of minimal opulent fireplace I had in mind: Industrial LR - minimal fireplace

    (Don't know why I can't insert the photo here...)

  • apple_pie_order
    5 years ago

    Please pick out some new inspiration photos you love. Right now, your ideabook is full of industrial looks, not English country homes.


    What are your favorite features of the house? You can upload some current photos now that you've moved in and the sellers' furniture is gone.


  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    Thank you all for the comments! Yes, I didn’t even think about doing new idea books. The ones I have now are from a former home remodel. I’ve collected a lot of inspiration photos on other sites.


    I guess the look I’m going for is the feel of a house where the furniture is elcletic, classic, and quality. As if it were a collection of pieces bought over the years that just ‘works’ together. I love quality fabrics and rich colors.


    I want to repaint the yellow tones on the walls. I will work on more photos for you all.


    I truly appreciate the help!

  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    Ok, so I added some pictures I liked to my ideabook— not perfect, but at least it’s a start.


    And here’s some from my house— it’s sparsely furnished because some of my stuff is staging the old house and I need to decide what I want for the rest.


    a spot I love:



  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    Those French doors above lead to a sunroom.


    Heres the living room:



  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    And the wall to the left of the fireplace:



  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    And to the right to the front door:




  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    The house looks a little bit fairytale cottage from the outside.


    I guess I want it to like like a house Cinderella would live in after she grew up and had 6 kids— a little bit whimsical, little bit sophisticated. I have a vision in my head, but I’m having trouble actualizing it into something concrete.


    Also, I said we wouldn’t paint the built-ins, but I’m pretty sure I could talk my husband into it depending on the plan :).

  • tartanmeup
    5 years ago

    Beautiful home, 3pinktrees! I don't see anything in your ideabook though?

  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    Thank you tartan! I will check— maybe it’s on private on accident

  • User
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I like your idea of using a dark teal. if BM Century Blue Muscari didn't work, then play around with undertones. I wanted to do dark teal for my guest bath and wound up choosing something with a much stronger yellow/green undertone than I originally imagined.

    Also, I've been loving some of the navy blues people have been going with these days.

    either way, a dark color would look SO good with that limestone and the dark brown built ins. I'd add a few gold accents here and there.

  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    So my ideabook is called ‘cottage’ — it’s not set to private. Is it still not showing up?

  • wmsimons85
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    That view! Just gorgeous!! What an exciting project.

    I don’t see a lot of leftover “Tuscan” in your photos with the exception of the lights maybe. Simplfiying and painting will go such a long way in your beautiful home.

  • tartanmeup
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    If I click on ideabook from your profile page, it's not there but I went through your activity (stalker alert!) and clicked on the link from 17 hrs ago and I see your pictures. (The site can be glitchy.)

    Very nice pictures! Traditional, English. And yes, minimalist in its expression because the rooms aren't crowded with furniture.

    Link to your ideabook (in case others are having similar access issue).

    3pinktrees thanked tartanmeup
  • PRO
    BeverlyFLADeziner
    5 years ago

    I would think changing from Tuscan to Mediterranean might be reasonably easy.











  • wmsimons85
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Oh gosh Beverly those are just gorgeous!!! Love them! I can imagine any of those rooms with 3pinktrees view. :)

  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    Thank you all for your kind comments! The property really is so idyllic and I'm excited to make it feel like our own home.


    A couple questions:


    If I did paint the built-ins, should I do them white or a color?


    I like the look of this color, any guesses as to what might give this effect? If I repainted the main walls in a cream, could I get away with this for an accent wall?



    Or maybe this green? Or is it just too dark?




    I love blues and greens. The tray ceiling in the dining room is currently painted maroon and there is a heavy faux-Tuscan chandelier in there. I need to repaint the tray and choose a chandelier. My ideal would be something vintage, gilded, with a slightly botanical or whimsical theme.


    I think I need to attack the fireplace surround first, but I'm having trouble visualizing the choices. My last two houses were much smaller in scale and therefore much easier projects. My last house was built in 1969 and we did it all in bright whites in the Swedish farmhouse style. I loved it, but want a totally different look for this house.


    I like those mediterranean inspired photos, but I think I want some more color in this house.



  • apple_pie_order
    5 years ago

    If you are eager to try things out before the rest of your furniture arrives, buy some big foamcore boards and some sample pots of a creamy linen white, a light celadon green, and whatever else takes your fancy. Paint the boards and prop them up here and there. Changing your lighting fixtures first will make a huge difference because the existing fixtures have golden yellow glass. You could also prime just the fireplace wall with a couple coats of white primer, then prop your foamcore on the mantle.

    I don't usually say this, but you may want to hire a color consultant once your furniture has arrived. It's a big, magnificent house that could require scaffolding or high ladders to paint, so it'd be good to get the paint color right the first time.

  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    3pinktrees, lovely home and you have gotten some good advice. I too would suggest getting help from a designer. As far as the beautiful green paneled room you love, that is painted and lightly antiqued. A costly application. As far as your built ins. I think they are too dark and too short . I would have ten reconfigured. I especially don’t like how they look in relation to your adjoining doors. Depending on the look you go with( the lovely Mediterranean feel a Beverly posted) or something else they could be lighter woodtone, match the wall color or off white. As they are now it gives this wall a disjointed feel.
  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    This is probably the right answer. I definitely plan on hiring out the painting, because the walls are too tall. I have someone who is willing to do a mural for me on one wall, I'm thinking some kind of chinoiserie. My budget is not huge, so I don't want to invest in hired out painting and be disappointed in the color. I can find the kinds of light fixtures I want myself, as I know the places to hunt for them. I do think working with an outside pair of eyes would be helpful to nail down a consistent color scheme for the whole main floor. It's such a pretty place that I want to get it right!

  • l pinkmountain
    5 years ago

    If you like chinoiserie you cheapest option would be wallpaper. I'll bet you could find something awesome. But if you're set on hiring someone to do it, best to just make that the star and pick complimenting colors from that. Looks like you have an aquatic vibe going with that stained glass. If you like green, there are various light greens that are fab, like a "beach glass" color and a grey blue like water color . . . Look up "chinoiserie color palette," you can find inspirations ranging from bold to watercolor.

    3pinktrees thanked l pinkmountain
  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    I’m sure painting will make a big difference! Just getting rid of the decorative finish will calm things down!
  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    I would save the chinoiserie for fabrics or wallpaper in the powder room! While I love chinoiserie it doesn’t always go everywhere so before you spend $$$ to have it painted on a wall formulate a design plan in here first! You can always find beautiful fabrics in this style to incorporate in drapes or pillows!
    3pinktrees thanked lynartist
  • Pugga70
    5 years ago

    Your home is very nice!! I'm curious to see the outcome.

    3pinktrees thanked Pugga70
  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Lynartist, that's good advice. I was planning on putting William and Morris bird and pomegranate in the aqua color way in the powder room. That room has a copper sink with embossed blossoming branches on it, so I thought something equally fanciful on the small back wall would be fun.

    There is a small recessed area in the entry where the original owners had an antique table/mirror thing. I had been thinking maybe to have the mural there. But maybe it would be better to find other things to pop and keep the walls simpler.

  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    Actually, here is some wallpaper I really love, because it reminds me of the old Unicorn Tapestry. But I haven't been able to locate it.




  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    That is arts& crafts. You need to try sourcing neo-classical, Victorian, aesthetic movement etc. wallpapers from art houses like Bradbury &Bradbury, Liberty, Osborne& Little,. Here are some samples I have.
    3pinktrees thanked lynartist
  • Bri Bosh
    5 years ago
    OP, I would focus on improving the bones before furniture... to pull off the look you’re going for, the home would benefit from some upgraded trim work, in particular.
  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    Lynartist, yes, I love bird and pomegranate! All of the W&M wallpapers are so lovely.


    Bri, I'd rather work with the trim and mold my vision to fit it. I get that my house isn't as 'intricate' as those in my idea photos, but I haven't found any pictures that truly capture the feel I want. I think I can work with the existing trim. It's done very well and substantial, so for me it's not worth considering pulling it all out, especially since the house is relatively new.

  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago



    I like this colorway with the gold accents

  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    I once did a large painting in this style; it was a loose canvas meant to be hung like a tapestry. Perhaps if you love this style you could get a WM tapestry to hang in your home and forgo the mural.
  • tartanmeup
    5 years ago

    That's gorgeous, lynartist! And what a great idea.

  • wmsimons85
    5 years ago

    That is beautiful Lyn but to me having that sort of tapestry reminds me very much of Tuscan! I do agree with Lyn when she suggested more neutral background instead and maybe accessorize with color. Even though those two photos you posted are beautiful, they are old and authentic. If you were to go that way it does seem like you would be going down the same path with faux in a new home like the Tuscan look was.


    But I do have to disclose I am a neutral girl and I find those photos that Beverly posted a bit drool worthy. :)

  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    That's an interesting point wmsimons. The lighter green picture is actually from a recently built home, but obviously built in an old style.


    I definitely don't want to have the house look like it's weirdly trying to be something it's not. At the same time, I'm wary that all creamy white may just take on a generic feel? Or maybe it's just because my last house was white I feel like I should do something different?


    All I know is this Tuscan yellow has to go!


    I actually lived near Tuscany for a year when I was younger, and one of my children was born there. Which might be why the faux Tuscan particularly bothers me!


    I have these giant upside-down bell jar flower pendants (the longest one in the photo, it's about 2' tall) to replace the kitchen pendants. They are my perfect fairytale lights (minus the ivy, of course). So that's a start!





  • 3pinktrees
    Original Author
    5 years ago

    I mean, this is so pretty....



  • wmsimons85
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Love those pendants! I love Tuscany but even when the faux Tuscan look was ”stylish” like you, I never liked it.

    That green is just gorgeous 3pinktrees! I have to admit I am a little OCD as far as something not being authentic and in your words, trying to be something that it’s not. I do like simple more than most, just ask Lyn. :))) It sounds like you know what you want and it will be gorgeous. Can’t wait to see what you do.

    3pinktrees thanked wmsimons85
  • wmsimons85
    5 years ago

    By the way, I just noticed that first photo you posted and it was used as an inspiration photo for the coffee table! Love the room.

  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    I love those pendants too! I think inspiration can come from anywhere; you needn’t take it too literally of course! Translate to your own style and comfort level.
  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    BTW, I do recall painting many variations of “ Tuscan” wall finishes in the day;)!
  • PRO
    BeverlyFLADeziner
    5 years ago

    There used to be a Ralph Lauren Glaze called Tea Stain. I had it installed over white walls to age the rooms a bit so they were not perfect. It could be applied to wallpaper or paint and came in various shades. It's perfectly Mediterranean.

    3pinktrees thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • Bri Bosh
    5 years ago
    Whoops sorry 3pinktrees; just saw your pics on my computer. On my phone it looked like the windows were just drywall returns. Disregard my trim comment!
    3pinktrees thanked Bri Bosh
  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    You can make your own Beverly. Just varying amounts of raw umber acrylic into a glazing compound of your choice will do plus water to thin makes a perfect tea stain.
  • wmsimons85
    5 years ago

    Gosh we had something similar in our house when we bought it. I knew what it was but my father thought it was smoke damage! Haha. Had it all painted over but a lot of areas needed a good priming first.

  • lynartist
    5 years ago
    Heehee! Well it can look very nice when used in the right way and sparingly!