Software
Houzz Logo Print
hobbzz

Training saucer magnolias

6 years ago

Picked up an alexandrina saucer yesterday, and a species and I'm wondering if you can train the trunks to grow in a more pendulas manner rather than straight up? I'm thinking kind of like you would train the overall shape of a bonsai tree by bending or straightening branches... If so, how late is to late to train the branches? Thanks!

Comments (8)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    As with many other kinds of trees these grow up at first then out later - nursery sized plants are much too young to be trying to impose a mature crown shape upon them. Because you are expecting them to already have one.

  • 6 years ago

    Ken - Alexandrina is 5-6 feet. Has one main trunk that out branches after about 4". The species is about 18" tall, very small.


    Embothrium - Are you saying that this species cannot/shouldn't be trained or that people simply don't do it?

  • 6 years ago

    i dont see how you start bending a 5 to 6 foot tree/shrub .. until its roots grab hold.. and will offer resistance to said bend ...sooo..same answer ... wait a few years ...


    i suppose you could splint new soft growth in some direction or other ... maybe some copper wire like the bonsai peeps ...


    i really dont understand what you are wanting to do ... but dont let that hold you back.. i have never seen an really cool.. out of the ordinary plant... that wasnt manipulated by some dude with a vision .. so .. go for it ..


    ken

  • 6 years ago

    Brent, can you explain in greater detail what you are hoping to achieve? I don't understand what you mean by "trunks to grow in a more pendulas manner rather than straight up?" Typically, it would be branches that are pendulous or drooping/weeping, not the trunk.

    And unless one is indulging in bonsai - a wholely different concept - I have a tough time with attempting to manipulate trees into a form they are not inclined to assume naturally. It seems so contrived.

  • 6 years ago

    Gardengal trunks was a typo. I did mean branches as you suspected. Now, the branches have a little curve but quickly climb straight up. They'll start to lay flatter with age (think live oak), but with our short growing season I'm not sure my wife and I will be alive to see that lol. I know some people manipulate magnolias into single trunk trees by pruning, just wondering if training branches was ever done successfully.

  • 6 years ago

    How about a picture? I’m not following ‘the species is 18” tall’. Bottom line, Magnolia x soulangiana doesn’t need any training or even pruning if sited where it has sufficient space. Alexandrina doesn’t have a pendulous habit so it’s going to be an exercise in frustration to try and force it into one.

  • 6 years ago

    Name 'Alexandrina' has been used since the 18th century so multiple different cultivars have been circulated. However when material is so-called it does carry an implication of a tree-like habit, with an elevated crown.