Lots of choices for a craftsman. No shutters. I think the details will be better appreciated with a darker color. Looks washed out now.

Some possibilities

Look at earthy colors and pick three like the photo above.

Here are come other options:

Front Exterior · More Info

Craftsman Exterior · More Info

AA Trueline Construction Services Inc. · More Info

Visuals for you

SW Roycroft Bronze Green and Real Red door

SW Sage Green Light and SW Real Red door

SW Rockwood Sash Green and SW Positive Red door

SW Rockwood Blue Green and SW Positive Red

SW Roycroft Bottle Green and SW Fun Yellow door

I agree with the poster that said to pick a darker color for your house. My favorite is the Rockwood Sash Green

I think you should paint the sashes as well.

Go to your local library or find used versions of books on Craftsman and/or Bungalow exteriors, "Bungalow Colors" comes to mind.

Oldhouseguy.com might also have some guidance.

Download the colorsnap app and match to the stone colors and chose you favorite. From the picture this is what I got. You can also save the palette and see the colors on the house

Hope you don't mind, I'm tagging @cpartist for you. Great eye for all things Craftsman, especially colour schemes.

it cut off this one in the screen shot sorry.

Dark, earthy!

Visuals from Lisa's color match app

SW Labradorite

SW Sensuous Grey

SW Shade Grown

SW Pachyderm

SW Smokehouse

SW Emerging Taupe

SW Chateau Brown

I would not do "earthy" if this is an area that's gloomy in winter. Definitely don't do "mud" if it rains a lot! IMO, since this is a new "Craftsman", you're not particularly tied to "authentic" craftsman colors.

I think I would add more heft to the decorative triangles in the large gable, but perhaps someone else can weigh in on this. This would be a simple (and not expensive IMO) adjustment. You will see on the model photos, that those triangles are bolder than yours.

Thank you everyone for the awesome recommendations! For reference I live in NC so it’s never really gloomy. I was thinking about a navy blue for

the siding with a creamish trim. Any thoughts about that? It’s not earthy.

And I’ve found a few other pics I like but don’t know if they would work in my house or what the actually color names are

I like the navy idea. Are your sashes and muntins vinyl or wood?

I do think a blue color would be great and thanks to Melissa great rendering, you have a preview of Labradorite.

I would do a natural wood door or Cool avocado.

Trim in Oyster White or Extra White.

@Anna (6B/7A in MD) They are vinyl and a bright white

Some darker blues

@Lisa Caudill Designs I like the idea of a natural wood door. I also have side doors that I need to paint or replace. If I did a natural wood for the front door do you have any recommendations for the side doors? They are fairly prominent on the house.

.

SW Charcoal Blue and Obstinate Orange

SW Anchors Aweigh and Obstinate Orange

Looks like they are French doors and they have that same door in that option, just double check your door widths

@Melissa R Thanks, I really like those color combos with the orange doors. Do you think a cream trim is better than a bright white?

I like white. Nice and crisp. To me a cream would just look like dirty white lol

I really like the Anchors Aweigh/Obstinate Orange combo!

I love this color palette. And definitely delete the shutters. Great house!

@Melissa R what do you use to create those renderings? I’ve tried using the ColorSnap app and they look awful. I’m trying to see what it would look like with navy siding and a yellow door.

I use the tool on the Sherwin Williams site.

SW Honey Bees

SW Daisy

SW Decisive Yellow

Off-white with wood trim

Or navy blue

with proper shutters?

I like the blue one celery just did. more of a grayer blue, or a greenish blue

and yes, correct sized shutters. the ones you have are too skinny. (or remove them completely. )

Don't forget the accent colors.

love this blue, but the adjoining warm wood really accents the look.

Pink not your thing? choose a coral, or green

this w/natural cedar looks beautiful. do the cedar shutters