Cream. It also goes with driveway.

Modern Spanish Remodel West Hollywood · More Info

Traditional Home West U Home with a Modern Twist · More Info

Here's a visual of my suggestions, a warm white for the stucco such as one similar to these which you'll need to test.

Large numbers, sconces, and pendant light. Shutters on the upper windows above the garage. I show the stone you mentioned to cover the bricks.

Improving the landscaping will contribute give a more finished look including higher planting along the walkway. You mentioned a wood door which is not in your pictures so I show all doors in wood.

I would not include shutters, or mouldings. Paint everything, including the garage door the same unifying color. I would use SW Polished Mahagony for the house and a pretty blue for the door. or even Urbane Bronze with Rain front entry door.

How funny, I used to live in this exact model house. We eventually painted it a creamy white. Your neighbors may hate you if the white is too bright. We did the cream garage door, too. We had no trim on windows and painted the front door a dark brown. This was a common scheme in the neighborhood of similar homes. Those who painted the garage door brown (or other dark color) didn’t account for the fast fading in the So Cal sun. Good luck and you brought back some memories.

I'm agreeing with alot of people here that a nice cream color would work well and I might suggest exploring lime washing the brick to neutralize it and maybe seeing if you can't fit a trellis over the driveway and get some vegetation around those open areas. Having fun with lighting fixtures would also be a sure fir way to spruce things up a bit. Good luck!

Over the years I have never heard many people say that they were happy they painted their old garage doors..mostly upgrading…replacing…adding a little more style…seemed to be more rewarding..on the most modest to the most elegant homes