Your roof and house body are so matchy-matchy colorwise. I'd go darker on the house, the reverse of the house in photo #1 below would be a good direction. House #2 is a contemporary craftsman. I don't think you can totally turn yours into one, but you can add some touches. For example, especially evident in your last photo are the "floating piers or wings" that seem to hold up the short roof extensions. I assume they are decorative, rather than functional, and could be removed and replaced with some oversized craftsman corbels that appear to hold up the roof extensions. See the corbels in the peaks of the gables. Your wall could be covered with more craftsman style stone. Your house numbers are very modern and could be replaced with craftsman style ones, but to get them that large they might need to be custom made. If there is a high school or tech college nearby that has a shop or metal working department it might make a good student project. Landscaping is a must.

HI -- Your house can only be the contemporary style it is . Not possible to be a craftsman or even a proper looking country farm house . You have a bit of a chance adding some farm country house touches . But this is a modern house , so trying to make into something else , it could end up looking odd. Maybe with color like a barn red ... Rusty Nail by BM paints .

Not sure if we're a fan of such large house numbers