well, the first one seems more traditional, the second more of an asian feel...are you going that way with your bathroom?

The second one is more distinctive, IMHO.

I had not seen that American Standard unit...thats beautiful! and Im a Grohe fan..not the same as Hansgrohe BTW

I love the 2nd one. Very clean lines, love it!

Hmmm.... Well Im not sure Im going for an asian look. Trying to mix modern & kind of a craftsman style. Im think of hex tiles or maybe basketweave on the floor. So Maybe I shouldnt get the green tea? Its pretty, but it might not work. I never thought faucet shopping would be so hard...

Should I go with something more traditional/victorian? Got anything you recommend?

It is very pretty, but I would not say that it screams craftsman!!

Good luck...I know it's hard....too many choices!! LOL!!

I'm sorry to say that I don't like the lines of either one...I can't put my finger on what it is. I don't know what Craftsman style is either so I'm not sure if they qualify.

Here is one transitional style that I was considering before...Selection 25 Eiffel faucet:
{{gwi:1390703}}

I also googled "craftsman" bath and found this photo:
{{gwi:1396074}}

redroze - I really like that Eiffel faucet! I cant seem to find anywhere to buy it online. Do you know who sells it?

Ok so Ive looked at some other faucets and have narrowed it down. I dont want to spend a fortune, kind of mid range.

Everything would be in polished chrome. We got the Hansgrohe Raindance fixtures for the shower already.

Roman Tub & Widespread Lavatory faucet sets....

JADO Illume

TOTO Clayton

MICO Wilson

HANSGROHE Limbo

Anything stand out? I know its kind of a personal preference thing, but I have the worst time making decisions and I appreciate any feedback :)

twogirls, I like the Green Tea, but it really doesn't go with a craftsman style. THE Mico has a better look, imo, but I can't say anything about quality...I know nothing about them. We are ordering the Delta Dryden in polished chrome for our family bath. I think the lines might work nicely with craftsman style.

Here is a link that might be useful: Delta Dryden

It's from Selection 25 (a brand I never heard of before) and I've seen this brand at a kitchen and bath store in Toronto, Canada called Taps. So sorry, I don't know where to find it online or in the US. On their website it turns out that they're a Canadian company. If you're still interested, perhaps you can contact them? Here's the website.

I LOVE your new selections though...again, since I don't know what Craftsman is, I don't konw which one to recommend. Do you have a photo of your vanity or any other elements in your kitchen? I'd love to try and help.

Also, do you have a tub, and is it oval or rectangular? If you have an oval tub, perhaps a fixture with softer lines (like the Hansgrohe Limbo) would work better, whereas an architectural faucet (the others you narrowed it down to) would work with a more rectangular tub.

Our tub is rectangular and the sinks are either square or rectangular, I cant remember. We went with Kohler Archer for the tub & sinks. I dont have pics of vanities or anything because this is a new build. The vanity is going to be 7 ft long which includes 3" flutes with plinth blocks on each end. I'll probably do a darker stain.

I think Im leaning toward the TOTO Carlyle. Seems to be classic but yet has cleaner lines, not too ornate. I think it might help marry the modern & classic Im going for.

hudson - Thanks for your suggestion! Ive looked at the Delta Dryden before and I think its almost too rigid and boxy for our purposes. The MICO is nice, I just know nothing about that brand.

I like the Limbo a lot better than any of the others, but it's a totally different look. The others are all architectural/modern.