Do you think the tub will interfere with the door? If not I prefer the 2nd layout. A longer vanity is worth moving the tub.

I like the second one if the door is not an issue

Why does the shower not go wall to wall? I'm not loving either of these layouts. Are the exterior dimensions fixed?

Door to the toilet room should really open out.

Thanks krmarchese and chispa. I want to make sure that the tub doesn't interfere with the door/walkway.

Chispa, the shower actually will go all the way to the wall, sorry that the drawing is confusing.

Now I'm thinking of just moving the tub down to the corner or maybe angling is slightly like in these layouts below. But will it look odd?

can you get a corner tub?

I was thinking about a corner tub last night and actually getting excited about it...then I read that they're considered "out," use a lot of hot water, and kind of expensive. So now I'm leaning toward the freestanding tub again.

Re Chispas comment, where I live, toilet room door has to open out per code.

If you can't change the footprint, then the slightly angled tub will look fine.

Do you need a tub in this bathroom?

Chispa, thanks for the reassurance.

I definitely don't need a tub, but DH loves to take baths, so...

I was originally really excited about the look of the tub under the windows, but I think I can make the slightly angled tub work.

Any decorating ideas to make it look more balanced with the window on one side of tub and blank wall on the other?

Can you make your bathroom door a pocket door? Seems like it's going to get in the way of the other door outside of your bathroom.

I was going to say just move it straight down so I'm glad you made that an option. More modern that way. Don't get a corner tub. Don't waste space by making that tub angled. With it in the corner, you can put a small (not sure how long that wall space would be right there) shelf there for holding a candle, bubble bath, glass of wine, etc.

Good call mark_rachel. I hadn't noticed that before, but the bathroom door would probably be open most of the time so it would block the closet door. I'll talk the the contractor about a pocket door.

Thanks ck_squared! I'm actually going for a more traditional look as the house is from 1905 so maybe the angled would work. I do like the idea of a shelf.

Thanks sjhockeyfan, I'll check with my architect about the toilet door.